Coking Coal winds down after $4.5 million credit-bid sale to Cumberland Coal as records dispute and final fees remain open - ElevenFlo
Lead Debtor: Coking Coal, LLC
Ch. 11Filed24-70529·E.D. Ky.·Judge Gregory R. Schaaf
Coking Coal winds down after $4.5 million credit-bid sale to Cumberland Coal as records dispute and final fees remain open
ElevenFlo ·
Coking Coal sold substantially all assets to Cumberland Coal Corporation under a July 16, 2025 sale order, and an August 21, 2025 interim order found cause to dismiss but holds the dismissal order until the debtor certifies its wind-down is complete Dkt. 554. Still open are a continued dispute over the debtor's old records and debtor's counsel's final fee application, where Tacora Capital objected to the proposed order ahead of a November 19, 2026 hearing Dkt. 654.
Tacora Capital, the prepetition lender, financed the case. The sale consideration was a $4.5 million credit bid of postpetition obligations, $637,500 in escrowed cash for disputed coal and up to $1.55 million in contingent payments for unsecured creditors.
Coking Coal, LLC, a metallurgical coal producer based in Norton, Virginia, filed chapter 11 in the Eastern District of Kentucky on December 16, 2024 Dkt. 1. It sold substantially all of its assets to Cumberland Coal Corporation under a sale order entered July 16, 2025, after an auction that concluded April 30, 2025 Dkt. 521. On August 21, 2025 the court entered an interim order finding cause to dismiss the case under sections 1112(b) and 105(a) and overruling all unresolved objections Dkt. 554. The dismissal order itself will be entered only after the debtor certifies that a list of wind-down tasks is complete and that the creditors' committee and Tacora agree the case is ready to be dismissed.
Two matters were active on the docket in October and November 2026. The first is a dispute over the debtor's old electronic records. The debtor asked to abandon and destroy them, Ascentia, Inc. and Cumberland moved to enforce the sale order and the debtor's governance documents, and the court continued the October 22, 2026 hearing without a ruling Dkt. 649. The second is the final fee application of debtor's counsel Dinsmore & Shohl LLP, filed October 28, 2026 Dkt. 652. Tacora objected to the form of the proposed fee order on November 16, 2026 Dkt. 654. The application sets a November 19, 2026 hearing if objections are filed, and Ascentia has asked to appear by telephone at a hearing that day Dkt. 655.
Dismissal waits on a certification that the wind-down is complete
On July 31, 2025 the debtor moved to dismiss the case rather than convert it to chapter 7. It argued that a trustee would add cost and delay for little added recovery Dkt. 533. The motion referred to August 15, 2025 bar dates for general, governmental and administrative claims. It listed the remaining work as fee applications, reconciliation of administrative claims and disputed collateral. On August 20, 2025 the committee moved to create an ad hoc committee of creditors to administer the contingent unsecured-creditor payments after dismissal Dkt. 549.
The August 21, 2025 interim order grants the motion subject to a final order Dkt. 554. The debtor may file its certification requesting dismissal once these conditions are met:
all monthly operating reports are filed and all U.S. Trustee quarterly fees are paid;
professional fees and expenses approved on a final basis are paid in full;
the reconciliation of administrative claims is concluded, and allowed administrative and priority claims are paid;
the adversary proceeding ACIN LLC v. American Resources Insurance Company is closed or remanded;
any litigation over ownership of the disputed coal is concluded;
any challenge to the committee's ad hoc committee motion is resolved; and
any adversary proceeding or collection action by Tacora over amounts due under the DIP orders or the sale order is concluded.
The order also sends unspent DIP money to the buyer. DIP funds the debtor had not spent by the closing date became an acquired asset of the purchaser. The purchaser is to use them, at the debtor's direction, to pay allowed administrative claims and its own obligations under the sale order and asset purchase agreement. The debtor's general counsel, John Osborne, keeps authority to sign estate documents until all acquired assets have transferred. He may also direct the buyer to pay allowed administrative claims without further order. He is exculpated for good-faith acts, except for fraud, gross negligence, bad faith, breach of fiduciary duty or willful misconduct. Operating reports and U.S. Trustee fees continue until the case is dismissed.
The debtor's operating report for September 2025 was filed October 28, 2026. It reports $1,233,176 of third-quarter 2025 disbursements: $1,061,224 in August and $171,952 in September Dkt. 651. After the sale closed, the debtor's checking accounts were closed and its accounting staff's employment ended. Cumberland became responsible for unpaid pre-closing operating expenses. Funds for outstanding administrative fees, including U.S. Trustee fees and debtor's counsel's final fees, were deposited with Cumberland under the interim order. They are to be paid once those amounts are calculated or approved.
The open contest is over the debtor's old email and data
In October 2026 the debtor moved for authority to abandon and securely destroy certain records, and to set a deadline for objections or proposals for another disposition. Ascentia, Inc. and Cumberland separately moved to enforce the sale order and the debtor's corporate governance documents. The court set both motions for hearing on October 22, 2026 Dkt. 642.
Tacora objected to destruction and cross-moved for preservation Dkt. 641. It says the unreviewed records include historical email and other Outlook data of former officers and directors. It contends some of those records were sold to Cumberland under the sale order and may be relevant to pending civil litigation. Tacora argues that abandonment does not authorize destruction and that the records may not be estate property. Under its protocol, Digital Forensic Services would hold the records at Tacora's cost. No one could access their contents without the written agreement of Tacora, Cumberland and Ascentia or a court order, and preservation duties would continue after dismissal.
James Chisholm and Lloyd Hill oppose both destruction and wholesale turnover Dkt. 640. Hill gave the debtor's first-day declaration Dkt. 35 · p. 20. They describe the data as an unreviewed, intermingled export that holds records and potentially privileged communications of several entities and individuals. They do not oppose Cumberland receiving identifiable, nonprivileged Coking Coal records it bought. They argue, however, that neither the sale order nor an Australian assignment deed entitles the movants to the entire export Dkt. 643. Their alternative would send one hashed copy to an independent neutral custodian for an initial 12 months, with no review or access absent a court order or agreement. They would pay the costs, not the estate.
The minutes of the October 22, 2026 hearing on the enforcement motion record that the hearing was continued and that no ruling was made Dkt. 649. The sale order reserves to the court exclusive jurisdiction to enforce the asset purchase agreement Dkt. 521.
Tacora's DIP terms still govern how wind-down costs are paid
Dinsmore's application seeks final allowance of $47,443.00 in fees and $368.10 in expenses for September 16, 2025 through October 16, 2026. It also seeks final allowance of amounts previously allowed on an interim basis Dkt. 652. It asks to apply escrowed funds to the allowed amounts, with the debtor or its successor to pay any unpaid balance. The post-closing work it describes covers mining-permit transfers, final administrative expenses and reports, a proposed fund for unsecured creditors and the records dispute. Objections were due November 18, 2026.
Tacora's November 16 objection does not challenge the fees or expenses Dkt. 654. It asks that any order preserve the DIP orders' limits on funding professional fees and provide that the DIP orders control in a conflict. It also asks that the order leave untouched Tacora's potential claims against Dinsmore or its lawyers over prepetition conduct or matters unrelated to case administration. Tacora says allowance under section 330 does not expand its funding obligations. It puts the total final allowance at about $767,301.78 and expects to submit an agreed order if the two sides settle the language. Payment in full of finally approved professional fees is one of the conditions to dismissal.
Tacora is also collecting collateral that the final DIP order had set aside. Under an agreed order entered October 26, 2026, Central Bank & Trust Co. may reimburse itself $16,013.20 in fees and costs from certificates of deposit that secured letters of credit. It must then wire the remaining balance, about $119,646.74, to Tacora within five business days Dkt. 650. The certificates held $135,659.94 on October 8, 2026. The final DIP order had excluded them from DIP collateral pending further determination. Central Bank had obtained stay relief by agreed order on April 4, 2025 Dkt. 349.
Dinsmore & Shohl LLP is debtor's counsel. Hamilton Law Offices, PLLC was approved as conflicts and special counsel on an interim basis on January 28, 2025 Dkt. 287. Epiq is claims and noticing agent, and the June 2025 DIP budget carried $205,000 for Epiq Dkt. 450. Bailey & Glasser LLP represents Tacora.
Tacora lent new money only, and the DIP cap rose from $4.5 million to $8.9 million as the sale ran long
Tacora Capital LP held the prepetition first-lien loan and provided the DIP facility. The interim order of December 20, 2024 limited draws to $1.5 million Dkt. 112 · p. 7. It imposed a rolling 13-week budget with weekly variance reporting and gave the lender approval rights over budget updates and material deviations.
The final hearing slipped while the debtor negotiated with objectors. DIP objections came from the INMET Mining liquidating trust, Continental Heritage Insurance, Central Bank & Trust, Panorama Equipment Leasing, Marco International and John Deere Dkt. 269. The debtor's January 13, 2025 status report said cash on hand would last until January 23, 2025 Dkt. 219. By January 22 the debtor had signed about 27 stipulations extending objection deadlines.
The final order, entered February 12, 2025, approved a $4.5 million non-revolving facility at 13.5% a year, the same rate for contract and default Dkt. 315. The DIP loan agreement attached to the motion had referenced a 17.5% contract rate with a 6% default premium Dkt. 35. The final order reaffirmed Tacora's prepetition claim as allowed in an amount not less than $41,837,445.46 Dkt. 315 · p. 3. Neither DIP order provides a roll-up. DIP proceeds pay budgeted expenses and facility charges, and the prepetition claim stays separate.
The final order gave Tacora first-priority priming liens on DIP collateral, excluding avoidance actions, and superpriority administrative claims. Several third-party interests stayed ahead of the DIP liens or outside them. Liens of Kentucky Utilities, ACIN's liens on its senior collateral and John Deere's purchase-money liens on specific equipment remain senior. Marco-owned coal, true-leased Panorama equipment, Continental Heritage funds and Central Bank certificates of deposit were excluded from DIP collateral pending further determination.
The sale took longer than the DIP milestones assumed. On April 15, 2025 the debtor asked to raise the cap to $6.019 million and extend the budget through May 30, 2025. The money would keep the mines in "hot idle" and fund payroll and professional fees while the auction moved to April 30 Dkt. 362. The court granted the motion on April 17 Dkt. 377. The next day it entered an amended order setting the cap at $6.049 million Dkt. 382 · p. 2. The amended budget projected a cumulative cash deficit of $1,549,000 for the six weeks to May 30 .
On June 6 the debtor sought to raise the cap to $8.9 million through the earlier of closing or August 22, 2025, with an added $250,000 carve-out for debtor's counsel and the claims agent Dkt. 430. On June 11 the court granted that motion on a limited basis, authorizing weekly Friday draws against an amended budget through June 26, 2025 Dkt. 450. The committee objected. It withdrew the objection on June 25 after reaching an agreement in principle with the debtor and Tacora tied to the proposed sale order Dkt. 472. An agreed order entered July 18, 2025 raised the cap to $8.9 million . A July 21 stipulation adopted a new budget that added the committee's agreed carve-out and forecast $52,000 of cash on August 22, 2025 .
Tacora's authorized DIP borrowing rose from $4.5 million at the final order to $8.9 million by July 2025Borrowing limit set by each order. Not shown: the April 17, 2025 order's $6.019 million cap, which was replaced the next day, and the June 11, 2025 limited-basis order, which authorized weekly draws without setting a new cap.
$1.5M
$4.5M
$6.049M
$8.9M
Interim DIP order
Final DIP order
Amended order on first amendment
Agreed order on second amendment
Show the numbers
Cumberland paid with a $4.5 million credit bid, $637,500 in escrowed cash and an earn-out of up to $1.55 million for unsecured creditors
The sale followed the usual section 363 structure of a stalking-horse bid, an auction and a sale hearing goodwinlaw.com: section 363 sale (outside source, not verified by ElevenFlo). The December 30, 2024 sale motion proposed Black Energy Corp. as stalking-horse bidder Dkt. 133. By January 22, 2025, 11 parties had objected to the proposed procedures Dkt. 269. They included Kentucky Utilities, Penn Virginia, Natural Resource Partners and ACIN, Marco International, insurers Continental Heritage and Indemnity National, and Alpha Metallurgical Coal Sales. The debtor was working through questions about the proposed stalking-horse bid.
The bidding procedures order of February 7, 2025 required a 25% cash deposit and $25,000 minimum overbids Dkt. 311. It set a March 5 bid deadline, an April 4 auction and an April 17 sale hearing. It let the debtor designate a stalking horse by February 12, subject to approval by Tacora and the committee. Tacora was deemed a qualified bidder with the right to credit bid its prepetition and postpetition obligations. Bidders had to take transfer of the mining permits, assume reclamation obligations and pay regulatory fees, including Kentucky Reclamation Guaranty Fund arrearages. They also had to replace reclamation and financial assurance bonds and could not be permit-blocked under the Surface Mining Control and Reclamation Act. The auction was continued to April 14 and then to April 30 Dkt. 362. It was held on April 30, and a prevailing bidder was selected Dkt. 430.
The sale order, entered July 16, 2025, names Cumberland Coal Corporation as purchaser Dkt. 521. The consideration was a $4.5 million credit bid of postpetition obligations, $637,500 in cash at closing for "Marco Coal" and the unsecured-creditor settlement below. Wilmington Trust holds the coal cash in escrow pending resolution of ownership disputes among Tacora, Marco International, AM Futures and ACIN.
Unsecured-creditor settlement in the sale order, capped at $1.55 million
Component
Maximum
Terms
Supplemental carve-out
$100,000
Paid at closing for committee professional fees, with any unused amount going to general unsecured creditors
Tranche 1
$1,150,000
$1.00 per metric ton in months when production exceeds 75,000 tons at a price of at least $200 per ton
The earn-out runs for 36 months, with quarterly reporting and payment calculations. The purchaser has no obligation to take steps to meet the thresholds, so the payout depends on how Cumberland runs the mines and on coal prices. Cumberland also took derivative standing to pursue chapter 5 avoidance actions but agreed not to pursue them against non-insider general unsecured creditors.
Contract and lease treatment under the sale order
Counterparty
Treatment
Terms
Norfolk Southern
Assumed and assigned
$540,000 cure: $300,000 by December 31, 2025, then eight quarterly payments of $30,000
Howard Engineering
Assumed and assigned
$352,943.05 liquidated cure paid at closing
The order approves the sale free and clear of liens, claims and interests under section 363(f), with those interests attaching to the proceeds. It finds Cumberland a good-faith purchaser under section 363(m) and gives broad protection against successor, vicarious and transferee liability. The sale is not exempt from stamp or transfer taxes under section 1146(a), and Cumberland pays them. The 14-day stays under Bankruptcy Rules 6004(h) and 6006(d) were waived. The court kept exclusive jurisdiction over disputes about the escrowed coal proceeds.
The debtor stays permittee of record until Cumberland's permit transfers are final
The sale order requires Cumberland to apply for permit transfers within 15 business days of closing Dkt. 521. Until the final transfer date the debtor remains permittee of record. Meanwhile Cumberland operates as designated operator and indemnifies the debtor for post-closing violations. Cumberland must obtain replacement permits and surety bonds. Continental Heritage Insurance Company holds $2,520,301.33 of collateral that will secure Cumberland's replacement bonds once the existing bonds are released. Dinsmore's final fee application lists mining-permit transfers among its post-closing work Dkt. 652.
Tacora's $41.8 million loan is the only funded debt identified
Tacora held senior secured, first-priority claims against Coking Coal and liens on its assets. They arose under a credit agreement, security agreement and promissory note dated January 26, 2024. The DIP motion puts the amount owed at approximately $41,837,445.46 on the petition date Dkt. 35 · p. 20. Both DIP orders treat it as an allowed claim of not less than that amount Dkt. 112 · p. 3. The filings do not inventory every funded instrument, so this figure is the identified funded debt rather than a total.
The DIP motion reports approximately $121 million of liabilities, of which approximately $41.8 million is the Tacora debt. It says the debtor also owes approximately $44.2 million to AHL under an intercompany loan Dkt. 35 · p. 20. The intercompany loan is not funded debt. The first-day declaration estimated unsecured trade debt at approximately $21.34 million as of December 11, 2024 Dkt. 36.
Petition-date obligations reported in the first-day filings
Obligation
Amount
Treatment
Tacora prepetition loan (January 26, 2024)
$41,837,445.46
Senior secured, first priority; allowed claim of not less than this amount under the DIP orders
AHL intercompany loan
Approximately $44.2 million
Intercompany; not funded debt
Other parties asserted liens on, or ownership of, particular assets. They included equipment lessors and vendors, Kentucky Utilities, ACIN, John Deere, Marco and Central Bank, and the final DIP order protected or carved out their interests. The committee had 30 days after the final DIP order to challenge Tacora's prepetition liens and claims, with derivative standing and a $75,000 investigation budget Dkt. 315. General unsecured creditors look to the sale order's settlement, not a plan distribution, for their recovery.
Falling prices, mine problems and export disruptions preceded the filing
The first-day declaration describes Coking Coal as a producer of high-volatility bituminous metallurgical coal sold under the "Black Bear" brand Dkt. 36. Its main property was the Coking Coal Complex near Norton, Virginia. The complex covers about 49,300 acres and comprises the Pardee and Pigeon Creek complexes, with underground mines in Kentucky and Virginia. Two coal handling and preparation plants had combined capacity of about 2,150 tons per hour. An April 2024 independent appraisal valued the plants and related equipment in the nine figures. The company cited about 348 million tons of coal reserves. Customers included ArcelorMittal S.A. and Zentralkokerei Saar GmbH, and exports moved on Norfolk Southern rail through the Port of Baltimore. The debtor had about 49 employees at filing, down from about 150, and was considering furloughs of about 19 more.
The filings cite these causes of distress:
metallurgical coal prices well below 2022 levels;
equipment and operating problems at the Pigeon Creek complex, and customer penalties for production and quality shortfalls;
logistics disruption and demurrage costs after the Francis Scott Key Bridge collapse in Baltimore;
damage from Hurricane Helene;
unsuccessful efforts to raise capital in 2024 and covenant pressure under the Tacora facility; and
litigation by the Blackjewel Liquidation Trust over the debtor's acquisition of the Pardee Complex, with a claimed amount of about $2.07 million.
U.S. metallurgical coal is an export business, and regional prices fell by half between 2022 and 2024