American Physician Partners trust's $1.17 million dividend suit draws MagMutual motion to dismiss
ElevenFlo ·
American Physician Partners is in post-effective liquidation under a plan that took effect March 21, 2024 Dkt. 1253. On November 17, 2026, PSIC and three MagMutual entities moved to dismiss the liquidating trust's suit seeking turnover of a $1.17 million policyholder dividend Dkt. 25, arguing the claim is disputed and unripe . The trust's opposition and a ruling are next.
The emergency-department and hospitalist staffing company wound down under a liquidating plan that took effect March 21, 2024. Its liquidating trust now pursues insurance, fiduciary-duty and claims matters.
American Physician Partners, LLC and its affiliated debtors are in post-effective liquidation. The court confirmed their plan of liquidation on March 15, 2024 Dkt. 1131, and the plan took effect on March 21, 2024 Dkt. 1253. That moved the remaining assets and causes of action into a liquidating trust. The trust's most active matter is adversary proceeding 26-50590 against Professional Security Insurance Company (PSIC), MagMutual Insurance Company and two MagMutual holding companies. The revised amended complaint, filed October 22, 2026, seeks turnover of a $1,170,000 policyholder dividend and declarations that the insurers cannot set it off against retrospective premiums Dkt. 20. A stipulated order gave the defendants until November 17, 2026 to respond Dkt. 22. On that date they moved to dismiss. They seek dismissal with prejudice of most counts against MagMutual Insurance Company and, in the alternative, dismissal of the whole complaint as unripe Dkt. 26. The next steps are the trust's opposition and the court's ruling.
The trust reported $10,904,141 in disbursements from effectiveness through September 30, 2026, including $861,766 in the third quarter of 2026 Dkt. 1890. It is also suing co-founders John Rutledge and Bob Newport over bonus and consulting payments made in 2022 Dkt. 1795. In the main case it is objecting to duplicate and late claims and letting injury plaintiffs pursue insurance proceeds through court-approved stipulations.
The debtors filed chapter 11 petitions in the District of Delaware on September 18, 2023 Dkt. 1. The filings listed assets of up to $500 million and liabilities of up to $1 billion bloomberg.com: American Physician Partners Files Bankruptcy After Shutting Down (outside source). The case was a liquidation businesswire.com: American Physician Partners Files Chapter 11 Petitions as it Finalizes Orderly Wind Down (outside source) from the start. By the petition date, APP had begun moving roughly 150 emergency department and hospitalist contracts to replacement providers, and its workforce had fallen from about 2,546 employees to 27. The first-day declaration blames reimbursement pressure under the No Surprises Act, rising clinical labor costs, weaker collections per patient visit and the end of lender support Dkt. 18. The debtors owed at least $589.6 million under their secured credit facility. With the operating contracts gone, their main remaining asset was patient receivables, and disputes over who owned those receivables ran through the case.
The MagMutual suit turns on a $1.17 million dividend and open retrospective premiums
The insurance dispute came up at confirmation. The Ad Hoc Committee of Healthcare Providers named malpractice insurance issues, including a MagMutual policy dispute, as unfinished business for the liquidating trustee Dkt. 814. The trust filed adversary proceeding 26-50590 against PSIC and MagMutual Insurance Company on June 26, 2026 Dkt. 1. The complaint sought turnover of a $1,170,000 dividend that it alleges MagMutual declared and owes APP. It also asked for declarations that the defendants cannot set off or recoup their own claims against policy amounts. The trust asked the court to declare that retrospective premium adjustments under the 2020–2022 and 2022–2023 policies are separate transactions that cannot be recouped against each other, and it sought an accounting. It alleges that claims under both policies remain open, that deposit premiums have not been exceeded and that the parties have not agreed to start adjustments.
A letter attached to the original complaint states that PSIC rescinded APP's June 30, 2023 renewal policy for alleged nondisclosure of material facts Dkt. 1. For two other policies, the letter offered APP two options. Under the first, APP would escrow $9,056,991 in expected additional premium while MagMutual kept administering both policies. Under the second, MagMutual would handle only 87 active claims and suits, APP would agree that MagMutual had no responsibility for 115 remaining incidents, and APP would receive a $2.87 million premium return.
The trust amended its complaint on October 13, 2026. The amendment added MagMutual Holding Company and MagMutual Intermediate Holding Company as defendants and pleaded alternative claims for alter-ego liability, unjust enrichment, constructive trust and breach of contract Dkt. 19. The amended complaint gives the 2020–2022 policy a $30 million deposit premium, a $6.36 million minimum and a $59.46 million maximum Dkt. 18. For the 2022–2023 policy, the complaint states a $30 million deposit premium, but the attached endorsement states $18 million. A separate retrospective-rating endorsement attached to the complaint sets a $13 million inner aggregate of losses and allocated loss adjustment expense, a $5.4 million deposit and minimum premium and a $19.5 million maximum premium. The exhibits include a PSIC proof of claim for unliquidated retrospective premiums and another for $102,545 plus contingent deductible amounts. They also include MagMutual's $133,781.75 proof of claim, marked as a section 507(a)(2) priority claim Dkt. 20. The revised amended complaint of October 22 supersedes the October 13 version. The stipulated order treats the omission of the two holding companies from the amended caption as a clerical error .
The defendants moved to dismiss under Rule 12(b)(6) on November 17, 2026 Dkt. 25. They raise four main arguments. Turnover is unavailable because the dividend's existence, amount and obligor are all disputed, which makes the claim an unripe contract dispute rather than an undisputed debt. Alter ego cannot be pleaded as a standalone claim. The PSIC policy governs and bars Counts IX and X. MagMutual Insurance Company issued only a workers' compensation policy, which is unrelated to the dividend Dkt. 26. They also argue that the court lacks post-confirmation jurisdiction over the two holding companies on Counts III–V and VIII–X. In the alternative, they ask that the whole complaint be dismissed without prejudice. Under the policy, adjustments begin 24 months after expiration and continue until all claims close. The defendants argue that open claims and pending adjustments therefore make any dividend or return premium impossible to calculate yet. They also assert that both insurers preserved setoff rights and that PSIC may assert recoupment. A companion motion asks to file a 45-page brief instead of the 30-page local limit, and the trust does not oppose it Dkt. 27. Disclosure statements filed the same day show that MagMutual Intermediate Holding Company is a wholly owned subsidiary of MagMutual Holding Company . They also show that no publicly held corporation owns 10% or more of MagMutual Holding Company .
The trust has disbursed $10.9 million since effectiveness and is still clearing claims
The trust's report for the quarter ended September 30, 2026 is preliminary and unaudited Dkt. 1890. It shows $3,935,775 of secured claims allowed and paid, with 100% of those claims expected to be paid. It shows no administrative claims allowed and paid. Professional fees and expenses approved and paid before confirmation total $9,804,041, and none were paid in the quarter.
Disbursements since effectiveness on March 21, 2024
$10,904,141
Preconfirmation professional fees and expenses approved and paid
$9,804,041
Secured claims allowed and paid (100% anticipated)
$3,935,775
Administrative claims allowed and paid
$0
A May 1, 2024 retention order named Pirinate Consulting Group, LLC, with Eugene Davis as principal, as liquidating trustee Dkt. 1291. The revised liquidating trust agreement was filed with the modified plan supplement on January 2, 2024 Dkt. 807.
Omnibus objections target late and duplicate claims
An October 16, 2023 order set a general claims bar date of November 22, 2023 Dkt. 243. The trustee filed a first omnibus objection to late-filed claims on July 10, 2025 Dkt. 1748. A second objection, filed July 14, 2025, covered same-debtor duplicate claims and claims that had been amended and superseded Dkt. 1753. The court granted both objections on August 1, 2025 . The third and fourth omnibus objections were filed on March 4, 2026 and set for hearing on April 22, 2026. They target further same-debtor and cross-debtor duplicates. The trustee has obtained repeated extensions of the claims-objection and removal deadlines, including a fifth enlargement of the removal period in December 2025 .
Injury plaintiffs get insurance-only stay relief
The trustee has agreed to limited relief from the automatic stay and the plan injunction for specific malpractice and personal-injury suits. A December 2025 stipulation covered claims by Peter Wirth, Dominic Jacob Morales, Venus Skinner and Pablo Morales Dkt. 1820. A September 24, 2026 order let Terri Wohlgemuth and Richard Sons pursue their suit against insurance proceeds only. The plaintiffs waived their bankruptcy claims and distributions, and those claims are deemed disallowed Dkt. 1886. An October 20, 2026 order approved a stipulation with Kurt T. Schelling, DO, that lets Robert P. Dahman's Missouri personal-injury suit proceed on the same insurance-only basis Dkt. 1889. Under both 2026 stipulations, the relief lasts only while the trust incurs no material cost in the litigation. No debtor-related party may be joined without further relief. Earlier, on November 21, 2024, the court entered a memorandum order dismissing a motion for relief from stay .
A fiduciary-duty suit targets $3.19 million of 2022 bonuses and $60,000 in consulting fees
On September 17, 2025, the liquidating trustee sued APP co-founders John Rutledge and Bob Newport Dkt. 1795. The complaint alleges breach of fiduciary duty and seeks recovery under sections 548 and 550 of the Bankruptcy Code. Meland Budwick, Shawde & Eaton and Womble Bond Dickinson represent the trustee in the adversary proceeding law360.com: Medical Staffing Co. Trustee Says Ex-Execs Drained Funds - Law360 (outside source). The complaint makes two sets of allegations.
The first concerns bonuses. APP had agreed to cancel its fiscal 2021 corporate bonuses because of its cash crisis. The trustee alleges that Rutledge nonetheless directed bonus payments totaling $3,191,682 from May through October 2022, while APP was struggling to meet payroll and pay basic vendors. About $1,179,000 of that went to four people: about $445,000 to Rutledge, $293,000 to Chief Medical Officer Dr. Anthony Briningstool, $224,000 to SVP Andy McQueen and $217,000 to Newport. The trustee alleges that the board of managers never approved the payments. It also alleges that the bonuses were calculated on 2021 EBITDA figures that had been cut substantially by the time they were paid.
The second concerns consulting fees. Newport resigned as CFO effective June 30, 2022. The trustee alleges that Rutledge then had APP pay him $15,000 a month under a purported consulting agreement. APP paid Newport $60,000 between July and October 2022 for work that, according to the trustee, was never performed. The payments stopped after BBH discovered the arrangement around October 2022.
In June 2025, a Florida physician filed a separate lawsuit law360.com: Fla. Doc Sues In Del. Alleging Multistate Group Conspiracy (outside source) alleging a multistate conspiracy involving APP-affiliated entities. In December 2025, two more adversary cases, 25-52455 and 25-52461, were transferred to the bankruptcy court from the U.S. District Court for the District of Delaware.
Revenue reached $645 million, but operating losses ran $101 million to $148 million a year
American Physician Partners was formed in 2015 through the merger of Align MD and Elite Emergency Physicians. The company was based in Brentwood, Tennessee, and managed about 150 contracts news.bloomberglaw.com: American Physician Partners Goes Bankrupt After Shuttering (1) (outside source) across 15 states for emergency departments and hospitalist programs. It deployed more than 2,500 physicians and served more than 4 million patients a year. The first-day declaration describes nine physician practice acquisitions between 2016 and 2020 and more than 90 new contracts. Revenue rose from $438 million in 2019 to $645 million in 2022, while operating losses ran from $101 million to $148 million a year over the same period Dkt. 18.
In 2016, Brown Brothers Harriman Capital Partners recapitalized APP wsj.com: Brown Brothers Harriman Capital Partners recapitalized APP (outside source) and became its majority owner, providing about $105 million in secondary capital Dkt. 1795. APP received about $30.6 million in CARES Act relief across 2020 and 2021. The No Surprises Act stout.com: Hospital-Based Physician Staffing Company Industry Outlook - Stout (outside source) took effect in January 2022. It moved payment leverage to payors and contributed to delayed or denied reimbursements. The trustee's complaint puts its effect at more than $3.2 million a month in lost cash flow during 2022. As cash tightened in early 2022, BBH put in $15 million of emergency capital in April 2022 under a subscription agreement, then $5 million in June and another $5 million in September. Collections per patient visit fell short of expectations through 2022 and 2023, and stipend revenue declined. APP leaned more on expensive locum tenens staffing to fill clinical gaps. It continued to struggle with payroll, billing-vendor fees and other basic obligations.
In mid-September 2022, Huron Consulting Group's John C. DiDonato became chief restructuring officer, with James Nugent as deputy CRO. On December 9, 2022, the lenders cited defaults under the credit agreement and exercised proxy rights Dkt. 1795. They appointed an advisory board that later became an independent board of managers. CEO John Rutledge resigned on January 23, 2023. The lenders provided $28.0 million in new-money loans from January through May 2023. The declaration states that after June 9, 2023 they declined further advances, apart from $3 million in new money around June 15, 2023 to fund short-term operations Dkt. 18. In July 2023, APP began transitioning its contracts petition11.com to replacement providers and health systems. The goals were to avoid disruption to patient care and to shed tens of millions of dollars of obligations.
At least $589.6 million of secured loans sat ahead of about $40 million of trade claims
APP's funded debt was issued under an Amended and Restated Credit and Guaranty Agreement dated December 21, 2016. The parties were APP Holdco, LLC, American Physician Partners, LLC as borrower, the other company parties, and Goldman Sachs Specialty Lending Group, L.P. as administrative agent Dkt. 435 · p. 4. The debtors stipulated that as of August 31, 2023 they owed not less than $570,108,740.35 in term loans and $19,500,000 in revolver loans Dkt. 435 · p. 5. That puts identified funded debt at no less than $589.6 million. The lenders hold liens on substantially all of the credit parties' assets. The facility was originally due in December 2021 and, after an extension, matured in August 2022, when APP acknowledged owing at least $486 million in principal. APP Holdco, which is owned and controlled by third parties including BBH, is the only obligor under the facility that is not a debtor Dkt. 455 · p. 35.
Both identified prepetition loans sit under one Goldman Sachs-agented secured facility, totaling at least $589.6 millionPrincipal as of August 31, 2023, stated as "not less than" amounts. Excludes insurance premium financing and about $40 million of trade, staffing and payables claims.
Prepetition secured facility
Prepetition term loansAPP LLC as borrower and the guarantors$570.11M
Prepetition revolver loansAPP LLC as borrower and the guarantors$19.50M
Show the numbers
The lending group included Carlyle Secured Lending, which disclosed APP as a portfolio holding carlylesecuredlending.com: Form 10-Q for Carlyle Secured Lending INC filed 05/02/2022 (outside source) in its SEC filings. It also included AB Private Credit Investors Corporation, whose November 2023 quarterly report disclosed a restructuring event pdf.secdatabase.com: AB Private Credit Investors Corp Form 10-Q Quarterly Report ... (outside source) affecting how it recognized interest income on the APP position. Trade debt, staffing-related claims and other accounts payable came to about $40 million at the petition date, excluding contingent or unliquidated claims Dkt. 18. APP financed some insurance premiums through BankDirect Capital Finance and AFCO and was current on those obligations at filing Dkt. 18 · p. 37. APP Holdco, LLC held the common equity. CPV APP Blocker, Inc. and BBH held preferred equity.
Cash collateral, not a DIP loan, funded the wind-down
The debtors did not seek new-money DIP financing. They funded the wind-down with cash collateral under an interim order entered September 21, 2023 Dkt. 50 and a final order entered November 2, 2023 Dkt. 435. The final order let APP use cash from patient receivable collections and net proceeds of receivable sales. Spending followed a budget updated every two weeks and approved by the prepetition agent at the direction of the required lenders. The initial budget was a seven-week weekly cash flow forecast Dkt. 435. The lenders received replacement liens, superpriority claims and current payment of the agent's professionals, all subject to a carve-out that ranked ahead of them.
The motion drew objections from Pendrick Capital Partners, LLC Dkt. 108 and from certain former employees Dkt. 105. Sapientes Funding II, Collect Rx and Wakefield filed a limited objection on October 27, 2023 . They argued that "Sapientes Direct Payments" were not estate property and that the interim order authorized remittance of those payments but did not compel it. They sought segregation of about $1.836 million in disputed prepetition payments, an express exclusion of Sapientes cash from cash collateral, and procedures for paying postpetition amounts owed to Wakefield.
The final order did not decide who owned the disputed cash. It required the debtors to segregate $1,836,528.46 of Sapientes prepetition cash and $384,476.07 of Pendrick cash until the court determined ownership. It excluded both pools from the lenders' replacement liens. To protect the former employees who asserted prior liens, it required the debtors to keep at least $5.5 million in their operating accounts. Payment procedures were attached as Exhibit B Dkt. 435.
Cascade Capital bought the receivables for $7.71 million
With the operating contracts already transferred, the estate's remaining assets were mostly patient receivables. In December 2023, the debtors moved to sell the portfolio in a private sale Dkt. 677. The motion split the receivables into four pools: aged CMRE receivables, aged Wakefield receivables, active receivables managed by MCI, and receivables in the No Surprises Act independent dispute resolution (IDR) pipeline. The IDR pool consisted of reimbursement claims against payors still moving through the act's dispute process. APP said it marketed the portfolio in October 2023 to a limited group of industry buyers who signed NDAs and business associate agreements. Three bids came in. After a highest-and-best round, the debtors chose Cascade Capital Funding, LLC.
The price was $7.71 million, including a 25% deposit. The closing payment was reduced by gap payments collected before closing. The debtors argued that one bid for the whole portfolio beat piecemeal sales because the assets were distressed and aging. They also argued that a private sale offered more certainty and lower administrative cost than an auction. The court approved the sale on March 15, 2024 Dkt. 1130, the same day it confirmed the plan.
The plan gives lenders 60% of shared-asset proceeds; other unsecured creditors were projected near 3%
The debtors filed a combined plan and disclosure statement on the first day of the case. They amended it on October 30, 2023 Dkt. 303 and filed the solicitation version on November 9, 2023 Dkt. 455. A Delaware judge approved the disclosure statement law360.com: American Physician Partners Ch. 11 Confirmation Set For Dec. (outside source) in late October 2023 and authorized solicitation news.bloomberglaw.com: American Physician Partners Gets Nod to Solicit Votes on Plan (outside source). The judge set a December 14, 2023 confirmation hearing and urged the debtors to keep negotiating with unsecured creditors. The second amended combined plan was filed January 2, 2024 Dkt. 805. On March 15, 2024, the court entered an order giving final approval to the disclosure statement and confirming the plan Dkt. 1131. The plan created a liquidating trust to hold and sell the remaining assets, including shared assets and causes of action, for distribution to creditors.
Class 3 other secured claims were unimpaired. Each could be satisfied through lien retention until the collateral was sold, cash payment of the allowed claim, or abandonment of the collateral. Class 4 unsecured claims were impaired. Holders of allowed Class 4 claims share pro rata in a GUC cash settlement and in liquidating trust interests. The lenders' deficiency claim is carved out of the GUC cash settlement. Instead, it receives 60% of net proceeds from shared assets and causes of action, and the other 40% goes to the remaining allowed Class 4 claims Dkt. 805. The plan includes releases for the debtors and their professionals, plus third-party releases tied to an opt-out election during solicitation.
The confirmation analysis estimated the Class 4 recovery at about 3%, plus any value from shared assets and causes of action Dkt. 822.
Objectors settled before confirmation, and Class 4 was crammed down
The Ad Hoc Committee of Healthcare Providers settled its confirmation objection. A January 9, 2024 hearing transcript shows the settlement followed the addition of language preserving the group's standing to pursue causes of action even though equity interests were cancelled Dkt. 814. The confirmation brief reports that former employee issues were resolved through a stipulation allowing a $600,000 Class 3 secured claim. Cascade Capital's objection became moot after Cascade agreed to buy the remaining receivables and waive its claims. At the time of the brief, the debtors were still working with the United States on language covering tax, setoff, recoupment and rejection claims.
Class 4 voted against the plan, so the debtors had to meet the cramdown requirements of section 1129(b) Dkt. 814. The brief addressed the unfair-discrimination and fair-and-equitable tests. It argued that the 60/40 split of shared-asset proceeds reflected the relative size of the claim pools and the lenders' secured priority, not unfair discrimination.
Preconfirmation professional fees reached $9.8 million
The trust reports $9,804,041 in preconfirmation professional fees and expenses approved and paid Dkt. 1890. A June 10, 2024 omnibus final fee order approved fees and expenses for four professionals Dkt. 1539.
Fees and expenses approved in the June 10, 2024 omnibus final fee order Dkt. 1539
Professional
Fees
Expenses
Epiq Corporate Restructuring LLC
$51,041.50
Not listed
Kilpatrick Townsend & Stockton LLP
$1,418,679.46
$11,421.96
Womble Bond Dickinson (US) LLP
$108,981.50
$1,905.24
Force Ten Partners, LLC
$629,665.00
$4,370.08
The four approvals add up to about $2.21 million in fees and $17,697 in expenses. Bass, Berry & Sims PLC filed a separate final application as special counsel Dkt. 1317, seeking $162,402.50 in fees and $614.75 in expenses for September 18, 2023 through March 21, 2024. Pachulski Stang Ziehl & Jones LLP filed a final application as Delaware co-counsel to the debtors for the same period Dkt. 1526.
Petition to effectiveness took six months; trust litigation runs through 2026
Date
Event
September 18–19, 2023
Petitions, initial combined plan and first-day declaration filed
September 21, 2023
Interim cash collateral order entered
October 16, 2023
Bar date order entered; general bar date set for November 22, 2023
November 2, 2023
Final cash collateral order entered
November 9, 2023
Solicitation version of the amended combined plan filed
December 15, 2023
Motion to sell the remaining receivables filed
January 2, 2024
Second amended combined plan and modified plan supplement filed
March 15, 2024
Receivables sale approved; plan of liquidation confirmed
March 21, 2024
Plan takes effect
May 1, 2024
Liquidating trustee retention order entered
June 10, 2024
Omnibus final fee order entered
November 21, 2024
Memorandum order dismissing a motion for relief from stay
July 10–14, 2025
First and second omnibus claim objections filed
August 1, 2025
First and second omnibus objections granted
September 17, 2025
Complaint filed against former executives Rutledge and Newport
December 2025
Fifth enlargement of the removal period; malpractice stay-relief stipulation
March 4, 2026
Third and fourth omnibus claim objections filed
June 26, 2026
Adversary 26-50590 filed against PSIC and MagMutual Insurance Company
September 24, 2026
Wohlgemuth and Sons insurance-only stay-relief stipulation approved
October 13 and 22, 2026
Amended and revised amended complaints filed, adding two MagMutual holding companies
October 20, 2026
Schelling stay-relief stipulation approved
October 21, 2026
Post-confirmation report for the third quarter of 2026 filed
October 28, 2026
Order sets November 17, 2026 as the defendants' response date
November 17, 2026
Defendants move to dismiss the revised amended complaint