Bankruptcy court enjoins charter-revocation appeal against Highlands as nonprofit contests $186 million state audit claim
ElevenFlo ·
The bankruptcy court on November 10, 2026 granted Highlands' motion for a section 105(a) injunction against Twin Rivers' appeal seeking revocation of its two charters Dkt. 33, which CapRadio reported stopped the State Board hearing capradio.org: Education - capradio.org (outside source). A November 17 final cash order lets California withhold up to 100% of each school's 2026–27 apportionments to recover contested overpayments Dkt. 171. If Sutter County approves new charters on December 5 as scheduled, Highlands expects to file a plan within 30 days Dkt. 4.
Jump to section
Highlands reports no funded debt Dkt. 22. Its dominant creditor is the State of California, which asserts the disputed audit claim and separate attendance-overpayment claims of $30.8 million and $22.4 million against the two schools Dkt. 4.
The court entered its order granting Highlands' motion for an injunction under Bankruptcy Code section 105(a) on November 10, 2026 Dkt. 33. That was the date set for the hearing Dkt. 7, two days before the November 12 State Board of Education meeting described in Highlands' complaint Dkt. 1. CapRadio reported that the ruling stopped the State Board hearing on the revocation appeal capradio.org: Education - capradio.org (outside source). In Adversary Proceeding No. 26-02134 against the Twin Rivers Unified School District board of trustees and the State Board, Highlands had asked the court to bar both from continuing, enforcing or adjudicating the appeal while the bankruptcy case is pending or until further order Dkt. 1. The order's text was not available for review, so its duration and any conditions are unconfirmed.
The order's title names section 105(a), Highlands' alternative request. Its primary request was a declaration that the automatic stay, which halts most actions against a debtor once it files, already covered the appeal Dkt. 6. A section 105(a) injunction is a discretionary order that does not depend on that finding. The difference matters because the automatic stay does not reach a government unit's enforcement of its police and regulatory power. Highlands' supporting memorandum argued that charter revocation served no valid regulatory purpose in these circumstances Dkt. 13.
The appeal threatened funding for schools serving nearly 2,000 adults
Highlands is a California nonprofit that runs two tuition-free charter schools for adults in Sacramento County. At filing, according to Executive Director Jonathan Raymond, Highlands Community Charter School had 1,260 students, California Innovative Career Academy had 655 and Highlands had 167 employees Dkt. 4. Twin Rivers issued both charters Dkt. 4.
Twin Rivers' board voted in January 2026 to revoke the charters. Raymond says district staff and counsel had recommended against revocation Dkt. 4. The Sacramento County Board of Education overturned the revocation on May 19, and Twin Rivers appealed to the State Board on June 18 Dkt. 1. Highlands says the state's Advisory Commission on Charter Schools then recommended upholding revocation, and the State Board set the appeal for November 12 Dkt. 1. Highlands alleged that a revocation could cut off its funding and close the schools on or shortly after that date Dkt. 1. In its announcement of the filing, Highlands told students that the schools are not closing and that classes will continue hccts.org: Highlands Is Open as We Pursue an Orderly Reorganization – Highlands Community Charter and Technical Schools (outside source).
Twin Rivers is involved in the case in several roles. Besides prosecuting the appeal, it appears on Highlands' list of largest unsecured creditors with a $2,413,709.68 claim marked contingent, unliquidated and disputed Dkt. 1. Highlands says it may have claims against the district over oversight failures and its role in school management. These include about $12.9 million in oversight and facility fees identified for the audit period Dkt. 4. Twin Rivers is also a counterparty to one of the leases the court allowed Highlands to reject on November 17 Dkt. 169.
California recoups overpayments from 2026–27 apportionments but gets no lien on Highlands' cash
The final cash-use order entered November 17 lets Highlands spend cash on hand and later receipts on operations and case administration under an approved budget Dkt. 171. It also sets how the State of California collects attendance-based overpayments. The October 15 interim order had reserved those terms for final consideration Dkt. 95. The State may apply apportionments it had already withheld at filing, about $1.81 million from Highlands Community Charter School and $1.73 million from California Innovative Career Academy Dkt. 4. It may also withhold up to 100% of each 2026–27 apportionment otherwise payable to either school Dkt. 171. Each school's money goes only to that school's overpayment. Withholding continues until that overpayment, as agreed or as the court determines, is recovered in full Dkt. 171.
Withholding for a school stops at the earliest of full recovery, the end of the 2026–27 school year or revocation of that school's charter Dkt. 171. The State must give Highlands a school-by-school statement of amounts withheld, amounts applied and the remaining balance within 21 days after each month Dkt. 171. After the school year, the State may seek further relief for any remaining balance, and Highlands may contest it Dkt. 171. Highlands admits neither the validity nor the amount of the overpayments. If an amount is reduced, the State must promptly return the excess Dkt. 171.
For other creditors, the limits on the State's recovery matter as much as the recovery itself. The State's rights reach only 2026–27 apportionments and give it no lien on, or right to apply, other estate property. The order also grants no lien, superpriority claim or other protection in Highlands' cash Dkt. 171. Raymond reported about $93.6 million of cash at filing. About $51.8 million of it is restricted to designated grant and program purposes Dkt. 22. By subtraction, about $41.8 million was unrestricted, and Raymond identified that cash as the primary source for general operating expenses Dkt. 22.
Spending is tied to the budget. Grant and categorical funds may be used only for their designated purposes and must be accounted for separately Dkt. 171. Material budget amendments require a court order on notice to the U.S. Trustee, the State and any committee. Highlands may make cumulative monthly line-item variances of up to 10% after two business days' written notice Dkt. 171. Monthly operating reports must compare actual receipts and disbursements with the budget Dkt. 171.
Disputed state claims make up nearly all reported liabilities
The only secured obligations Raymond identifies are three equipment leases with De Lage Landen Financial Services and Canon Financial Services, with combined balances of about $31,265 Dkt. 4 · p. 8. The final cash-use order lets Highlands keep paying those leases while it decides whether to assume or reject them. It also preserves Highlands' right to argue that a lease is a financing rather than a true lease Dkt. 171.
- State claims
- Other liabilities
- Audit liability, June 2025 State Auditor reportState of California$186.45M
- Attendance overpayment, Highlands Community Charter SchoolCalifornia Department of Education$30.82M
- Attendance overpayment, California Innovative Career AcademyCalifornia Department of Education$22.40M
- Trade, vendor, service-provider and real-property lease liabilitiesVarious$0.80M
- Litigation and workers' compensation claimsVarious$0.39M
- Equipment leasesDe Lage Landen; Canon Financial Services$0.03M
Show the numbers
| Liability | Claimant or holder | Amount |
|---|---|---|
| Audit liability, June 2025 State Auditor report | State of California | $186.45M |
| Attendance overpayment, Highlands Community Charter School | California Department of Education | $30.82M |
| Attendance overpayment, California Innovative Career Academy | California Department of Education | $22.40M |
| Trade, vendor, service-provider and real-property lease liabilities | Various | $0.80M |
| Litigation and workers' compensation claims | Various | $0.39M |
| Equipment leases | De Lage Landen; Canon Financial Services | $0.03M |
Source: first-day declaration Dkt. 4
The audit claim stems from the California State Auditor's June 2025 report. The report found that Highlands received about $186.45 million for which it was allegedly ineligible, including about $177 million of K-12 funding and an estimated $5.5 million of overpayments Dkt. 4. Raymond says the audit did not allege fraud. He also says Highlands has replaced its leadership and board, implemented all 18 audit recommendations and laid off more than 600 employees Dkt. 4. The California Department of Education issued repayment determinations after the audit, and the schools appealed them to the Education Audit Appeals Panel Dkt. 1. Highlands did not ask the bankruptcy court to stop that appeal because the Department of Finance did not object to staying it. The Department reserved the right to seek relief from the stay Dkt. 1.
The attendance overpayments are a separate dispute. Raymond explains that 2025–26 funding was first paid on the prior year's higher attendance, and enrollment then fell Dkt. 22. Highlands estimated 2025–26 gross revenue at about $24.56 million, compared with $152.69 million in 2024–25 and $164.96 million in 2023–24 Dkt. 4. The State treated the academy's entire funding as an overpayment because the academy lacked a required funding determination Dkt. 22. Raymond puts the academy's actual overpayment at about $12.2 million in his cash-use declaration and about $13 million in his first-day declaration. He says the final amount is unknown Dkt. 22Dkt. 4.
The petition's list of largest unsecured creditors shows a single California Department of Education claim of $243,123,953, marked contingent, unliquidated and disputed Dkt. 1. The petition estimates assets and liabilities each at $100 million to $500 million. It also states that funds will be available for distribution to unsecured creditors Dkt. 1.
The planned exit depends on new Sutter County charters, with a going-concern sale as the fallback
Highlands' preferred restructuring moves its schools to new charters. Its complaint identifies the Sutter County Board of Education as the prospective authorizer, for charters beginning in the 2027–28 school year Dkt. 1. Raymond's first-day declaration says the decision was scheduled for December 5, 2026 Dkt. 4. If the charters are approved, Highlands expects to file a chapter 11 plan within 30 days of the decision and to seek confirmation within 90 days after filing. The plan would transfer the schools, programs, employees and students effective July 1, 2027 Dkt. 4. Raymond names a going-concern sale as the alternative Dkt. 4.
Highlands told the court that letting the revocation appeal proceed would impair that reorganization Dkt. 1. While the injunction remains in effect, the existing charters stay in place as Sutter County decides.
Rejected-lease counterparties have until at least December 17 to file claims
The November 17 lease order rejects the leases listed on its exhibit, effective as of the October 4 petition date. The counterparties are Twin Rivers Unified School District, Teichert Land Co., Buzz Oates Development, L.P. and Buzz Oates LLC, AFP Investment Partners, LLC, Canon Financial Services as agent for FlexTG Financial Services, and Cesar Nava APC, doing business as Nava Law Firm Dkt. 169. A counterparty asserting a rejection claim must file a proof of claim by the later of two dates: 30 days after entry, which is December 17, 2026, or the court's deadline for prepetition claims Dkt. 169. Personal property left at the premises is deemed abandoned as of the petition date. Counterparties may not apply security deposits without court approval Dkt. 169. Verita Global is the court-approved claims agent and maintains the official claims register Dkt. 76.
The court made the remaining first-day relief final the same day. Highlands may honor up to $1,900,660 of prepetition wage and benefit obligations, subject to a $17,150 per-employee cap Dkt. 176. It must post a $301,667.82 utility deposit Dkt. 172. It may keep its bank accounts, cash management system and insurance policies Dkt. 170Dkt. 173. On November 17 and 18, the court approved four retentions: Sheppard, Mullin, Richter & Hampton as bankruptcy counsel, Arch & Beam Global as financial advisor, Young, Minney & Corr as special charter school counsel and Verita as administrative advisor. It did not approve their engagement terms under section 328(a) Dkt. 179Dkt. 177Dkt. 178Dkt. 175.
Sources
- Dkt. 1Charter Appeal Stay ComplaintFiled Oct 13, 2026Oct 13, 2026
- Dkt. 1Highlands Chapter 11 PetitionFiled Oct 4, 2026Oct 4, 2026
- Dkt. 4HCCTS Filing DeclarationCited at p. 8 · Filed Oct 4, 2026Oct 4, 2026
- Dkt. 6Motion to Extend StayFiled Oct 13, 2026Oct 13, 2026
- Dkt. 7Stay Motion Hearing NoticeFiled Oct 13, 2026Oct 13, 2026
- Dkt. 13Motion to Extend StayFiled Oct 13, 2026Oct 13, 2026
- Dkt. 22Raymond Cash Use DeclarationFiled Oct 5, 2026Oct 5, 2026
- Dkt. 33Injunction OrderFiled Nov 10, 2026Nov 10, 2026
- Dkt. 76Verita Retention OrderFiled Oct 12, 2026Oct 12, 2026
- Dkt. 95Interim Cash Use OrderFiled Oct 15, 2026Oct 15, 2026
- Dkt. 169Lease Rejection OrderFiled Nov 17, 2026Nov 17, 2026
- Dkt. 170Final Cash Management OrderFiled Nov 17, 2026Nov 17, 2026
- Dkt. 171Final Cash Use and Recovery OrderFiled Nov 17, 2026Nov 17, 2026
- Dkt. 172Final Utility Assurance OrderFiled Nov 17, 2026Nov 17, 2026
- Dkt. 173Final Insurance OrderFiled Nov 17, 2026Nov 17, 2026
- Dkt. 175Verita Employment OrderFiled Nov 17, 2026Nov 17, 2026
- Dkt. 176Final Employee Benefits OrderFiled Nov 17, 2026Nov 17, 2026
- Dkt. 177Financial Advisor Employment OrderFiled Nov 17, 2026Nov 17, 2026
- Dkt. 178YM&C Employment ApprovedFiled Nov 17, 2026Nov 17, 2026
- Dkt. 179Sheppard Counsel EmploymentFiled Nov 18, 2026Nov 18, 2026
- WebEducation - capradio.orgcapradio.org · Outside source
- WebHighlands Is Open as We Pursue an Orderly Reorganization – Highlands Community Charter and Technical Schoolshccts.org · Outside source