Fulcrum BioEnergy, a Pleasanton, California-based waste-to-fuel company, filed chapter 11 on September 9, 2024 in the U.S. Bankruptcy Court, District of Delaware. Public reporting said the company had obligations to more than 200 creditors totaling over $456 million.
Fulcrum BioEnergy, Inc.; Fulcrum Sierra BioFuels, LLC; Fulcrum Sierra Finance Company, LLC; Fulcrum Sierra Holdings, LLC
Court
U.S. Bankruptcy Court, District of Delaware
Case Number
24-12008
Judge
Hon. Thomas M. Horan
Petition Date
September 9, 2024
Confirmation Date
April 14, 2025
Effective Date
May 5, 2025
Plan Type
Plan of liquidation with a liquidation trust
Reported Obligations
More than $456 million
Reported Equity Raised
More than $500 million
Nevada Bond Support
About $290 million in environmental improvement revenue bonds
DIP Facility
$5 million from Switch Ltd.
Stalking Horse Bid
$15 million from Switch Ltd.
Biorefinery Sale Buyer
Switch Ltd.
Feedstock Sale Buyer
Refuse, Inc. (WM subsidiary)
Liquidation Trustee
Wilmington Savings Fund Society, FSB
Case Snapshot
363 Sale Process and Liquidation Plan
DIP financing and cash collateral. The DIP Motion described a facility of up to $5 million, with $3,204,103 stated as available on an interim basis and a 10% PIK interest rate that capitalized monthly. The DIP note matured at the earliest of 80 days after the petition date, 30 days after the petition date if a final order was not entered, a sale closing, substantial consummation of a plan, or acceleration of the DIP note. Milestones called for a motion to approve bidding procedures within two days, an interim order within three days, a bidding procedures order within 30 days, a final DIP order within 30 days, an auction within 60 days, a sale approval order within 65 days, and a sale closing within 80 days.
Budgeting used a rolling 13-week forecast with a 15% permitted variance for disbursements and receipts and a biweekly budget submission cadence. The Final DIP Order granted priming DIP liens over certain prepetition bond liens and provided adequate protection liens and claims, subject to a carve-out for statutory fees, a $25,000 chapter 7 trustee carve-out, and a $250,000 post-trigger professional fee cap. Termination events included milestone failures, conversion to chapter 7, appointment of a trustee or examiner, and environmental diligence outcomes tied to a Phase II assessment and purchase price adjustment concepts.
An Amended Final DIP Order added a Prepetition Lender Estate Fund Carveout funded from BioFuels sale proceeds equal to 16% of the excess distributed to BioFuels bondholders above $15.6 million, with 25% of that carveout payable to the committee's investment banker if its work produced a successful or back-up bidder. The same provision referenced a $50,000 initial broker fee and an additional $92,500 for committee professionals. The amended order also provided that BioFuels bondholders could vote unsecured deficiency claims but would not receive plan or trust distributions on account of those deficiency claims, while guarantee claims against Fulcrum BioEnergy, Inc. were not limited.
Sale process and asset dispositions. The court entered a Bidding Procedures Order in October 2024, designating Switch as stalking horse bidder, set a November 4 bid deadline, a November 7 auction, and a November 12 sale hearing. The Sale Motion described stalking horse terms including a $600,000 break-up fee, a $1,500,000 good faith deposit, and a $250,000 minimum bid increment. DSI marketed the assets, including the biorefinery, a feedstock processing facility on 10 acres, agreements with NV Energy and local water suppliers, and a portfolio of U.S. and international patents, along with equity in UK-based subsidiaries.
The auction ran 57 rounds, and the successful bids were $55 million for the biorefinery assets and $3 million for the feedstock processing facility. The Biorefinery Sale Order allowed Switch to credit bid DIP obligations of $5,073,551.95 and directed cash proceeds to a segregated account for prepetition BioFuels bond obligations. The Feedstock Sale Order included typical section 363(m) good-faith findings. Other transactions included a $900,000 Catalyst Sale to Johnson Matthey, a $10 million Agent Credit Bid Sale of parent assets to the prepetition agent against a claim of at least $112,058,488, and a $325,000 UK Share Sale to Northpointe Energy, with proceeds applied to the agent claim before distributions under the plan. The characterized the credit bid sale as a 9% recovery for Class 2A holders.
Case timeline (selected).
Date
Event
2024-09-10
chapter 11 petitions filed
2024-09-11
First day declaration filed
2024-09-11
DIP financing motion filed
2024-09-12
Interim DIP/cash collateral order entered
2024-10-10
Final DIP/cash collateral order entered
2024-10-11
Bidding procedures order entered
2024-10-16
Amended final DIP/cash collateral order entered
2024-11-07
Auction held
2024-11-14
Biorefinery and feedstock sales approved
2025-01-15
Catalyst sale approved ($900,000)
2025-01-17
Agent credit bid sale order entered ($10 million)
2025-02-03
Disclosure statement filed
2025-04-14
Plan confirmed
2025-04-24
UK subsidiary share sale approved ($325,000)
2025-05-05
Effective date occurred
2025-10-27
Motion to extend claim objection deadline filed
2025-11-10
Claims and noticing agent changed
Plan confirmation and liquidation trust. The court's Confirmation Order confirmed a Plan of Liquidation on April 14, 2025, and the plan became effective May 5, 2025, establishing a liquidation trust administered by Wilmington Savings Fund Society, FSB. The liquidation trustee was selected by the committee in consultation with the debtors, the BioFuels trustee, and the prepetition agent. The Plan Supplement transferred remaining assets and causes of action to the trust for the benefit of liquidation trust beneficiaries, who are treated as grantors and deemed owners of the trust assets for federal income tax purposes.
The trust may establish a disputed claim reserve for each disputed claim, funded from liquidation trust assets in an amount that approximates the distribution that would be made if the claim were allowed. The trustee can distribute the allowed portion while reserving the disputed portion and can withhold distributions while deciding whether to object to claims. The trust agreement grants the trustee broad authority to administer the wind-down and pursue causes of action, provides that the trustee is entitled to compensation and reimbursement of reasonable documented expenses from trust assets without prior bankruptcy court approval, and requires notice and an opportunity to object for settlements resulting in an allowed claim over $2 million.
Allowed administrative expense claims (excluding fee claims) are payable in cash after the later of allowance and the effective date, subject to an administrative expense claims bar date. The plan funded a professional fees account on the effective date and required fee estimates five days before the anticipated effective date, with final fee applications due 45 days after the effective date and objections generally due 20 days after filing. Priority tax claims can be paid in a lump sum or in installments with section 511 interest over up to five years from the petition date. The liquidation trustee directs the initial distribution date and subsequent distributions, with minimum distribution thresholds for small claims.
The disclosure statement provided estimated recoveries for certain classes, with many listed as unknown because recoveries depend on liquidation trust monetization and final distributable cash.
Class
Estimated allowed amount
High-level treatment
Class 1 (Other Priority Claims)
$15,342
Cash after effective date and allowance
Class 2A (Fulcrum prepetition loan secured)
$102,058,488
Collateral/proceeds and liquidation trust proceeds, with first $1.1 million redirected to Class 4A
Class 2B (Holdings bond secured)
$113,955,468
Delivery of remaining collateral not otherwise released
Class 2C (BioFuels bond secured)
$127,616,691
Delivery of remaining collateral not otherwise released
Class 3A (Fulcrum deficiency)
N/A
Pro rata share of cash, if any, from the Fulcrum liquidation trust account
Class 3B (Holdings deficiency)
$113,955,468
Pro rata share of cash, if any, from the Holdings liquidation trust account
Class 3C (BioFuels deficiency)
$124,710,200
Waives distributions
Class 4A (Fulcrum undersecured/GUC)
$93,863,401
Pro rata share of cash, if any, from the Fulcrum liquidation trust account
Class 4B (Holdings undersecured/GUC)
N/A
Pro rata share of cash, if any, from the Holdings liquidation trust account
Class 4C (BioFuels undersecured/GUC)
$80,863,858
Pro rata share of cash, if any, from the BioFuels liquidation trust account
Class 5 (Interests)
N/A
Cancelled on effective date
Class 3C treatment tied to the amended DIP order, which allowed BioFuels bondholders to vote deficiency claims but barred distributions on account of those deficiency claims.
Release and exculpation mechanics. The plan used a voluntary release opt-out mechanism for voting classes that required parties to check an opt-out box on their ballots to avoid granting releases. The confirmation order approved the release, exculpation, and injunction provisions as binding after notice and an opportunity to opt out.
Confirmation order and post-effective administration. The confirmation order dissolved the creditors' committee on the effective date, made the order immediately enforceable upon entry, and required reserves for Abengoa-related claims using the face amounts listed for Classes 4A and 4C. The liquidation trust moved to extend the claims objection deadline from November 3, 2025 to May 4, 2026, and the court granted the extension.
Claims and noticing agent. Kurtzman Carson Consultants, LLC dba Verita Global served as claims and noticing agent at the start of the cases. A November 2025 order terminated Verita and appointed Donlin, Recano & Company, LLC to maintain the claims register and provide noticing services.
Waste-to-Fuel Process and Plant Shutdown
Business and plant profile. Fulcrum was founded in 2007, and the First Day Declaration describes a process that used gasification and Fischer-Tropsch technologies to convert municipal solid waste into drop-in fuels. Press releases described products that included low-carbon transportation fuels such as sustainable aviation fuel and renewable diesel. The Sierra BioFuels Plant near Reno launched in 2022, received landfill waste, and converted it to synthetic crude oil sent to Marathon Petroleum for refining. Bioenergy Insight described the Nevada site as the first commercial waste-to-sustainable fuel facility in the U.S. and said the company was backed by Waste Management and Marathon Petroleum. The Chemical Engineer reported the facility had a target of about 42 million liters of synthetic crude oil per year and said a February 2023 railcar shipment contained . SAF Investor described the Nevada facility as .
Debtor structure. The chapter 11 cases covered four U.S. entities: Fulcrum BioEnergy, Inc.; Fulcrum Sierra BioFuels, LLC; Fulcrum Sierra Finance Company, LLC; Fulcrum Sierra Holdings, LLC. The First Day Declaration said the parent owned 13 subsidiaries (nine U.S. entities and four international entities), and the international entities did not file and were not obligors on the funded debt.
The First Day Declaration reported about $456.6 million of prepetition funded indebtedness just before the petition date. The declaration said unsecured convertible notes were largely converted into preferred stock on December 31, 2023, leaving a smaller remaining unsecured note. The parent term loan matured December 23, 2023 and the debtors received a bond default notice and acceleration on October 16, 2023. After more than six months in forbearance, the debtors said they lost funding for continued operations and maintenance at the Sierra plant in early May 2024.
Instrument
Borrower
Outstanding principal (approx.)
Notes
Parent prepetition term loan facility
Fulcrum BioEnergy, Inc.
$90,500,000
First lien on substantially all assets of the parent and certain subsidiary guarantors
Filings also described separate BioFuels and Holdings bond stacks with collateral packages including deeds of trust on the Sierra plant, trust estate revenues and accounts, and membership interests.
Largest unsecured creditors. The Voluntary Petition listed the 30 largest unsecured creditors. The top 10 claims were:
Rank
Creditor
Nature
Unsecured claim (approx.)
1
Teachers Insurance and Annuity Association of America
Loan
$39,894,423.00
2
Specialty Welding & Turnarounds, LLC
Trade
$10,524,332.33
3
Rustic Canyon Ventures III LP
Loan
$5,000,000.00
4
Schmueser & Associates, LLC
Trade
$3,219,752.68
5
Aquatech International, LLC
Trade
$2,724,385.62
6
Arvos GmbH (Schmidtsche Schack)
Trade
$2,564,832.19
7
Hogan Lovells
Professional services
$2,270,235.97
8
Spartan Companies 300 LLC
Trade
$2,244,949.65
9
Linde Inc.
Trade
$2,160,214.96
10
Siemens Energy, Inc.
Trade
$1,784,448.77
The list also included Marathon Petroleum at about $858,925 and Waste Management at about $363,293.
Professionals and Fee Procedures
Debtor professionals. The debtors retained Morris, Nichols, Arsht & Tunnell LLP as bankruptcy counsel, with an advance payment retainer of $74,129.45 and hourly rates ranging from $195 for case clerks to $1,695 for partners. Development Specialists, Inc. served as financial advisor and investment banker, with an $80,000 monthly fee cap and hourly rates that included $745 per hour for named personnel; the retention order treated the success fee under section 328 and other compensation under sections 330/331. Kurtzman Carson Consultants, LLC dba Verita Global was appointed claims and noticing agent and also served as administrative advisor; claims agent compensation was allowed under the engagement agreement without fee applications, while administrative advisor fees required court approval, and the papers disclosed a $50,000 prepetition retainer and $30,000 prepayment. The court's interim compensation procedures allowed monthly payment of 80% of fees and 100% of expenses, with quarterly interim fee applications to reconcile holdbacks.
Committee professionals. The unsecured creditors' committee, appointed September 19, 2024, retained Morris James LLP and Eversheds Sutherland as counsel under sections 330/331 with restrictions on contract attorney markups and notice requirements for rate increases; Dundon Advisers as financial advisor with hourly rates up to $960 and non-working travel billed at 50%; and Layer 7 Capital as sale banker with a $50,000 fee plus 25% of the Prepetition Lender Estate Fund Carveout, subject to a successful or back-up bid, while the application described a 4% success fee above the initial stalking horse bid.
Switch provided a $5 million DIP facility that carried 10% PIK interest and milestones tied to the sale process, with the DIP obligations available for credit bid in the asset sale.
Donlin, Recano & Company, LLC serves as the claims and noticing agent. A November 2025 order terminated Kurtzman Carson Consultants, LLC dba Verita Global and appointed Donlin Recano to maintain the claims register for the cases.
Morris James LLP /documents/fe88d667-5ac8-47a6-9de4-a8439716bfae/
Layer 7 Capital /documents/cc370d76-426e-4a3e-9126-b2696bae84a6/
waste-to-fuel company https://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20240918647885/en/Solicitation-for-Bids-of-the-Assets-of-Fulcrum-Sierra-BioFuels-LLC-and-Fulcrum-BioEnergy-Inc.
over $456 million https://www.wastedive.com/news/fulcrum-bioenergy-chapter-11-bankruptcy-nevada/726555/
stopped operating in mid-May 2024 https://cen.acs.org/energy/Fulcrum-BioEnergy-abandons-trashfuel-plant/102/web/2024/06
nitric acid formation that corroded equipment https://www.thechemicalengineer.com/features/why-the-lessons-of-the-fulcrum-fiasco-must-not-be-wasted
Switch Ltd. provided a $5 million DIP loan https://www.law360.com/bankruptcy-authority/articles/1888562/fulcrum-gets-ok-for-5m-ch-11-loan-from-potential-buyer
Switch acquiring the biorefinery https://www.wastedive.com/news/fulcrum-bankruptcy-auction-assets-sold-wm-abengoa/
Marathon Petroleum for refining https://www.argusmedia.com/en/news-and-insights/latest-market-news/2608211-fulcrum-bioenergy-files-for-chapter-11-relief
first commercial waste-to-sustainable fuel facility in the U.S. https://www.bioenergy-news.com/news/fulcrum-bioenergy-files-for-bankruptcy-protection/
$30 million equity investment https://united.mediaroom.com/2015-06-30-United-Airlines-Purchases-Stake-in-Fulcrum-BioEnergy-with-30-Million-Investment
375 million gallon, 10-year offtake agreement https://news.cathaypacific.com/cathay-pacific-invests-in-sustainable-biojet-fuel-developer-171569
up to $500 million in tax-exempt bonds https://www.bondbuyer.com/news/nevada-garbage-to-jet-fuel-project-defaults-indiana-follow-up-on-hold
$600 million in investment and 160 jobs https://www.chicagotribune.com/2024/09/17/gary-officials-environmental-group-react-to-fulcrum-bioenergy-bankruptcy-filing/
exclude plastics-to-fuel projects from Inflation Reduction Act credits https://insideclimatenews.org/news/20112023/fulcrum-gary-indiana-net-zero-jet-fuel/
missed a monthly payment in August 2023 https://www.wastedive.com/news/fulcrum-bioenergy-sierra-biofuels-forbearance-reno-nevada-gary-indiana/698991/
This article was researched and written with AI assistance, using court records and news sources. AI-generated content can contain errors. Verify all information against primary sources before relying on it. This is not legal or financial advice. See the disclaimer.