Party City trustee contests IRS claims and sues on preferences after liquidation plan for 692-store chain took effect - ElevenFlo
P
Party City Holdco Inc. (2024)
Ch. 11Effective24-90621·S.D. Tex.·Judge Alfredo R. Perez
Party City trustee contests IRS claims and sues on preferences after liquidation plan for 692-store chain took effect
ElevenFlo ·
Party City's liquidation plan took effect on September 22, 2025Dkt. 1857. Liquidating trustee Elizabeth LaPuma is now settling claims and suing vendors to recover preference payments Dkt. 2429. On November 5, 2026 the court vacated its order granting her motion to estimate the IRS's tax claims Dkt. 2434, which reopens that dispute. The next hearing on the calendar is a motion hearing on November 30, 2026.
The court confirmed Party City's joint plan of liquidation on August 27, 2025, and the plan took effect on September 22, 2025. A liquidating trust now holds the remaining assets and is reconciling claims before it makes distributions.
Party City's second chapter 11 case is in post-effective administration. On August 27, 2025 the court entered an order approving the disclosure statement on a final basis and confirming the debtors' joint chapter 11 plan of liquidation Dkt. 1827. The plan took effect on September 22, 2025, and its releases, exculpations and injunctions became effective the same day Dkt. 1857. The remaining assets, including causes of action, sit in the Party City Liquidating Trust. Elizabeth LaPuma is the liquidating trustee Dkt. 2427. Under the plan, the trustee is also the sole officer and director of the wind-down debtors Dkt. 1672.
The trust's November 2026 filings show the two jobs left: shrinking the claims pool and collecting money to distribute. On November 3, 2026 the trustee filed three adversary complaints to avoid and recover alleged preferential transfers Dkt. 2429. Between November 4 and November 7 the court signed stipulated orders resolving parts of the trustee's sixteenth, seventeenth and nineteenth omnibus claim objections Dkt. 2437. The dispute with the IRS is contested again. On November 5, 2026 the court vacated its October 4, 2026 order granting the trustee's motion to estimate the IRS's tax claims Dkt. 2434. On November 9 the United States asked the court to overrule the trustee's claim objection and deny estimation Dkt. 2440. The next hearing on the calendar is a motion hearing on November 30, 2026.
The case moved fast. Party City filed on December 21, 2024 with about $399 million of funded debt Dkt. 44 · p. 10 and began store-closing sales at 692 locations two days later gordonbrothers.com: December 23, 2024 (outside source, not verified by ElevenFlo). It ran the case on its lenders' cash collateral instead of a DIP loan and repaid its first-lien lenders after the petition date Dkt. 1637. The confirmed plan divides what remains among three groups: administrative and priority creditors, the second lien noteholders who also owned the company, and general unsecured creditors.
The trust is cutting claims, suing vendors and again contesting the IRS
Stipulated orders are resolving omnibus objections
Between November 4 and November 7, 2026, the court signed three stipulated orders on the trustee's omnibus claim objections:
Claim No. 2030 is allowed at $420,000. Marc NaperW, LLC and NaperW, LLC had filed it against Party City Corporation as a $2,414,490.33 general unsecured claim. The trustee's seventeenth omnibus objection argued that the claim exceeded the section 502(b)(6) cap on lease-termination damages Dkt. 2437.
Claim No. 641 is disallowed because it duplicated the construction-lien part of Summerhill Square, L.L.C.'s Claim No. 1865. Claim 1865 keeps the treatment set under the nineteenth omnibus objection: $104,612.63 allowed as an administrative claim and $860,046.32 reclassified as a Class 4 general unsecured claim Dkt. 2433.
On the sixteenth omnibus objection, three Arizona Department of Revenue claims are allowed: Claim No. 2275 as a $109,500 priority tax claim, Claim No. 2699 at $419.08 and Claim No. 275 as a $376.50 general unsecured claim. Claims 274 and 1905 are expunged as amended or superseded Dkt. 2439.
Three preference complaints were filed on November 3, 2026
The trustee filed three suits:
Henderson Harbor Group Limited Liability Company, over one $21,750 ACH payment made on November 15, 2024 Dkt. 2427.
Hye Tech Mechanical Limited Liability Company, over four transfers totaling $66,725.23. The trustee says $54,719.61 of invoices may count as subsequent new value Dkt. 2428.
iHeart Communications, Inc., over five transfers totaling $101,390 Dkt. 2429.
All three complaints describe payments Party City Corporation made during the preference period. Each seeks to avoid the payments as preferences under section 547, or in the alternative as constructive fraudulent transfers under section 548. Each also seeks recovery under section 550 and asks the court to disallow the defendant's claims under section 502 until the money is returned.
The IRS estimation order was vacated
The trustee objected to five IRS proofs of claim and moved to estimate them at $0 Dkt. 2440. The court granted the estimation motion on October 4, 2026. The United States then moved to vacate that order, and the trustee did not oppose Dkt. 2431. On November 5, 2026 the court vacated the order, finding cause under Civil Rule 60(b) as applied by Bankruptcy Rule 9024 Dkt. 2434.
The United States filed its response on November 9, 2026 Dkt. 2440. It makes these points:
The IRS issued an audit notice in November 2025, and the examination is still open.
A $5,909,238.58 refund processed in April 2026 was an automatically generated estimate made while the audit is pending.
Tax liabilities for 2017 and 2018 are still outstanding. Credits moved from the 2015 tax year cut the 2017 balance to $1,843,702.06, and an amended Claim No. 2687 will reflect that figure.
Claims 2241 and 2254 now stand at $0. Claims 2249 and 2250 were amended on October 19, 2026 to $6,424.97 and $6,190.33.
These are the government's arguments, not findings.
Party City returned to chapter 11 fourteen months after its first emergence
The second case's capital structure dates from that emergence. The ABL credit agreement is dated October 12, 2023. On the same day, Party City Holdco Inc. issued about $232.4 million of 12.00% senior secured second lien PIK toggle notes due 2029 Dkt. 45 · p. 11. The noteholders also owned the company: the disclosure statement says the ad hoc noteholder group held more than 97% of the equity Dkt. 1637.
At filing, Party City ran about 692 company-owned stores and about 29 franchised stores, including stores in Puerto Rico. It also had an e-commerce business and a consumer products business that designed, sourced and distributed party goods Dkt. 45. Public reporting put the chain at nearly 700 stores and about 12,000 employees npr.org: February 28, 2025 (outside source, not verified by ElevenFlo). Company histories trace the chain to a specialty retail roll-up that began in the late 1980s, with an early emphasis on Halloween merchandise fundinguniverse.com: early growth (outside source, not verified by ElevenFlo). Reference sources track its later ownership, including a private equity take-private and a return to the public markets en.wikipedia.org.
Party City ran short of cash within six weeks of a lower inventory appraisal. The pre-filing sequence as described in the first-day declaration of chief restructuring officer Deborah Rieger-Paganis.
Date
Event
September 2024
Company tries to raise more capital
About November 12, 2024
A preliminary appraisal lowers the net orderly liquidation value of the inventory that supports ABL and FILO availability
November 18, 2024
About $399 million of secured debt, led by $267.5 million of second lien notes
The cash collateral motion puts total funded debt at about $399 million at the petition date and says seven entities owe parts of it Dkt. 44 · p. 10. The disclosure statement rounds the total to about $400 million Dkt. 1675. All of the debt was secured. The first-lien ABL and FILO loans ranked ahead of the second lien notes, which were held mainly by the ad hoc noteholder group that also owned the equity.
The second lien notes were the largest part of Party City's funded debt at filingPrincipal at the December 21, 2024 petition date. ABL and FILO amounts are as stipulated in the cash collateral orders; the notes amount is from the first-day declaration. Excludes $30.9 million of letters of credit issued under the ABL. The total is the figure stated in the cash collateral motion.
First lien
Second lien
ABL revolving loansParty City Holdings Inc. and Party City Corporation · First$118.2M
FILO loansParty City Holdings Inc. and Party City Corporation · First$13.3M
12.00% second lien PIK toggle notes due 2029Party City Holdco Inc. · Second$267.5M
JPMorgan Chase Bank, N.A. is agent under the ABL credit agreement. As amended by the December 17, 2024 forbearance agreement, the agreement provides an asset-based revolver of up to $250 million, including $40 million of swingline loans and $60 million of letters of credit. It also provides $17.1 million of first-in, last-out (FILO) commitments. Party City Holdings Inc. and Party City Corporation are the borrowers, and the other debtors are guarantors. The facilities mature on October 12, 2028 and hold first liens on substantially all assets Dkt. 45 · p. 10. The cash collateral orders record these petition-date amounts: $118,165,942 of revolving loans, $30,942,000 of letters of credit and $13,312,000 of FILO loans Dkt. 1701.
Wilmington Savings Fund Society, FSB is trustee for the second lien notes. The notes mature on January 20, 2029 and hold second-priority liens behind the ABL and FILO liens. The first-day declaration puts the outstanding principal at about $268 million at the petition date, against about $232.4 million issued in October 2023 Dkt. 45 · p. 11. Its capital structure table gives the exact figure as $267,527,394 Dkt. 45 · p. 10. The cash collateral orders stipulate that the notes debt was not less than $232,394,231 Dkt. 1701. The plan allows the second lien notes claims at $267,703,631.42 .
Cash collateral, not a DIP loan, funded the wind-down and repaid the first-lien lenders
The debtors did not seek a DIP facility. The cash collateral motion asked to use the lenders' cash under a budget with weekly variance testing and case milestones. It also set up reserves large enough for the estate to finish the shutdown even if the lenders' consent ended. The motion set an outside date of March 31, 2025, which the directing cash collateral agent could extend Dkt. 44.
The first interim order, entered December 23, 2024, did the following Dkt. 65:
Funded a $28 million wind-down reserve and a $3.5 million WARN/severance reserve.
Capped professional fees incurred after a carve-out trigger notice at $1.75 million.
Allowed unfavorable budget variances of 20% on receipts and 17.5% on disbursements in the first week, tightening to 15% and 12.5% after that.
Required a rolling 13-week forecast and weekly variance reports starting in early January 2025.
Gave the creditors' committee $50,000 to investigate the prepetition liens.
The court renewed this authority in short steps. It entered seven interim orders between December 23, 2024 and July 8, 2025. An agreed order on August 26, 2025 then approved use under a revised budget through the week ending September 19, 2025 Dkt. 1820. That extension carried the case to the effective date.
The second interim order was entered on February 5, 2025 Dkt. 468. It extended use through March 31, 2025. It required current cash interest to the ABL lenders at the contractual default rate, back to January 1, 2025. It set stub rent for December 21 to 31, 2024 in three installments of 34%, 33% and 33%, due February 15, March 15 and May 15. It also raised the committee's investigation budget to $75,000.
By February the ABL and FILO balance had fallen to $77.65 million. The revised budget projected paying it off in full within 13 weeks Dkt. 499.
The February 2025 budget projected repaying the ABL and FILO balance in full within 13 weeks. Selected lines from the revised 13-week forecast ending April 26, 2025, converted from thousands of dollars. Not every line is shown, so the lines do not add up. The forecast started with $37.91 million of cash and left out the results of the February 6 and 7, 2025 auctions, which still needed court approval.
Line
13 weeks to April 26, 2025
Total cash collections
$246.5M
Operating disbursements
($146.9M)
From April, the orders sent more cash to the first-lien lenders:
The third interim order required the debtors to sweep cash above a $3 million floor to the ABL agent and to cash-collateralize outstanding letters of credit at 105% of face amount Dkt. 1127.
The fourth required sweeps every third business day of cash above $3 million, later $2.5 million. It also required a $1 million segregated deposit for unpaid postpetition rent, plus tax reserves of $14,241.35 for Broward County and $1,573,548.39 for Texas taxing authorities Dkt. 1178.
The sixth lowered the minimum cash balance to $2.0 million in May, $1.5 million in June and $1.0 million after that, with weekly sweeps starting May 9 Dkt. 1480.
The orders also paid the lenders' advisors: Simpson Thacher and Berkeley Research Group for the ABL agent, and Davis Polk, Haynes Boone and K&L Gates for the notes trustee Dkt. 1480.
The disclosure statement reports that the ABL and FILO debt was paid in full after the petition date Dkt. 1637. By the seventh interim order, entered July 8, 2025, adequate protection ran to the second lien notes parties, and their adequate protection liens were confirmed as first-priority liens. That order authorized use through August 31, 2025 Dkt. 1701. The August 26 agreed order names only the second lien notes trustee as the consenting secured party Dkt. 1820.
The committee's deadline to challenge the prepetition liens was extended by agreement with the ABL agent and the notes trustee: from March 7 to April 7 Dkt. 848, then to May 7 Dkt. 1020 and June 9, 2025 Dkt. 1263. The seventh interim order moved it to September 30, 2025. The deadline for all other parties had already passed on March 8, 2025 Dkt. 1701. The committee later joined the plan settlement .
Landlords objected to how cash collateral was used. On February 3, 2025 a group of landlords joined an objection filed by several other landlords Dkt. 445. On April 29, 2025 CBL & Associates Management, Inc. renewed its objection, alleging that the debtors had not paid March 2025 rent for a store at The Terrace in Chattanooga, Tennessee, even though the budget included it Dkt. 1293.
Stores closed on a lender-set calendar that ran to February 28, 2025
The cash collateral orders made the closing schedule a condition of continued funding. The first interim order required all stores to be liquidated and vacated by February 28, 2025 Dkt. 65. The second interim order let up to 525 “March Locations” stay open through March 31 and moved the real estate deadline to April 15 Dkt. 468.
The second interim order set the wind-down calendar. Milestones under the February 5, 2025 order. The first interim order had required all stores to be vacated by February 28, 2025 and the real estate sale process completed by March 31, 2025.
Deadline
Milestone
January 31, 2025
Gordon Brothers delivers a sales-performance report, with a recommendation on whether to continue sales into March
February 15, 2025
Ship all store inventory from the distribution center to the stores
Shortly after the petition date the court entered the sale procedures order Dkt. 94. It approved procedures for three things: sales of substantially all assets, small (de minimis) asset sales, and the assumption and assignment of executory contracts and unexpired leases. The debtors could choose qualified bidders, run auctions and select winning and backup bids. They could also name stalking horse bidders with bid protections, subject to notice and objection, with break-up fees capped at 3% of the purchase price. Counterparties could bid for their own contracts or leases. If a timely cure objection was not resolved by the sale hearing, the court could hear it later while the assignment went ahead with the disputed cure amount held in reserve.
Administrative and priority creditors share a capped pool; the noteholders take the remainder
The debtors filed their joint plan of liquidation and disclosure statement on June 19, 2025 Dkt. 1636. They amended both on June 26 Dkt. 1672. On June 30, after the court approved the disclosure statement for solicitation, they filed the solicitation versions Dkt. 1685. The plan rests on a settlement among the debtors, the ad hoc noteholder group and the official committee of unsecured creditors Dkt. 1675. On the effective date all assets vest in a liquidating trust, run by a trustee chosen by the ad hoc group and the committee. The trust funds a wind-down account and a professional fee escrow and may keep a reserve for disputed claims Dkt. 1672.
Every impaired voting class receives liquidating trust interests, and equity is canceled. Classes under the amended joint plan of liquidation filed June 26, 2025.
The waterfall works only if administrative and priority creditors accept less than full cash payment. Known holders were deemed to consent unless they opted out or objected by August 20, 2025. The plan could take effect only if opted-out administrative and priority claims totaled less than $1 million Dkt. 1685. The disclosure statement warned that if that cap were exceeded, the cases would likely convert to chapter 7, which could leave Classes 1, 3 and 4 with no recovery Dkt. 1675.
The plan also settles a dispute with Gordon Brothers over a $6.6 million claim Dkt. 1637. Gordon Brothers keeps a $1.5 million deposit, receives a $2.25 million initial payment and holds an allowed administrative claim of $2,729,333.03 Dkt. 1672. The plan includes debtor releases and third-party releases that bind holders who do not opt out. It also exculpates covered parties for acts from the petition date through the effective date, except gross negligence and willful misconduct Dkt. 1672.
The court approved the disclosure statement on a final basis and confirmed the plan on August 27, 2025 Dkt. 1827. The plan took effect on September 22, 2025, after its conditions were satisfied or waived Dkt. 1857. The effective-date notice set these terms:
Executory contracts and unexpired leases were deemed rejected on that date unless already assumed, expired or terminated, or subject to a pending motion.
Rejection damages claims are due within 30 days after the later of the rejection order and the rejection's effective date. If allowed, they are treated as Class 4 claims.
Requests for administrative claims arising after June 23, 2025 through the effective date were due 30 days after the effective date, October 22, 2025.
Final professional fee applications were due 45 days after the effective date, November 6, 2025, and are paid from the professional fee escrow Dkt. 1857.
Kroll Restructuring Administration LLC is the claims, noticing and solicitation agent Dkt. 58.