RAD Diversified REIT seeks December 17 confirmation of liquidation plan projecting 9.7% recovery for unsecured creditors
ElevenFlo ·
Ballots on the debtors' Joint Second Amended Plan of Liquidation must be received by December 10, 2026 at 5:00 p.m. ET Dkt. 1220 · p. 23. The court's October 14 conditional approval order sets the hearing on final disclosure-statement approval and confirmation for December 17 at 3:30 p.m. Dkt. 1269. The debtors estimate that general unsecured creditors would recover 9.7% through a liquidating trust, against 7.3% in chapter 7 Dkt. 1220 · p. 65.
Jump to section
The debtors' Joint Second Amended Plan of Liquidation would move the remaining rental houses and the estates' claims against insiders and advisers into a liquidating trust. In the meantime, Pennsylvania properties are still being auctioned or released to lenders.
The 9.7% figure is an estimate that rests on three open questions. The first is what the remaining houses sell for. The second is how much of the $147.6 million of general unsecured claims in the analysis is allowed. The third is whether the court substantively consolidates the six estates. The liquidation analysis gives the estates' lawsuits against insiders and third parties no value, so any net recovery on those claims is not in the figure Dkt. 1220 · p. 65.
RAD Diversified REIT, Inc. and four affiliates filed chapter 11 on March 1, 2026 in the U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the Middle District of Florida, Tampa Division. The Seminar Solution, LLC followed on September 4, 2026 Dkt. 1220 · p. 16. The six cases are jointly administered under the REIT's case, No. 8:26-bk-01636 Dkt. 1086. The plan, dated October 5, 2026, would create a liquidating trust to sell the remaining assets, resolve disputed claims and pay creditors Dkt. 1220 · p. 8. The debtors and the creditors' committee recommend that creditors accept it Dkt. 1220.
The plan is not confirmed. The October 14 amended order conditionally approved the disclosure statement. It set a combined hearing on final approval and confirmation for December 17 in Courtroom 8B of the Sam M. Gibbons U.S. Courthouse in Tampa Dkt. 1269. The court can adjourn that hearing by announcing it in open court, with no further notice Dkt. 1269 · p. 2.
Unsecured creditors are estimated at 9.7% under the plan, against 7.3% in chapter 7
The disclosure statement's liquidation analysis compares the plan with a chapter 7 liquidation. It calls every figure an estimate or modeling assumption, not an appraisal or guarantee Dkt. 1220 · p. 65. In both scenarios it assumes property sells for about 75% of estimated value. The plan scenario also assumes substantive consolidation. The debtors say chapter 7 would add professional and administrative costs Dkt. 1220.
| Item | Chapter 11 plan | Chapter 7 |
|---|---|---|
| Net available for distribution | $14,286,852 | $10,674,600 |
| General unsecured claims pool | $147,595,598 | $147,050,679 |
| Estimated general unsecured recovery | 9.7% | 7.3% |
The plan summary table lists Class 1 and 2 recoveries as varying, Class 9 recoveries as to be determined and equity at 0% Dkt. 1220 · p. 8. The debtors warn that actual values, costs, claim amounts, priorities and timing may differ materially Dkt. 1220.
Secured lenders choose a sale or their collateral, and investor securities claims rank behind general unsecured creditors
| Class | Claims | Treatment | Votes? |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | First mortgage secured claims, one subclass per loan | Holder elects either a sale of all its collateral by the trust, with the trust first keeping a surcharge from the proceeds, or surrender of the collateral. Surrender is unavailable if the collateral is worth more than the claim Dkt. 1220 · pp. 28, 29 | Yes Dkt. 1220 · p. 29 |
| 2 | Judgment lien claims | At the holder's option, sale or surrender of collateral the trust designates, unless the claim is paid in full. The trust chooses which parcels Dkt. 1220 · pp. 29, 30 | Yes Dkt. 1220 · p. 30 |
| 3 | Municipal lien claims | Paid in full from sale proceeds after the surcharge, or lien retained if the property is surrendered Dkt. 1220 · p. 31 | Yes Dkt. 1220 · p. 32 |
| 4 | Other secured claims | Paid in full, given the collateral, or other agreed treatment Dkt. 1220 · p. 32 | No, deemed to accept Dkt. 1220 · p. 32 |
| 5 | Priority non-tax claims | Paid in cash Dkt. 1220 · p. 32 | No, deemed to accept Dkt. 1220 · p. 33 |
| 6 | General unsecured claims | Pro rata Class A beneficial interests in the liquidating trust Dkt. 1220 · p. 33 | Yes Dkt. 1220 · p. 33 |
| 7 | Claims subordinated under section 510(b) | Pro rata Class B beneficial interests, paid only after allowed claims in Classes 1 to 6 are paid in full Dkt. 1220 · pp. 33, 34 | Yes Dkt. 1220 · p. 34 |
| 8 | Intercompany claims | Cancelled, no distribution Dkt. 1220 · p. 34 | No, deemed to reject Dkt. 1220 · p. 34 |
| 9 | Government agency and regulatory claims, one subclass per agency | Class B beneficial interests, ranking equally with Class 7 and behind Class A. Nothing is paid until allowed Class 6 claims are paid in full Dkt. 1220 · pp. 34, 35 | Yes, each subclass Dkt. 1220 · p. 35 |
| 10 | Equity interests | Cancelled, no recovery Dkt. 1220 · p. 35 | No, deemed to reject Dkt. 1220 · p. 35 |
Section 510(b) of the Bankruptcy Code generally subordinates claims for damages arising from the purchase or sale of a debtor's securities. The disclosure statement warns that an investor's treatment does not turn only on the title of the investment agreement. It may depend on the governing agreement, the contracting entity, the amounts invested and repaid, and whether any lien was properly created and perfected Dkt. 1220 · p. 13.
The plan asks the court to substantively consolidate all of the debtors. Their assets and liabilities would be pooled into a single estate for plan purposes, and secured claims would keep their collateral. If the court declines, the plan becomes a separate sub-plan for each debtor Dkt. 1220 · p. 40. Until the court orders consolidation after notice and a hearing, the joint administration order bars commingling of the debtors' assets and liabilities Dkt. 1086. The 9.7% estimate assumes consolidation. Without it, each creditor would recover under the sub-plan of the debtor that owes it.
Only Classes 1, 2, 3, 6, 7 and 9 vote, and ballots must arrive by December 10
Only holders of claims in Classes 1, 2, 3, 6, 7 and 9 may vote, along with holders whose claims are temporarily allowed for voting under Bankruptcy Rule 3018(a) Dkt. 1220 · p. 23. Holders in Classes 4, 5, 8 and 10 do not vote Dkt. 1220 · p. 24.
A ballot counts only if it is completed, signed and received by December 10, 2026 at 5:00 p.m. prevailing Eastern Time Dkt. 1220 · p. 23. The disclosure statement directs ballots to Epiq, the balloting agent. They can go by first class mail, by hand or overnight delivery, or through Epiq's electronic balloting service Dkt. 1220 · p. 23. The court's conditional approval order separately lists court submission routes and requires ballots at least seven days before the hearing Dkt. 1269 · p. 2. Follow the return instructions printed on the ballot you received.
Fax and email ballots do not count, except through the electronic balloting service. A ballot for a disputed, contingent or zero-amount claim counts only if a Rule 3018(a) motion is filed by December 10 Dkt. 1220 · pp. 9, 24. A submitted vote cannot be changed without a court order Dkt. 1220 · p. 23. A class accepts if more than half in number and two-thirds in dollar amount of the claims voting in it accept. A creditor who does not vote, or votes to reject, still receives any distribution it is entitled to if the plan is confirmed Dkt. 1220 · p. 24.
The Contributed Claim election is irrevocable and separate from the vote
Some ballots include a separate, voluntary election to contribute the holder's own claims against third parties to the liquidating trust. It does not change how the vote is counted Dkt. 1220 · p. 23. Contributed Claims are direct claims a creditor holds against non-debtors for harm suffered as a creditor. They include claims over how investments were marketed and sold, alleged misrepresentation of the debtors' finances and alleged concealment of the debtors' conduct. The disclosure statement's example is an investor's claim against Brandon "Dutch" Mendenhall for public misrepresentations that induced the investment. The election excludes the debtors' own derivative claims, claims against the exculpated parties and claims that cannot be assigned Dkt. 1220 · p. 36.
The election is irrevocable and takes effect at the plan's effectiveness. A contributing claimant gives up the right to pursue or recover on the claim separately and cannot direct how the trust handles it. The claimant must also sign documents the trustee reasonably requests Dkt. 1220 · p. 37. The trustee may decide not to pursue a contributed claim. A holder who receives no distribution under the plan cannot benefit from contributing Dkt. 1220 · p. 38. The debtors and the committee believe most claimants will likely benefit from contributing. The debtors also say they cannot recommend a choice for any individual claimant and suggest consulting counsel Dkt. 1220 · pp. 37, 38.
Houses are sold at court-supervised auctions where lenders can credit bid, and each sale needs a second order
A November 7 order authorizes the sale of 11 Philadelphia houses, including 2030 E. Lehigh Ave. and 5166 Viola St., free and clear of liens. The auctioneer is SoldNow, LLC, doing business as Tranzon Driggers Dkt. 1362. Municipal liens must be paid in full at closing, or they survive the sale. Every other lien attaches to the proceeds after the estate's Surcharge Amount is paid, keeping the extent, validity and priority it had on the petition date. A mortgagee may credit bid all or part of its allowed secured claim. If a mortgagee wins, a $1,000 alternative buyer's premium is added to its bid Dkt. 1362.
The order does not approve any buyer or price. The debtors must report auction results within five business days. They must then file a motion to approve the sale and the payout of proceeds, and parties may object to it. The court kept jurisdiction over how the proceeds are paid out Dkt. 1362. A winning bidder needs that second order to close, and lenders are paid from proceeds only under it.
An October auction used the same auctioneer and the same approval step. On October 6 the auctioneers announced that 46 homes in Philadelphia, Chester and Delaware counties would be sold online. Opening bids were $25,000 or $50,000, auctions closed October 13 to 15, and a 10% buyer's premium applied. The properties were sold as-is, buyers were responsible for outstanding real estate taxes, and each sale needed the bankruptcy court's approval prnewswire.com: Tranzon Alderfer to Auction 46 Philadelphia-Area Homes; Bidding Starts at $25,000 (outside source).
One motion to confirm sales and authorize distributions at closing covers 151 Bryn Mawr Ave. in Lansdowne and 3640 Morrell Ave. in Philadelphia. On November 16, Fay Servicing, servicer for the two mortgage holders, said it does not object as long as the agreed amounts are paid. The lenders agreed to limit their secured claims to unpaid principal, escrow advances and corporate advances, and to waive interest and default interest Dkt. 1402.
| Property | Mortgage holder | Agreed secured claim | Interest waived |
|---|---|---|---|
| 151 Bryn Mawr Ave., Lansdowne | Wilmington Savings Fund Society, FSB, as trustee for Ibis Holdings A Trust | $214,540.30 | $100,144.63 |
| 3640 Morrell Ave., Philadelphia | U.S. Bank Trust National Association, as Delaware trustee for Treaty Oak Mortgage Trust | $213,906.67 | $105,956.89 |
Title limits what the estate can sell. On September 24 the court refused to approve a sale of 311 9th St. in Upland, Pa. It found the property was not estate property on the March 1 petition date. The rest of the relief under that sale motion stands Dkt. 1165. The debtors' latest budget projects $100,000 of property-sale revenue in each of the weeks ending November 20, December 4 and December 18 Dkt. 1404.
Lenders are taking back individual properties while rents fund operations
The court's memo from the November 17 hearing records three rulings, each with an order to be submitted. Ten lender motions for relief from the stay on individual properties were granted. A creditor's motion for more time to file a claim was granted. The debtors' cash collateral motion was granted on a final basis. Six adequate-protection or stay-relief motions on Pennsylvania properties were continued to January 5, 2027 at 3:30 p.m. The memo states that it is not an official order of the court Dkt. 1408.
More motions will be heard alongside confirmation. On November 13 the court set December 17 at 3:30 p.m. for preliminary hearings on six stay-relief motions. Toorak Capital Partners LLC filed three and Wilmington Savings Fund Society, FSB filed three. The automatic stay remains in effect until the court rules. Opponents who do not appear risk having their objections treated as waived Dkt. 1384Dkt. 1386Dkt. 1387Dkt. 1385Dkt. 1388Dkt. 1389. On November 9, Wilmington Savings Fund Society, as owner trustee of Atlas SP RESI Opportunity Trust IA, sought relief for 621 Ridge Pike in Lafayette Hill, Pa. The motion alleges that DDH Fund signed a $637,500 note secured by the property. It says the lender bought the property back at a foreclosure auction on October 29, 2025, and that its sheriff's deed was recorded December 1, 2025, before the bankruptcy Dkt. 1370.
Rents are the debtors' only operating revenue. At filing the debtors estimated postpetition collections at about $90,000 a month, and mortgagees with assignment-of-rents clauses claim interests in those rents Dkt. 50. The most recent entered cash collateral order is an interim order of September 22. It allows spending under a five-week budget with a 10% variance on each line. Rents from objecting lenders' properties may be used only for that property's ordinary expenses. Each mortgagee receives a replacement lien on rents from its properties, plus monthly reports Dkt. 1156. The debtors' sixth budget supplement, filed November 17, projects ending cash falling from $154,340 in the week ending November 13 to $113,765 in the week ending December 25 Dkt. 1404.
The trust would pursue insiders and advisers, and The Seminar Solution reports no assets
When the plan becomes effective, the trust would receive the debtors' cash, insider claims and claims against directors and officers. It would also receive related claims against third parties, including professionals, as well as retained causes of action and any Contributed Claims Dkt. 1220 · p. 36. The liquidating trustee will be named in the plan supplement due December 10 Dkt. 1220 · pp. 38, 9.
The Seminar Solution ran the group's educational and consulting programs, including the Inner Circle membership program Dkt. 1220 · p. 13. The SEC alleges that about $54 million of investor funds was diverted to it Dkt. 1405 · p. 94. In October, Bisnow, citing the Tampa Bay Business Journal, reported that bankruptcy officials had traced at least $38.5 million to it bisnow.com: Properties Owned By REIT Accused Of Fraud To Be Auctioned Off (outside source). Its October operating report shows no assets and $0 cash. Against that it lists $57,100 of prepetition secured debt and $38,396,546 of prepetition unsecured debt Dkt. 1420. So any recovery of money that passed through The Seminar Solution would have to come from claims against whoever received it. The plan assigns those claims to the trust.
Mendenhall's criminal and SEC cases are pending, and he wants the $1 million D&O policy to fund his defense
Mendenhall's motion says the U.S. Attorney for the Middle District of Florida sent him a grand jury target letter on March 10, 2026. It says the government filed an indictment against him on May 27, 2026, in United States v. Mendenhall, No. 8:26-cr-00192 Dkt. 1405 · p. 5. Bisnow reported that the indictment charges one count of mail fraud bisnow.com: Properties Owned By REIT Accused Of Fraud To Be Auctioned Off (outside source). On July 29, 2026 the SEC sued the REIT, Mendenhall and Amy Vaughn in SEC v. Mendenhall, No. 8:26-cv-02186 Dkt. 1405 · p. 5. Bisnow reported that the SEC alleges the REIT raised $152 million from more than 5,500 investors bisnow.com: SEC Charges REIT, Its Founders With Alleged $152M Fraud Scheme (outside source). Both cases are pending, and the charges and claims are allegations.
The SEC complaint is attached to the motion. It alleges that the defendants told investors no one had ever lost money. It alleges that Mendenhall's brother set the REIT's share price rather than independent valuations, and that redemptions were denied before being frozen in February 2024. It also alleges that Mendenhall misappropriated about $2.3 million and Vaughn about $2.5 million Dkt. 1405 · pp. 93, 94.
On November 17 Mendenhall asked the bankruptcy court to confirm that the automatic stay does not stop StarStone Specialty Insurance Company from advancing defense costs to insured persons, including him, under the REIT's directors and officers policy. In the alternative, he asked the court to lift the stay to allow the payments Dkt. 1405 · pp. 1, 2. The motion says the policy has a $1 million limit and that defense costs reduce that limit. It also says StarStone acknowledged coverage subject to a reservation of rights Dkt. 1405 · pp. 2, 5. Because defense costs come out of the same limit, advances for insured persons' defense would shrink the coverage left for the D&O claims the plan transfers to the trust. The plan would assume the debtors' insurance policies Dkt. 1220. The court has not ruled on the motion.
Most of the debtors' obligations trace to individual investors
The debtors are affiliated real estate entities based in Port Richey, Florida. They were formed to buy, renovate, lease and sell property and to provide educational and consulting services. At filing they held more than 300 residential rental properties and vacant lots, mostly in Pennsylvania, Texas and Florida Dkt. 1220 · p. 12. The REIT's petition estimated 5,001 to 10,000 creditors, with assets and liabilities each between $50 million and $100 million Dkt. 1. In October, Bisnow reported that more than 3,200 creditor claims had been filed bisnow.com: Properties Owned By REIT Accused Of Fraud To Be Auctioned Off (outside source).
The REIT raised money under Regulation A and Regulation D offerings. The examiner reported offering materials stating about $73.8 million of gross offering proceeds as of March 15, 2023. That is a historical figure, not cash or net assets on the petition date Dkt. 1220 · p. 13. Investors also used promissory notes, hard-money loans, joint ventures and equity interests, in amounts from about $1,000 to more than $1 million Dkt. 1220 · p. 13. The examiner reported that internal balance sheets at December 31, 2025 showed about $29.8 million of promissory notes, $3.0 million of hard-money loans and $22.1 million of joint-venture equity. These are unaudited historical accounting figures, not petition-date balances. The debtors take no position on their accuracy or on whether any of them is debt rather than equity Dkt. 1220 · p. 14.
In February 2024 the SEC declared the REIT's offering statement abandoned Dkt. 1220 · p. 15Dkt. 3 · p. 11. In July 2025 Florida Attorney General James Uthmeier announced subpoenas and said "this appears to be a Ponzi scheme." Prepetition management disputed that characterization Dkt. 3 · p. 11. The disclosure statement says those matters have not been decided in the chapter 11 cases Dkt. 1220 · p. 15.
Before the filing, founders Mendenhall and Vaughn managed the debtors Dkt. 1220 · p. 13. GGG Partners was engaged on February 20, 2026, with Katie S. Goodman as chief restructuring officer. Michael T. Roye was appointed independent director Dkt. 1220 · pp. 13, 15. The U.S. Trustee formed a nine-member creditors' committee on March 27, 2026, and the court approved Greenberg Traurig as its counsel on June 2 Dkt. 1220 · p. 16. Examiner Maria M. Yip filed an initial report on June 8, 2026 Dkt. 575 · p. 1. It drew on a database of 114,682 transactions from 75 bank accounts Dkt. 575 · p. 7.
Sources
- Dkt. 1RAD Diversified Chapter 11 PetitionFiled Mar 1, 2026Mar 1, 2026
- Dkt. 3Declaration in Support of First Day MotionsCited at p. 11 · Filed Mar 1, 2026Mar 1, 2026
- Dkt. 50Emergency Cash Collateral MotionFiled Mar 8, 2026Mar 8, 2026
- Dkt. 575Examiner's Report on Financial MismanagementFiled Jun 8, 2026Jun 8, 2026
- Dkt. 1086Joint Administration OrderFiled Sep 8, 2026Sep 8, 2026
- Dkt. 1156Cash Collateral OrderFiled Sep 22, 2026Sep 22, 2026
- Dkt. 1165Partial Sale Motion DenialFiled Sep 24, 2026Sep 24, 2026
- Dkt. 1220Proposed Liquidation PlanFiled Oct 5, 2026Oct 5, 2026
- Dkt. 1269Disclosure Approval and DeadlinesFiled Oct 14, 2026Oct 14, 2026
- Dkt. 1362Property Sale AuthorizationFiled Nov 7, 2026Nov 7, 2026
- Dkt. 1370Motion for Stay ReliefFiled Nov 9, 2026Nov 9, 2026
- Dkt. 1384Preliminary Stay HearingFiled Nov 13, 2026Nov 13, 2026
- Dkt. 1385Stay Hearing ScheduledFiled Nov 13, 2026Nov 13, 2026
- Dkt. 1386Stay Motion Hearing OrderFiled Nov 13, 2026Nov 13, 2026
- Dkt. 1387Stay Relief Hearing ScheduledFiled Nov 13, 2026Nov 13, 2026
- Dkt. 1388Stay Relief Hearing ScheduledFiled Nov 13, 2026Nov 13, 2026
- Dkt. 1389Stay Relief Hearing ScheduledFiled Nov 13, 2026Nov 13, 2026
- Dkt. 1402Creditors’ Conditional Non-ObjectionFiled Nov 16, 2026Nov 16, 2026
- Dkt. 1404Sixth Budget SupplementFiled Nov 17, 2026Nov 17, 2026
- Dkt. 1405D&O Defense Cost Stay ReliefFiled Nov 17, 2026Nov 17, 2026
- Dkt. 1408Hearing Proceeding MemoFiled Nov 17, 2026Nov 17, 2026
- Dkt. 1420October Operating ReportFiled Nov 19, 2026Nov 19, 2026
- WebTranzon Alderfer to Auction 46 Philadelphia-Area Homes; Bidding Starts at $25,000prnewswire.com · Outside source
- WebProperties Owned By REIT Accused Of Fraud To Be Auctioned Offbisnow.com · Outside source
- WebSEC Charges REIT, Its Founders With Alleged $152M Fraud Schemebisnow.com · Outside source