Maguire Group Holdings Bankruptcy: 100% Plan for Key Subconsultants, $925,000 Four-Year Pool for Other Unsecured Creditors
ElevenFlo ·
Maguire Group Holdings and four affiliates, owners of the Maguire Group architecture and engineering firm, confirmed a plan in July 2012 that promised subconsultants needed for ongoing work 100% of their allowed claims and gave other unsecured creditors a pro rata share of $925,000 over four years Dkt. 701 · pp. 66, 68. The reorganized debtors later put that Class 5 dividend at about 26% Dkt. 786 · p. 2. Old equity was cancelled Dkt. 701 · p. 69, and the court closed the case on May 6, 2013 Dkt. 788 · p. 1.
Jump to section
Maguire Group Holdings, Inc., The Maguire Corporation, Maguire Group Inc., East Atlantic Casualty Company, Ltd. and Maguire Group, Architects, Engineers, Planners, Ltd. filed chapter 11 in the Southern District of Florida on October 24, 2011, and their plan took effect on August 27, 2012. This page covers who received the reorganized company's equity, what each creditor class received, why the company filed, what the affiliates are called now and how the case closed, using filings through the May 6, 2013 final decree.
Who owned Maguire Group after the bankruptcy?
The plan proponents, as of the August 27, 2012 effective date. The confirmation order directs the cancellation of all existing equity interests in the debtors and the issuance of 100% of the reorganized debtors' equity to the plan proponents or their designee Dkt. 701 · p. 26. The plan proponents are the debtors and the company's principal Dkt. 701 · pp. 2, 12, who held 95% of Maguire Holdings' stock before the case, with another individual holding the remaining 5% Dkt. 299 · p. 20. Old equity holders received nothing on account of their shares Dkt. 701 · p. 69.
The plan calls for the principal to contribute $350,000 in cash on the effective date, $250,000 of it to fund the first Class 5 payment and $100,000 toward operating expenses, and to personally guarantee certain plan payments Dkt. 701 · p. 57. The disclosure statement said the reorganized debtors would operate under the management and operational control of the plan proponents or their designees Dkt. 299 · p. 15. The U.S. Trustee disagreed with the debtors' view that the plan provides maximum recoveries to all creditors Dkt. 299 · p. 13. This page does not cite a filing that identifies the company's owners after the case closed.
What did Maguire's unsecured creditors recover?
The plan split general unsecured claims into two classes. Class 4 holds claims the debtors considered necessary for continued operations, mainly subconsultants, and Class 5 holds all other general unsecured claims, including litigation claimants, claims tied to the 2009 acquisition, former minority shareholders, noteholders, other subconsultants and trade vendors Dkt. 299 · pp. 14, 27Dkt. 701 · pp. 66, 67.
Class 4: 100% of each allowed claim in cash, without interest, paid during a distribution period the disclosure statement described as nine months from the effective date, with payments on each claim starting after the project owner paid the debtors for that project Dkt. 701 · p. 66Dkt. 299 · p. 14. The May 2013 final report lists $2,138,503.17 of allowed Class 4 claims, which it says reflect $350,543.69 of agreed reductions, and $1,280,589.69 paid from August 27, 2012 through January 30, 2013 Dkt. 786 · p. 8, and states that the reorganized debtors had been timely making Class 4 distributions Dkt. 786 · p. 2. This page does not cite a filing that reports the final Class 4 payment.
Class 5: a pro rata share of $925,000 in cash over four years, made up of $250,000 within 30 days of the effective date, funded by the principal's contribution and personally guaranteed, $150,000 within 14 days of the first anniversary and $175,000 within 14 days of each of the second, third and fourth anniversaries Dkt. 701 · p. 68. Class 5 also shares any net recoveries from the estates' causes of action Dkt. 701 · p. 68. The April 2012 disclosure statement had described a single lump-sum share of $250,000 paid on the effective date Dkt. 299 · pp. 18, 103. The final report says the plan provides a dividend of approximately 26%, without interest, as a result of successful claims objections, and that the initial Class 5 payment went out on September 21, 2012 Dkt. 786 · p. 2. This page does not cite a filing that reports the later annual Class 5 installments.
Both voting classes accepted: 100% of Class 4 creditors by number and amount, and Class 5 creditors holding 60% in number and about 75% in dollar amount Dkt. 701 · pp. 15, 16.
What did each Maguire creditor class receive?
| Class | Treatment |
|---|---|
| 1. Priority claims | Paid in full in cash Dkt. 299 · p. 16 |
| 2. Regions Bank secured claim (about $950,000) | Satisfied in full during the case; loan documents discharged Dkt. 299 · p. 16 |
| 3. Other secured claims | Paid in full, given sale proceeds or given the collateral Dkt. 701 · p. 66 |
| 4. General unsecured claims necessary for continued operations | 100% in cash, without interest, over the Class 4 distribution period Dkt. 701 · p. 66Dkt. 299 · p. 14 |
| 5. Other general unsecured claims | Pro rata share of $925,000 over four years plus net recoveries from causes of action Dkt. 701 · p. 68 |
| 6. Subordinated unsecured claims | Expected to receive nothing; shares cause-of-action recoveries only if Class 5 is paid in full; the court found the class had no creditors Dkt. 701 · pp. 69, 15 |
| 7. Equity interests | Cancelled without distribution Dkt. 701 · p. 69 |
What are the Maguire companies called now?
During 2012, debtor Maguire Group Inc., the operating company, changed its name to CDR Maguire Inc., and The Maguire Corporation was dissolved Dkt. 786 · p. 1Dkt. 299 · p. 20. The final decree lists Maguire Group Holdings, Inc. as formerly known as Metric Engineering Group, Inc. Dkt. 788 · p. 1. The disclosure statement describes the Maguire Group as a strategic partner of non-debtor Metric Engineering, Inc. Dkt. 299 · p. 21.
How did the Maguire Group Holdings case end?
Judge Robert A. Mark signed the confirmation order on July 24, 2012, and it was entered July 25, 2012 Dkt. 701 · p. 1. The effective date occurred on August 27, 2012 Dkt. 720 · p. 1. The amended final report of May 1, 2013 says the plan was substantially consummated, no pending adversary proceedings or contested matters would affect it, administrative claims were paid or provided for, and the reorganized debtors continue to operate the business Dkt. 786 · p. 3. It lists $1,024,815.64 in fees and expenses for the debtors' attorneys, $714,695.12 for other professionals, $64,025.00 in U.S. Trustee fees and $31,105,573.71 in total disbursements from the petition date through the report Dkt. 786 · p. 3.
On May 6, 2013 the court entered a final decree closing the case and directing that any future plan payments be disbursed under the plan Dkt. 788 · p. 1.
Why did Maguire Group file for chapter 11?
Maguire Group Holdings was incorporated in Florida in October 2008 to buy The Maguire Corporation and its subsidiaries. It bought a majority of The Maguire Corporation's shares in 2009, and that December The Maguire Corporation redeemed the remaining minority shares and became a wholly owned subsidiary Dkt. 299 · p. 20. The Maguire Group, founded more than 70 years earlier as a small civil engineering firm, provides architectural, engineering, planning and construction management services, mostly under government contracts, with about $24.7 million of annual revenue and about 170 employees at filing Dkt. 299 · p. 21.
According to the disclosure statement, revenue had been declining since 2006, and before the petition date the debtors discovered financial relationships and litigation risks that the former owners had not disclosed or had inadequately disclosed at the acquisition Dkt. 299 · p. 28. The debtors cited a 2005 lawsuit with the Connecticut Department of Transportation over the I-84 project, from which the firm was suspended, and said the Connecticut office's annual revenue fell from $6 million to $1.0 to $1.5 million Dkt. 299 · p. 28. They also cited new U.S. Department of Transportation claims on that project that could exceed $8 million, which the debtors dispute, with at most $300,000 of insurance coverage that they believed might apply Dkt. 299 · p. 28. Their schedules listed about $36.1 million of known and potential litigation-related claims, the vast majority of which they dispute Dkt. 299 · p. 14.
Early in the case the debtors received interim authority to use cash collateral, with the debtors and Regions Bank representing that about $950,000 of principal was owed to the bank Dkt. 51 · p. 3. The disclosure statement lists interim authority to obtain debtor in possession financing from their principal among the first day relief Dkt. 299 · p. 31, and the debtors later withdrew, without prejudice, their emergency motion for secured post-petition financing Dkt. 148 · p. 1.
Case Snapshot
| Debtors | Maguire Group Holdings, Inc. and four affiliates, jointly administered Dkt. 701 · pp. 1, 2 |
| Court and case | Bankr. S.D. Fla., No. 11-39347 (RAM) Dkt. 788 · p. 1 |
| Judge | Robert A. Mark Dkt. 701 · p. 1 |
| Petition date | October 24, 2011 Dkt. 299 · p. 107 |
| Plan | Plan Proponents' Third Amended Plan of Reorganization, as amended Dkt. 720 · p. 1 |
| Confirmation order | Signed July 24, 2012, entered July 25, 2012 Dkt. 701 · p. 1 |
| Effective date | August 27, 2012 Dkt. 720 · p. 1 |
| Final decree | May 6, 2013 Dkt. 788 · p. 1 |
| Claims, notice and ballot agent | Kurtzman Carson Consultants Dkt. 299 · p. 31 |
Key Dates
| Date | Event |
|---|---|
| October 2008 | Maguire Group Holdings incorporated in Florida Dkt. 299 · p. 20 |
| 2009 | Acquisition of The Maguire Corporation Dkt. 299 · p. 20 |
| October 24, 2011 | Chapter 11 petitions filed Dkt. 299 · p. 107 |
| April 12, 2012 | Date of the plan proponents' third amended plan Dkt. 720 · p. 1 |
| July 24, 2012 | Confirmation order signed; entered July 25 Dkt. 701 · p. 1 |
| August 27, 2012 | Plan effective Dkt. 720 · p. 1 |
| September 21, 2012 | Initial Class 5 distribution Dkt. 786 · p. 2 |
| May 1, 2013 | Amended final report and motion for entry of final decree Dkt. 786 · pp. 1, 4 |
| May 6, 2013 | Final decree closing the case Dkt. 788 · p. 1 |
Frequently Asked Questions
Who got the equity in the Maguire Group Holdings bankruptcy?
The plan issued 100% of the reorganized debtors' equity to the plan proponents, the debtors and the company's principal, or their designee Dkt. 701 · pp. 26, 12.
How much did Maguire's unsecured creditors recover?
Class 4 was promised 100% Dkt. 701 · p. 66. Class 5 shared $925,000 over four years Dkt. 701 · p. 68, which the final report described as a dividend of approximately 26% Dkt. 786 · p. 2.
Did the old Maguire shareholders receive anything?
No. Equity interests were cancelled without distribution Dkt. 701 · p. 69.
What is CDR Maguire Inc.?
It is the 2012 name of debtor Maguire Group Inc., the operating company Dkt. 786 · p. 1Dkt. 299 · p. 20.
When was the Maguire Group Holdings case closed?
May 6, 2013, by final decree Dkt. 788 · p. 1.
Sources
- Dkt. 51Interim Order (I) Authorizing the Debtors (A) to Use Cash Collateral on An Interim Basis Pursuant to 11 U.S.C. § 363, and (B) to Grant Adequate Protection in Connection Therewith Pursuant to 11 U.S.C. §§ 361, 363 and 507, and (II) Scheduling a Final Hearing Under Bankruptcy Rule 4001; Hearing to be Held on November 21, 2011, at 2:30 p.m.Cited at p. 3 · Filed Oct 27, 2011Oct 27, 2011
- Dkt. 148Notice of Withdrawal of Debtors' Emergency Motion for Entry of Interim and Final Orders Authorizing (A) Debtors In Possession to Obtain Secured Post-Petition Financing, (B) Granting Certain Liens, (C) Approving Agreements Relating to the Foregoing, (D) Modifying the Automatic Stay, (E) Granting Super-Priority Administrative Claim Status, (F) Scheduling a Final Hearing, and (G) Prescribing Form and Manner of Notice with Respect TheretoCited at p. 1 · Filed Dec 22, 2011Dec 22, 2011
- Dkt. 299Third Amended Disclosure Statement for the Plan Proponents' Plan of Reorganization Under Chapter 11 of the Bankruptcy CodeFiled Apr 12, 2012Apr 12, 2012
- Dkt. 701Order Confirming Plan Proponents' Third Amended Plan of Reorganization Under Chapter 11 of the Bankruptcy Code, Dated April 12, 2012, as AmendedFiled Jul 25, 2012Jul 25, 2012
- Dkt. 720Notice of Occurrence of Effective Date of Plan Proponents' Third Amended Plan of Reorganization Under Chapter 11 of the Bankruptcy Code, Dated April 12, 2012, as AmendedCited at p. 1 · Filed Aug 28, 2012Aug 28, 2012
- Dkt. 786Amended Final Report and Motion for Entry of Final DecreeFiled May 1, 2013May 1, 2013
- Dkt. 788Final DecreeCited at p. 1 · Filed May 6, 2013May 6, 2013