Kauai Beach Villas has a $9 million stalking horse bid but no sale order; closing waits on 363(h) suit against 8,316 owners - ElevenFlo
Kauai Beach Villas has a $9 million stalking horse bid but no sale order; closing waits on 363(h) suit against 8,316 owners
ElevenFlo ·
Garden Isle Dream, LLC's $9,000,000 stalking horse bid is the only price on file for the 150-unit Lihue resort Dkt. 212 · p. 6. An auction was noticed for September 22 after a competing qualified bid arrived Dkt. 229 · p. 2, but no successful bidder or sale order appears through the November 16 hearing. Closing comes within 14 days after the later of a sale order and a final 363(h) judgment, and the 363(h) trial is listed for March 20, 2027 .
Bank of Hawaii, the only secured lender, was paid off under an October 22, 2026 stipulated order Dkt. 246 · p. 1. The main case returns for a status conference on January 25, 2027 Dkt. 249.
The Association of Apartment Owners of Kauai Beach Villas governs a 150-unit resort in Lihue. It filed a Subchapter V case on December 5, 2025 (Bankr. D. Haw. No. 25-01103) Dkt. 1 to sell the entire property instead of funding more than $70 million of structural repairs Dkt. 11. The Association itself owns only an undivided 2/102 interest in one apartment and a share of the common elements Dkt. 1. It can deliver the resort only by selling its members' interests together with its own under section 363(h) of the Bankruptcy Code. A buyer therefore needs two rulings from Judge Robert J. Faris: a sale order in the main case, and a final, unappealable judgment in the 363(h) adversary authorizing the sale of all members' interests Dkt. 143 · p. 6.
The second ruling controls the buyer's risk. The winning and back-up bids stay irrevocable until the 363(h) judgment Dkt. 143 · p. 21. Garden Isle Dream, LLC's agreement also raises its deposit from 5% to 10% of the price if it is chosen as either bidder Dkt. 212 · pp. 31, 32. On the proceeds side, no secured claim now ranks ahead of the liquidation plan. As filed, the plan pays creditors in full and divides the remainder among members after offsets for unpaid fees Dkt. 97. What members receive depends on three things: the final price, the cost of carrying the case into 2027, and any settlement of the whole owners' Rouhier lawsuit. The court has recorded that such a settlement will affect the plan Dkt. 237.
Garden Isle's $9 million bid is the floor, and the auction result has not been filed
On September 17, 2026, the court approved Garden Isle Dream, LLC, a Hawaii limited liability company, as stalking horse bidder for the whole property Dkt. 231 · p. 5 at a purchase price of $9,000,000 Dkt. 212 · p. 6. The same day, the Association gave notice that it had received at least one competing qualified bid. The notice set a virtual auction for September 22, a sale objection deadline of October 19 and a sale hearing to begin on or before November 16 Dkt. 229 · p. 2. The bidding procedures call for a notice of successful bidder within three business days after the auction Dkt. 143 · p. 6.
The docket through the November 16 hearing shows no notice of successful bidder and no sale order. The minutes of that hearing do not mention the sale Dkt. 249. The Association's October operating report, filed November 20, reports no asset sales during the month Dkt. 251. The winning bidder and final price have not been made public.
The process ran later than first planned. The April 14, 2026 amended bidding-procedures order set the auction mechanics but denied stalking horse protections without prejudice Dkt. 143. A June 25 notice moved the bid deadline to August 13 and the auction to August 27 Dkt. 190, and later notices pushed the stalking horse deadline to August 21 Dkt. 212 · p. 6. Under the protections approved in September, the breakup fee is paid only from the proceeds of an alternative transaction, at its closing . Both the fee and the expense reimbursement are administrative expense claims , and Garden Isle may credit bid them in a later bid .
Two owner objections are on file. An October 8 objection opposes the bid and the sale to Garden Isle Dkt. 241. Interval owner Richard C. Knudsen Jr. filed pro se on October 16. He argues that the stalking horse agreement does not establish the successful bidder or the final price Dkt. 245 · p. 1. He asks the Association to file the auction results, the executed agreement, the proposed sale order, the allocation method and the distribution waterfall Dkt. 245 · p. 2. He also contends that approving the sale should not decide the disputed 363(h) elements, and he asks for a reserve of proceeds tied to disputed ownership interests .
The 363(h) case against 8,316 owners sets the earliest closing date
The Association filed its 363(h) complaint on May 14, 2026 as Adversary No. 26-90012. The lead defendant is First American Trust, FSB, as trustee for the Club Wyndham Access Vacation Ownership Plan Dkt. 1. The complaint argues that partition in kind is impracticable with thousands of owners and a timeshare structure. It also argues that selling the whole property will bring significantly more than selling the Association's fractional interest. The defendants' interests would attach to the proceeds, subject to setoff of unpaid maintenance fees and assessments Dkt. 1.
The suit names 8,316 defendants, who are the members holding interests on the Association's books as of May 5, 2026. Each was served with a stipulation and consent judgment Dkt. 28 · p. 4. By August 19, 3,204 defendants (38.53%) had returned consents. The Association says they own a majority of the interests in the property Dkt. 28 · p. 5. About 37 defendants had answered or told the Association they oppose the sale Dkt. 28 · pp. 4, 5. The Association said it would amend the complaint after a title search, move to enter the consent judgments and seek summary judgment against the rest Dkt. 28 · p. 6. Minutes of a September 11 scheduling conference state that trial is scheduled for March 20, 2027 at 9:30 a.m. Dkt. 44.
The opposing owners raise a threshold argument. A March 2, 2026 opposition contends that the Association is not a co-owner able to invoke section 363(h), and that partition remains feasible for the Association's own interest Dkt. 93. Closing requires a final, unappealable judgment. A March trial followed by an appeal would therefore hold the winning bidder to its price beyond that date, while summary judgment could shorten the wait.
Bank of Hawaii is paid off, and the estate runs on about $2.8 million of cash
Bank of Hawaii was the Association's only secured creditor. Its $1.9 million loan from 2014 was secured by the Association's accounts and its right to collect maintenance fees Dkt. 11 · p. 26. The balance before the December 1, 2025 payment was about $446,341.83 Dkt. 11 · p. 27. The bank said the Merrill Lynch reserve account was not its collateral Dkt. 37. The case then ran on five interim cash collateral orders. The fifth required monthly payments of $13,030 and a minimum balance of $450,000 in the DIP account Dkt. 207 · p. 3.
On October 22, 2026, the court approved a stipulated payoff of $326,434.16 as of October 9, plus $17,031.40 in attorneys' fees Dkt. 246 · p. 3 and per diem interest of $465.06 Dkt. 246. Once paid, the bank must release its liens and withdraw its proofs of claim Dkt. 246 · p. 4. At the November 16 hearing, the court found the cash collateral motion moot because the secured debt had been paid Dkt. 249.
The stipulation recites October 1 balances of about $1,924,170 in the First Hawaiian Bank DIP account, $978,318 in a Merrill Lynch reserve account and $21,423 in a Merrill Lynch operating account Dkt. 246 · pp. 2, 3. Those three balances roughly equal the $2,923,877.60 of September month-end cash in the operating report Dkt. 248, which indicates that the reported cash includes the reserve. The October report shows receipts of $534,498.97, disbursements of $615,170.84, month-end cash of $2,843,205.70 and receivables of $772,470.72 Dkt. 251. It projects November receipts of $100,035 against disbursements of $231,004 . The budgets show revenue falling. Monthly assessment revenue was $429,947 early in the case and was cut to $300,000 for May through August . Total operating revenue was budgeted at $100,035 a month for September through November .
Reported cash fell each month from July to October 2026Month-end cash in the Association's monthly operating reports, in millions of dollars, rounded.
$3.26M
$3.16M
$2.92M
$2.84M
July 2026
August 2026
September 2026
October 2026
Show the numbers
The reserve is paying for case costs. The court let the Association use up to 50% of the March 16, 2026 Merrill Lynch reserve balance for administrative costs, granting in part a motion that sought up to $2.66 million Dkt. 179. The first interim fee order covered December 5, 2025 through April 30, 2026. It awarded $198,484 to K&L Gates, $167,418.77 in fees and $4,136.86 in expenses to Choi & Ito, $37,268.65 to Porter Kiakona Kopper and $8,685.85 to the Law Offices of Bruce H. Wakuzawa Dkt. 188.
A Rouhier settlement would change the liquidation plan
The Association filed a Subchapter V plan of liquidation on March 5, 2026 Dkt. 97. As filed, the plan sells the property, resolves the related litigation, determines member interests and unpaid fees, distributes the proceeds and dissolves the Association. Secured and general unsecured claims are unimpaired and paid in full in cash. Whole-unit owners form a separate impaired class tied in part to an insurance-settlement trust. Members share residual value pro rata after claims and reserves, less unpaid fees Dkt. 97. The general claims bar date was April 6, 2026 Dkt. 81. In January the Association told the court this is “not the typical Subchapter V case,” because the minority-owner litigation and the 363(h) case had to be resolved before confirmation Dkt. 58. In August it said confirmation was pending Dkt. 28 · p. 3. Wayne K.T. Mau is the Subchapter V trustee Dkt. 17.
The whole-owner suit led by Allan Rouhier began in state court in April 2022. It alleges that the Association underfunded maintenance of Buildings F through H in favor of Buildings A through E, where timeshare owners predominate. The Association removed it on January 16, 2026 as Adversary No. 26-90003 Dkt. 1. Trial began August 11 Dkt. 15, both sides rested August 18 Dkt. 283, and the court took the matter under advisement Dkt. 285. The court's September 28 minutes record that the parties were working toward a settlement and that “a settlement will affect the chapter 11 plan” .
Counsel for the Rouhier creditors attended the November 16 hearing. There, the court continued the main-case status conference to January 25, 2027 at 2:00 p.m. It also provided that a motion to enforce a settlement filed by November 17 would be heard on December 7, 2026 at 2:00 p.m., with oppositions due November 30 and replies due by noon on December 3 Dkt. 249. The filings do not show whether that motion was filed.
Club Wyndham's exchange offer affects who shares in the proceeds. In a November 2025 email to owners, Club Wyndham offered owners in good standing a swap of their Kauai Beach Villas interests for Club Wyndham Access points. The email said that owners who accepted would receive no net proceeds from the sale, according to a copy posted on the Timeshare Users Group forum tugbbs.com: *** New Thread: KBV Vote for Chapter 11 Bankruptcy | Page 7 ... (outside source).
Structural defects made repairs unfinanceable and closed Buildings G and H
Ground-floor units in Buildings A through E flooded on March 20, 2020. Repair work then found waterproofing failures, corroded structural columns and compromised post-tension cables across the property. A September 19, 2025 report by Wiss, Janney, Elstner Associates recommended mitigation for structural safety concerns Dkt. 11. The Association estimated full remediation at $70 million or more. That would mean an assessment of about $311,808 for a one-bedroom apartment and $548,352 for a two-bedroom, two-bath apartment, and the Association concluded that no lender would fund the work Dkt. 11. Its previous assessment, the $4.1 million Project Reoccupy assessment for Buildings G and H, collected $3,488,098. The board said a default rate of about 16% would leave a deficit of at least $14 million on a $70 million assessment. Members voted 81.829% in favor of a filing and a sale of the entire project at a September 19, 2025 special meeting Dkt. 11.
Project Reoccupy itself stalled. On February 26, 2026, the court lifted the stay so the Association could use a First American Title escrow of about $1.99 million set aside for Buildings G and H Dkt. 67Dkt. 87. A February 3, 2026 board update to owners, posted on the Timeshare Users Group forum, reported Building G overruns of about $370,000 and $800,000 on two bid items. The update said the overruns could use up the whole escrow and leave nothing for Building H tugbbs.com: KBV Chapter 11 progress in court - tugbbs.com (outside source). On April 7, 2026, the Association sued three groups of owners in Buildings G and H (Adversary No. 26-90010). The complaint says repair work was suspended in January 2026 after post-tension corrosion proved more extensive than expected. It asks the court to bar occupancy, citing a February 3 letter from WJE that declared the buildings unsafe and uninhabitable .