American Signature gets plan exclusivity to January 2027 after committee deal added $10.75 million to insider sale
ElevenFlo ·
American Signature is winding down in chapter 11 after the court approved the sale of substantially all assets to Schottenstein-affiliated ASI Purchaser LLC on February 6, 2026, with a committee settlement adding $10.75 million to the price Dkt. 520. No plan is on file; the court has extended the debtors' exclusive right to file one through January 17, 2027 and to solicit votes through March 17, 2027 Dkt. 1123.
The Value City Furniture parent sold substantially all of its assets to a Schottenstein affiliate in February 2026. Its estates are now reconciling claims, selling leftover claims and rejecting the last contracts, with no plan on file.
American Signature's chapter 11 cases have moved from a sale process into a wind-down without a plan. On November 4, 2026, the court further extended the debtors' exclusive period to file a chapter 11 plan through January 17, 2027, and their exclusive period to solicit acceptances through March 17, 2027, without prejudice to further extensions Dkt. 1123. The January 17 filing deadline is the next fixed milestone.
The operating business was disposed of early in the case. No competing qualified bids were received, so the debtors named Schottenstein-affiliated ASI Purchaser LLC the successful bidder and canceled the auction Dkt. 344. On February 6, 2026, Judge J. Kate Stickles approved the sale of substantially all assets as modified by a settlement with the official committee of unsecured creditors Dkt. 520. The settlement added $10.75 million to the purchase price and gave the estates a share of future real-estate sale proceeds.
The later docket deals with what is left. The court authorized a private sale of certain Google claims on July 31, 2026, under a sale agreement priced at $5,757,165.65 Dkt. 986. On November 10 it approved a $250,000 settlement of Iron Mountain's asserted $2.24 million of records-closure costs Dkt. 1132, and on November 16 it approved the rejections in the debtors' tenth rejection notice, which listed seven store leases and four other contracts Dkt. 1138. In an October 28 filing, the debtors said they had not yet begun liquidating general unsecured claims Dkt. 1113.
Sales fell from $1.1 billion to $803 million in the two years before the filing
The first-day declaration describes a family-founded furniture retailer that ran more than 120 Value City Furniture and American Signature Furniture stores across 17 states, employed about 3,000 people and had about $1.995 million of cash on the petition date Dkt. 5. Net sales fell in each year from fiscal 2023 to fiscal 2025. The net operating loss was $18 million in each of fiscal 2023 and 2024 and reached $70 million in fiscal 2025.
Net sales fell by roughly $300 million over three fiscal yearsAnnual net sales by fiscal year, as reported in the first-day declaration; fiscal 2023 is stated as $1.1 billion.
Ownership and financing were concentrated in one family. The first-day declaration says the debtor was wholly owned by Schottenstein Stores Corporation, and that the equity holders lent the company more than $51 million on an unsecured basis in the two years before the petition, of which about $24 million remained outstanding Dkt. 5 · p. 13. Family affiliates also held the ABL agency (Second Avenue Capital Partners, or SACP), the liquidation consulting role (SB360) and the stalking-horse bid. The board formed a conflicts committee on November 19, 2025, consisting of independent director Adam Zalev, to handle those overlaps.
Identified debt of $117.3 million sat with an insider ABL lender, PNC and the equity holders
Nine debtors' cases are jointly administered under American Signature, Inc. Dkt. 72. Three instruments carry stated petition-date balances. SACP agented a prepetition ABL facility with $39,247,739.43 of revolving loans outstanding Dkt. 83 · p. 7. PNC agented a term loan with not less than approximately $54,078,921.69 outstanding Dkt. 83 · p. 10. The equity holders' unsecured loans stood at about $24 million. Together these make up identified debt of approximately $117,326,661.12 across the three instruments, on mixed bases; no filing reports that figure as a total.
The first-day declaration's own totals do not match that inventory. Its narrative puts funded debt at about $93 million. Its debt table totals $117 million by counting $39 million under the ABL, $54 million under the term loan and $24 million under PNC's letter-of-credit facility, and leaves out the equity-holder loans Dkt. 5 · p. 7. The interim DIP order describes the letter-of-credit exposure as about $23.7 million of outstanding letters of credit secured by $24,347,995 of segregated cash collateral under PNC's control Dkt. 83.
PNC's term loan was the largest of the three instruments with stated balancesBalances as of November 22, 2025. The term loan is stated as not less than approximately $54.08 million; the equity-holder loans are approximate and their basis is not stated. Together the rows are identified debt, not a reported total. Excludes the cash-collateralized letters of credit and the postpetition DIP facility.
Secured
Unsecured
Prepetition term loan (PNC, agent)First lien on term collateral$54.08M
Prepetition ABL facility (SACP, agent)First lien on ABL collateral$39.25M
Equity-holder loansUnsecured$24.0M
The secured lenders held separate collateral pools. The ABL's first liens covered mainly receivables, inventory, equipment and general intangibles; the term loan's first liens covered separate term collateral and excluded the ABL collateral. Both facilities had been accelerated before the petition date Dkt. 83. The term loan's scheduled maturity was July 14, 2032.
Below the secured debt, the first-day declaration estimates about $236 million of unsecured liabilities excluding lease liabilities Dkt. 5. The petition lists the two largest unsecured creditors as Man Wah MCO Commercial, at $14,569,745, and Targetcast LLC, at $12,556,980, and puts total liabilities in the $500 million to $1 billion range Dkt. 1.
The insider DIP rolled up the ABL and set a sell-or-liquidate timetable
The debtors financed the case with a $50 million superpriority senior secured asset-based DIP facility from SACP, the insider-affiliated prepetition ABL agent Dkt. 14. SSG Advisors, the debtors' investment banker, said it contacted 12 prospective lenders starting November 10, 2025; eight reviewed the opportunity and passed, and none offered terms better than the prepetition ABL lenders Dkt. 16.
The facility worked as a roll-up. Under the interim order, collections paid down prepetition ABL loans dollar for dollar and created matching DIP availability Dkt. 83. The final order, entered January 8, 2026, converted all remaining prepetition ABL obligations into DIP obligations on a cashless basis Dkt. 350 · p. 18. The DIP liens primed the ABL lenders but stayed junior to PNC's liens on PNC's collateral.
The DIP loans bore interest at Adjusted Term SOFR plus 6.20%, with a 2.00% floor Dkt. 83. The motion listed a $500,000 closing fee, a $50,000 maintenance fee every 90 days, a $25,000 monthly collateral-monitoring fee, a $250,000 exit fee and a 0.375% unused-line fee Dkt. 14.
The committee objected on December 29, 2025, calling the facility an insider "loan-to-own" structure. It said the facility provided only about $8 million of net new money against about $850,000 of fees, and that the budget deferred stub rent and section 503(b)(9) claims to May 2026 on the strength of a 10% purchase-price holdback from the insider buyer. Among other changes, it asked for a $150,000 investigation budget Dkt. 258. A group of landlords also objected, and the debtors sought leave to file a late reply that would describe concessions and settlement talks Dkt. 328.
The final order reflects part of that dispute. It raised the committee's investigation budget to $150,000 from the interim order's $50,000. It kept the section 506(c) surcharge waiver but let holders of unpaid stub rent and 503(b)(9) claims, the estates and the committee seek a surcharge for those amounts. It set February 4, 2026 as the deadline to challenge the prepetition liens Dkt. 350. Its milestones required a sale order by February 5, 2026, and consummation of the sale and payment in full of the prepetition ABL, DIP and prepetition PNC obligations by February 6, 2026.
No rival bid surfaced, and the committee settlement added $10.75 million
The original combined sale and bid-procedures motion asked the court to approve a stalking-horse deal with ASI Purchaser LLC as buyer and SEI, Inc. as guarantor Dkt. 108. It proposed a December 30, 2025 bid deadline, a January 5, 2026 auction and a January 7 sale hearing. That timetable did not hold: by December 19, Judge Stickles had rejected the accelerated sale schedule homenewsnow.com: Judge in American Signature bankruptcy schools the debtors (outside source).
The debtors filed the successful-bidder notice on January 7, 2026. It says no competing qualified bids were received, ASI Purchaser became the successful bidder under the bid procedures, and the auction for the aggregate assets was canceled Dkt. 344. Trade press reported the canceled auction the same week furnituretoday.com: ASI auction canceled; liquidation path clears another hurdle (outside source). From then on, the dispute was over whether the committee could improve the economics of the insider deal.
The February 6 sale order approved a hybrid transaction. ASI Purchaser bought lease designation rights and specified real property and, as agent, took over the liquidation of merchandise and furniture, fixtures and equipment at 89 retail locations and several distribution centers Dkt. 520. The committee settlement changed the price as follows.
Committee settlement terms approved in the February 6, 2026 sale order
Term
Amount
Purchase-price increase paid at closing
$6.0 million
Deferred purchase-price payment, due three months after closing
$4.75 million
Estate share of real-property net cash proceeds between $67.5 million and $70 million, plus the buyer's carrying costs
Under the settlement, the Schottenstein parties also waived most of their claims against the estates, other than obligations under the purchase and agency agreements and the DIP and ABL obligations. The order found the buyer and agent to be good-faith parties under sections 363(m) and 364(e), cut off successor liability, including for WARN Act claims, and required the debtors to move for a claims bar date by February 20, 2026. It left lease-assignment, cure and adequate-assurance disputes for later site-specific orders Dkt. 520.
Store closings and separate inventory and lease sales ran alongside the main deal
American Signature also needed authority to keep turning stores and merchandise into cash. The final store-closing order authorized the debtors to assume the consulting agreement, run store-closing sales at designated stores, sell additional merchandise on consignment and use liquidation-style advertising Dkt. 352. It also let the debtors return a store to normal operations on notice to the landlord and allowed site-specific side letters with landlords.
Some assets were sold outside the main transaction before the sale order was entered. On January 28, 2026, the court approved a sale of inventory to Summit Warehousing, LLC free and clear of liens, with those interests attaching to the proceeds, and waived the 14-day stay so the sale could close at once Dkt. 466. The same day, it approved the assumption and assignment of certain leases to Ross Dress for Less, Inc., which provided a route to pay cure costs and ended debtor liability on the assigned leases once the transfer closed Dkt. 467.
The debtors' February 20, 2026 bar-date motion proposed April 24, 2026 at 5:00 p.m. Eastern as the general deadline for non-governmental claims, including section 503(b)(9) claims, and for many administrative-expense claims arising on or before March 24, 2026. It proposed May 21, 2026 for governmental units Dkt. 555.
Reconciliation is still under way. Berkeley Research Group, whose Rudolph Morando and Stephen Coulombe serve as co-chief restructuring officers, reported September 2026 work on customer-deposit and other claims reconciliation and on administrative and priority claims Dkt. 1129.
The debtors' statement that general unsecured claims have not yet been liquidated came in opposition to Marlene Daley's motion for a Bankruptcy Rule 2004 examination. The debtors asked the court to deny it with prejudice, arguing that discovery would give her a head start over other general unsecured claimants, that no insurance proceeds are available for her claim, and that they may instead object to the claim to set its value Dkt. 1113. The amended agenda for the November 10, 2026 hearing listed the motion as going forward Dkt. 1128.
The estates are selling claims and pursuing receivables while WARN and administrative claims stay open
Recent asset sales involve claims rather than stores. The July 31, 2026 order authorized a private sale of certain Google claims and participation interests Dkt. 986. The attached agreement sets a purchase price of $5,757,165.65 for a 100% beneficial participation interest in the Google claim; American Signature remains the named party but must act at the buyer's direction. A bill of sale attached to the agreement transfers Schottenstein Stores Corporation's Google-related claims, including claims tied to Google advertising invoices and antitrust proceedings, to American Signature, subject to court approval and reimbursement of documented transaction expenses. Debtors' counsel's June 2026 fee application describes work on sales of both Google and tariff-refund claims Dkt. 1139.
The debtors are also pursuing receivables. On April 8, 2026, American Signature sued Uniters North America, LLC for turnover of $573,670.17 that it says Uniters withheld under a furniture service-contract dealer agreement, with added counts for breach of contract, account stated and unjust enrichment Dkt. 1.
Former workers are pressing WARN Act claims. On March 12, 2026, Eric Moore filed a class action adversary complaint against American Signature and Kroehler Furniture Mfg. Co., Inc., which is not one of the nine debtors. The complaint alleges that about 210 full-time employees at a Conover, North Carolina facility were terminated on or about December 31, 2025 without 60 days' notice, that the two companies were a single employer, and that the WARN claims should be paid as administrative expenses because they arose after the petition date Dkt. 1. It also says more than 50 creditors have filed claims totaling over $2.3 million related to Kroehler.
Other administrative claims are being resolved one by one. A Worldpay administrative-expense claim matter was adjourned from the November 10 hearing for a status conference Dkt. 1126. The Iron Mountain settlement approved that day requires the debtor to pay $250,000 within five business days after the approval order becomes final, in satisfaction of asserted closure costs of $2,239,605.40, and authorizes Iron Mountain to destroy the remaining records Dkt. 1132.
The debtors are also clearing remaining contracts. Their tenth rejection notice, filed October 27, 2026, listed seven retail store leases with June 20, 2026 rejection dates and four non-real-property contracts Dkt. 1112. The November 16 order approved the rejections, deemed property left at the premises abandoned and set the deadline for rejection-damage claims at the later of the bar date or 30 days after the later of the order and the rejection date Dkt. 1138.
The plan, unsecured claims and the real-estate upside are still to be decided
The debtors hold the exclusive right to file a plan through January 17, 2027 and to solicit acceptances through March 17, 2027 Dkt. 1123. No plan or disclosure statement is on file, so the treatment of administrative, priority and general unsecured claims has not been proposed.
Several inputs to any distribution remain open: the reconciliation of customer-deposit and administrative claims, the WARN plaintiffs' request for administrative priority, the Worldpay administrative claim, the Uniters turnover suit, and the estates' share of any real-property proceeds above $67.5 million under the committee settlement. Professional fees continue to accrue; Berkeley Research Group reported $346,808 of fees for October 2026 alone Dkt. 1134.
Key dates run from the November 2025 petition to the March 2027 end of solicitation exclusivity
Date
Event
November 22, 2025
American Signature and eight affiliates file chapter 11 petitions in Delaware
November 23, 2025
First-day declaration filed
November 26, 2025
Interim DIP order entered; combined sale and bid-procedures motion filed
December 29, 2025
Committee and landlords object to final DIP financing
January 7, 2026
No competing qualified bids; ASI Purchaser named successful bidder; auction canceled
January 8, 2026
Final DIP order and final store-closing order entered
January 28, 2026
Summit inventory sale and Ross lease assignment orders entered
February 5, 2026
Gardner White lease assignment order entered
February 6, 2026
Sale order entered approving the sale of substantially all assets as modified by the committee settlement
February 20, 2026
Bar-date motion filed
March 12, 2026
WARN Act class action adversary complaint filed
April 8, 2026
Turnover suit against Uniters North America filed
July 31, 2026
Order authorizing private sale of Google claims entered
November 4, 2026
Exclusive periods further extended
November 10, 2026
Iron Mountain settlement approved
November 16, 2026
Order approving tenth round of contract and lease rejections entered
January 17, 2027
Exclusive plan-filing period ends
March 17, 2027
Exclusive solicitation period ends
Short answers to common questions about the sale and wind-down
Did American Signature find a buyer?
Yes. After no competing qualified bids arrived, Schottenstein-affiliated ASI Purchaser LLC became the successful bidder, and the court approved the sale of substantially all assets on February 6, 2026 Dkt. 520.
Did the auction take place?
No. The successful-bidder notice says the auction for the aggregate assets was canceled because no other qualified bid was received Dkt. 344.
What did the committee settlement change?
It raised the purchase price by $10.75 million, gave the estates 15% to 50% of real-property proceeds above set thresholds, cut transition-services charges by $500,000, and had the Schottenstein parties waive most claims against the estates.
No. The debtors have the exclusive right to file a plan through January 17, 2027 and to solicit acceptances through March 17, 2027 Dkt. 1123.
Why did the insider role draw objections?
The buyer, the DIP lender, the liquidation consultant and some landlord relationships all traced back to the Schottenstein family, and creditors argued the sale process favored insiders and pushed for better economics before the deal was approved.