Patriot Coal: Second Chapter 11 and 363 Sale to Blackhawk Mining
ElevenFlo ·
Patriot Coal is in post-confirmation liquidation, with the PCC Liquidating Trust’s term extended through October 26, 2027, under the extension order Dkt. 3027. The trust’s principal remaining task is litigation against the West Virginia Tax Department, which it says is the only matter preventing closure of the Chapter 11 cases. Trust extension motion Dkt. 3023
Jump to section
Patriot Coal Corporation filed its second chapter 11 petition prnewswire.com: filed its second chapter 11 petition (outside source, not verified by ElevenFlo) on May 12, 2015 in the U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the Eastern District of Virginia (Richmond Division), case no. 15-32450, less than eighteen months after emerging from its first bankruptcy in the Eastern District of Missouri. The case was assigned to Hon. Keith L. Phillips. The petition was filed with substantially all operating assets in advanced sale negotiations Dkt. 22 with a strategic party, and the case ultimately resolved through a 363 sale to Blackhawk Mining LLC for the principal mining operations and to ERP Compliant Fuel, LLC, an affiliate of Virginia Conservation Legacy Fund, Inc., for the remaining assets.
The 2015 case proceeded as a sale-driven liquidating process rather than a balance-sheet reorganization. Patriot reported assets and liabilities each exceeding $1 billion finance.yahoo.com: assets and liabilities each exceeding $1 billion (outside source, not verified by ElevenFlo), employed approximately 2,840 full-time workers across eight active mining complexes in Northern and Central Appalachia, and entered the case with roughly $791 million of funded secured debt across four tranches. The plan was confirmed on October 9, 2015 and went effective on October 28, 2015, cancelling existing equity interests with no recovery to holders.
| Debtor(s) | Patriot Coal Corporation (and 50+ jointly administered affiliates) |
| Court | U.S. Bankruptcy Court, Eastern District of Virginia (Richmond Division) |
| Case Number | 15-32450 |
| Petition Date | May 12, 2015 |
| Confirmation Date | October 9, 2015 |
| Plan Effective Date | October 28, 2015 |
| Judge | Hon. Keith L. Phillips |
| DIP Facility | $100 million (final), with $30 million interim availability, led by prepetition secured debt holders |
Table: Case Snapshot
From 2013 Emergence to a Second Filing
Patriot was formed in 2007 as a spinoff from Peabody Energy Corporation gem.wiki: spinoff from Peabody Energy Corporation (outside source, not verified by ElevenFlo), and in connection with that spinoff Peabody transferred substantial legacy retiree healthcare, pension, and reclamation obligations to the new entity. In 2008 Patriot expanded the legacy book further by acquiring Magnum Coal Company from Arch Coal. The first chapter 11 followed in July 2012 in the Southern District of New York; the venue was transferred to the Eastern District of Missouri studicata.com: transferred to the Eastern District of Missouri (outside source, not verified by ElevenFlo) in November 2012 after that court found that Patriot had created shell subsidiaries to manufacture SDNY jurisdiction. Patriot emerged on December 18, 2013 with $576 million of exit financing arranged by Barclays and Deutsche Bank financierworldwide.com: exit financing arranged by Barclays and Deutsche Bank (outside source, not verified by ElevenFlo), comprising a $95 million ABL revolver, a $250 million term loan, and a $201 million letter of credit facility.
The first plan also produced the so-called Peabody Settlement psmag.com: Peabody Settlement (outside source, not verified by ElevenFlo), under which Peabody agreed to provide $310 million in cash contributions to the UMWA VEBA and $141 million in credit support for letters of credit and cash collateral previously posted by Patriot for UMWA retiree healthcare, Black Lung Act, and Coal Act obligations. The settlement funded union retiree healthcare obligations but did not address Patriot's standalone cost structure or its exposure to the metallurgical and thermal coal markets.
Coal prices kept falling. In late December 2014 Patriot idled its Highland Mine and Dodge Hill complex thesouthern.com: Highland Mine and Dodge Hill complex (outside source, not verified by ElevenFlo) in Kentucky, removing roughly 670 workers and approximately 3.9 million tons of annual thermal coal production from operations. By early 2015 Patriot was running eight active mining complexes producing thermal coal for electricity generators and metallurgical coal for steel and coke producers, with approximately 900 UMWA-represented employees among its 2,840 full-time workforce. CRO Ray Dombrowski's first day declaration pointed to continued weakened domestic and foreign coal demand, "burdensome government regulations," and unsustainable legacy and non-operating liabilities as the structural drivers behind the second filing. Operational setbacks during this period included a longwall move and a mine collapse at the Federal mining complex that disrupted production, and a planned sale of reserves at the Huff Creek mine that could not be consummated.
The proximate trigger for filing was an audit risk. Dombrowski stated that Patriot faced the prospect of a qualified going-concern audit opinion Dkt. 22, which would have constituted a default across the entire $791 million secured stack. Filing on May 12, 2015 averted the cross-default and put the company under court supervision while pre-petition asset sales and the broader marketing process continued.
Prepetition Capital Structure and the $791 Million Secured Stack
Patriot's first day declaration disclosed approximately $791 million Dkt. 22 of funded secured debt outstanding at the petition date, layered across four tranches with four different administrative or trustee parties:
- ABL Revolving Facility — $38 million outstanding, administered by Deutsche Bank AG New York Branch.
- L/C Facility — $200 million outstanding, administered by Barclays Bank PLC for the L/C lenders. The L/C facility was central to Patriot's surety, reclamation, and workers' compensation obligations and to the Peabody Settlement credit support.
- Term Loan Facility — $247 million outstanding, administered by Cortland Capital Market Services LLC for the term lenders.
- Second Lien Notes — $306 million outstanding, with U.S. Bank National Association as indenture trustee.
Barclays and Deutsche Bank had been the original 2013 exit-financing arrangers, while Cortland and U.S. Bank picked up the term and second-lien agent roles in 2015. Barclays later filed a September 2015 motion to convert the case to chapter 7 Dkt. 1334 and terminate the use of cash collateral in its capacity as L/C agent.
Patriot's principal unfunded liability stack came from its inheritance of legacy retiree, environmental, and black lung obligations from the Peabody spinoff and the Magnum Coal acquisition.
DIP Roll-Up From Secured Holders
Patriot sought authority for a debtor-in-possession financing facility of $30 million interim / $100 million final, structured as a roll-up and new-money package supplied by holders of the prepetition L/C and term debt. The interim DIP was approved at the first day hearings and the final DIP and cash collateral order Dkt. 230 was entered on June 4, 2015. The final order authorized continued use of cash collateral for the prepetition agents and lenders subject to adequate protection liens, milestones tied to the sale process, and a customary professional fee carve-out.
Press coverage at filing described the DIP as led by a consortium prnewswire.com: filed its second chapter 11 petition (outside source, not verified by ElevenFlo) of the company's secured debt holders. The Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors filed a limited objection to the cash collateral package, and the United Mine Workers of America objected later in the case to certain prepetition LC agent positions. Neither objection altered the DIP terms entered in early June.
Sale Process and the Path to Blackhawk Mining
The sale track was already partially built before the petition. Patriot entered chapter 11 with two signed asset purchase agreements: a sale of the Dodge Hill mining complex and undeveloped reserves to Alliance Resource Partners, and a sale of the Highland mining complex to Prairie Mining Company, LLC and Prairie Dock Company, LLC. The first day declaration disclosed that Patriot was also in "highly advanced" negotiations with a strategic party for substantially all of the remaining operating assets other than the Federal complex — the transaction that became the Blackhawk Mining sale.
The court approved bidding procedures and bid protections Dkt. 406 on June 25, 2015 for the broader sale process. The Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors and the UMWA 1974 Pension Plan and Trust each filed objections to portions of the procedures and assumption package, but the order was entered substantially as proposed. Through the summer Patriot also obtained an order approving assumption of the Prairie APAs Dkt. 953 on August 27, 2015 and a separate consent order resolving objections related to the Prairie transactions.
By mid-September 2015 Blackhawk Mining LLC 247wallst.com: Blackhawk Mining LLC (outside source, not verified by ElevenFlo) had emerged as the lead bidder — a privately-owned Kentucky operator that had previously acquired James River Coal's assets out of that company's 2014 bankruptcy. Blackhawk's bid covered Patriot's Panther, Rocklick, Wells, Kanawha Eagle, Paint Creek, and Midland Trail mining operations. ERP Compliant Fuel, LLC, an affiliate of Virginia Conservation Legacy Fund, Inc., acquired the remaining assets nrc.gov: the remaining assets (outside source, not verified by ElevenFlo), including the Hobet 21 mine and other reclamation-heavy operations. On October 9, 2015 the court entered the combined sale and confirmation order wvmetronews.com: combined sale and confirmation order (outside source, not verified by ElevenFlo) approving the Blackhawk and ERP/VCLF transactions over objections from state and federal regulators concerned about reclamation feasibility.
Plan Confirmation, Conversion Threat, and Equity Cancellation
On September 19, 2015 the prepetition L/C agent Barclays filed a motion to convert the case to chapter 7 and to terminate the use of cash collateral, citing concerns about the path of the sale process and the adequacy of protection for the L/C lenders. The motion drew objections from the United Mine Workers of America Dkt. 1528, the Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors, and Fifth Third Bank, which filed a joinder to the conversion motion to preserve its own position. The conversion motion was resolved alongside the sale and confirmation order rather than ruled on as a contested matter.
The court entered the order confirming the Fourth Amended Joint Plan Dkt. 1615 on October 9, 2015. The plan was structured to implement the Blackhawk and ERP/VCLF sale transactions, distribute the sale proceeds in accordance with the prepetition lien priority waterfall, and establish a liquidating trust to hold residual claims and avoidance actions. Patriot filed further plan supplements through December 28, 2015 Dkt. 2025 to refine the post-emergence trust mechanics.
The plan went effective on October 28, 2015. Patriot Coal Corporation common stock and other equity interests were cancelled on the effective date, and FINRA deemed the securities worthless finra.org: deemed the securities worthless (outside source, not verified by ElevenFlo) in a Uniform Practice Code notice issued the following day. The post-confirmation Patriot Coal Corporation Liquidating Trust subsequently pursued recovery actions, including an adversary proceeding for $5 million in tax refunds casemine.com: adversary proceeding for $5 million in tax refunds (outside source, not verified by ElevenFlo) against the West Virginia State Tax Department that was ultimately dismissed on sovereign immunity grounds.
Retiree Healthcare and the Alcoa Settlement Funds
A contested matter in the 2015 case involved approximately $18 million of proceeds from a prepetition Alcoa settlement that had been earmarked for retiree healthcare benefits. The funds had been allocated for the healthcare of 208 retired miners and their families grist.org: 208 retired miners and their families (outside source, not verified by ElevenFlo) in southern Indiana who had worked for Squaw Creek Coal Company, an entity whose benefit obligations had migrated to Patriot through prior corporate transfers. Patriot's professionals proposed redirecting the Alcoa settlement proceeds toward case professional fees rather than to the retiree benefit accounts. Then-presidential candidate Hillary Clinton called the proposal "outrageous" propublica.org: called the proposal "outrageous" (outside source, not verified by ElevenFlo), and Patriot withdrew the proposal.
Running in parallel with Patriot's case, Peabody Energy moved in the reopened first-case docket in the Eastern District of Missouri to exit the remaining $145 million of retiree healthcare credit support it had committed under the 2013 Peabody Settlement. The court granted Peabody's motion to reopen the closed first case to address the dispute, holding that the bankruptcy court retained jurisdiction to interpret its own settlement orders even after Patriot's second filing. The UMWA 1974 Pension Plan separately reported funded status of 37.7% as of 2018 congress.gov: funded status of 37.7% as of 2018 (outside source, not verified by ElevenFlo) and projected insolvency by 2022-2023.
Environmental Reclamation and Regulator Objections
Environmental regulators in Kentucky, Ohio, Pennsylvania, and West Virginia, together with federal regulators and environmental groups, opposed the Blackhawk sale plan wvmetronews.com: combined sale and confirmation order (outside source, not verified by ElevenFlo) on feasibility and statutory grounds, focusing on whether Blackhawk and ERP/VCLF could fund the reclamation obligations on Patriot's permitted sites. The objections did not block the sale, but the underlying concerns surfaced again in subsequent litigation: in March 2020 the West Virginia Department of Environmental Protection filed suit against ERP Environmental Fund, Inc. wvpublic.org: filed suit against ERP Environmental Fund, Inc. (outside source, not verified by ElevenFlo) seeking the appointment of a special receiver after ERP ceased operations and abandoned its mining sites, with the state alleging 160 environmental violations and seeking court intervention before reclamation costs shifted to taxpayers. ERP held a portfolio of reclamation-heavy sites that traced back to the 2015 Patriot transfer.
The Department of Labor handled the parallel federal black lung exposure differently. Effective October 31, 2015, DOL stopped accepting Patriot as responsible operator dol.gov: DOL stopped accepting Patriot as responsible operator (outside source, not verified by ElevenFlo) on Black Lung Benefits Act claims and shifted those claims to the Federal Black Lung Disability Trust Fund. Years later the Seventh Circuit vacated a Benefits Review Board decision law.justia.com: vacated a Benefits Review Board decision (outside source, not verified by ElevenFlo) that had assigned black lung liability for one Patriot subsidiary back to its former parent Arch Resources, holding in 2024 that there was no statutory basis to compel a parent corporation to pay benefits owed by a bankrupt former subsidiary under the relevant self-insurance arrangement. The 2015 Patriot case is now a frequently cited reference point in the policy debate over coal self-bonding debbiedingell.house.gov: coal self-bonding (outside source, not verified by ElevenFlo) and the financial assurance regime for reclamation.
Blackhawk itself entered chapter 11 in the District of Delaware on July 19, 2019 with a prepackaged plan to deleverage $1.09 billion minedocs.com: prepackaged plan to deleverage $1.09 billion (outside source, not verified by ElevenFlo) of debt, part of the so-called "Phase 2" wave of coal bankruptcies sierraclub.org: "Phase 2" wave of coal bankruptcies (outside source, not verified by ElevenFlo) characterized by the sale of high-liability mines from larger operators to smaller entities.
Key Timeline
The 2015 case ran approximately 169 days from the May 12, 2015 petition prnewswire.com: filed its second chapter 11 petition (outside source, not verified by ElevenFlo) to the October 28, 2015 plan effective date.
| Date | Event |
|---|---|
| October 31, 2007 | Patriot Coal spun off from Peabody Energy with legacy retiree liabilities transferred |
| 2008 | Patriot acquires Magnum Coal Company from Arch Coal |
| July 9, 2012 | First chapter 11 filing in SDNY |
| November 2012 | First case transferred from SDNY to Eastern District of Missouri |
| December 17–18, 2013 | First plan confirmed and effective; $576M exit financing closes |
| Late December 2014 | Highland and Dodge Hill complexes idled; about 670 workers affected |
| May 12, 2015 | Second chapter 11 filed in Eastern District of Virginia, case 15-32450 |
| June 4, 2015 | Final DIP and cash collateral order entered |
| June 25, 2015 | Bidding procedures and bid protections approved |
| August 27, 2015 | Prairie Mining asset purchase agreements assumed |
| September 19, 2015 | Prepetition L/C agent files motion to convert to chapter 7 and terminate cash collateral use |
| October 9, 2015 | Sale and confirmation order entered; Blackhawk and ERP/VCLF transactions approved |
| October 28, 2015 | Plan effective date; equity cancelled |
| October 31, 2015 | DOL stops administering federal black lung claims through Patriot |
| December 28, 2015 | Third amended plan supplement filed |
Frequently Asked Questions
Who is the claims agent for Patriot Coal Corporation's 2015 case?
Prime Clerk LLC was retained as the claims and noticing agent. The firm maintains the official claims register and distributes case notifications to creditors and parties in interest.
Who acquired Patriot Coal's mining operations?
Blackhawk Mining LLC acquired the principal operating mines, including Panther, Rocklick, Wells, Kanawha Eagle, Paint Creek, and Midland Trail. ERP Compliant Fuel, LLC, an affiliate of Virginia Conservation Legacy Fund, Inc., acquired the remaining assets, including the Hobet 21 mine. The court approved both transactions on October 9, 2015.
What happened to Patriot Coal's prepetition equity?
All existing equity interests were cancelled on the October 28, 2015 plan effective date. FINRA issued a Uniform Practice Code notice the following day deeming the securities worthless.
Who served as restructuring counsel in the 2015 case?
Kirkland & Ellis LLP served as lead restructuring counsel kirkland.com: lead restructuring counsel (outside source, not verified by ElevenFlo), with Kutak Rock LLP as Virginia local counsel. Centerview Partners served as investment banker.
Why did Patriot file a second chapter 11 less than two years after emerging?
The CRO's first day declaration cited continued weakened coal demand, regulatory burden, unsustainable legacy and non-operating liabilities, and operational setbacks at the Federal mining complex. The proximate filing trigger was the risk of a qualified going-concern audit opinion that would have defaulted Patriot's $791 million secured debt stack.
For more bankruptcy case coverage, visit the ElevenFlo bankruptcy blog.
Sources
- Dkt. 22First Day DeclarationFiled May 12, 2015May 12, 2015
- Dkt. 230Final Order Authorizing (A) Authorizing The Debtors To Obtain Postpetition Financing, (B) Authorizing Use Of Cash Collateral, (C) Granting Liens And Superpriority Claims, (D) Granting Adequate Protection, (E) Modifying The Automatic Stay, (F) Scheduling A Final Hearing, And (G) Granting Related Relief (Related Doc # 30) Motion to Approve Debtor in Possession Financing (Related Doc # 30) (Smith, Linda)Filed Jun 4, 2015Jun 4, 2015
- Dkt. 406Order Approving Debtors' Motion for Entry of an Order (A) Approving Bidding Procedures and Bid Protections in Connection With the Sales of Certain of the Debtors' Assets, (B) Approving the Form and Manner of Notice, (C) Scheduling Auctions and a Sale Hearing, (D) Approving Procedures for the Assumption and Assignment of Contracts, and (E) Granting Related Relief (Related Doc # 200) (Smith, Linda)Filed Jun 25, 2015Jun 25, 2015
- Dkt. 953Order (I) Authorizing the Debtors to (A) Assume the Prairie Asset Purchase Agreements Pursuant to Section 365 of the Bankruptcy Code, (B) Close the Prairie Transactions, Including by Selling the Prairie Assets Pursuant to Section 363 of the Bankruptcy Code, (C) Assume and Assign Underlying Contracts and Leases Pursuant to Section 365 of the Bankruptcy Code, and (II) Compelling Prairie to Close the Prairie Transactions (Related Doc # 730) (Smith, Linda)Filed Aug 27, 2015Aug 27, 2015
- Dkt. 1334Motion to Convert Case to Chapter 7 (Motion of Prepetition LC Agent for an Order Terminating the Use of Cash Collateral and Converting the Debtors' Chapter 11 Cases to Cases Under Chapter 7) filed by Henry Pollard Long III of Hunton & Williams, LLP on behalf of Barclays Bank PLC. (Long, Henry)Filed Sep 19, 2015Sep 19, 2015
- Dkt. 1528Objection to (Objection of the United Mine Workers of America to the Motion of Prepetition LC Agent for an Order Terminating the Use of Cash Collateral and Converting the Debtors' Chapter 11 Cases to Cases Under Chapter 7) (Re: related document(s)1334 Motion to Convert Case to Chapter 7 filed by Barclays Bank PLC) filed by Troy Savenko of Kaplan, Voekler, Cunningham & Frank, PLC on behalf of United Mine Workers of America. (Savenko, Troy)Filed Oct 2, 2015Oct 2, 2015
- Dkt. 1615Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law and Order (I) Confirming the Debtors' Fourth Amended Joint Plan of Reorganization Pursuant to Chapter 11 of the Bankruptcy Code and (II) Approving the Fourth Amended Disclosure Statement (Re: related document(s)1332 Chapter 11 Plan filed by Patriot Coal Corporation, 1579 Amended/Modified Chapter 11 Plan filed by Patriot Coal Corporation) (Manley, Candace)Filed Oct 9, 2015Oct 9, 2015
- Dkt. 2025Statement Notice of Filing of Third Amended Plan Supplement filed by Michael A. Condyles of Kutak Rock LLP on behalf of Patriot Coal Corporation. (Condyles, Michael)Filed Dec 28, 2015Dec 28, 2015
- Dkt. 3023Trust Term Extension MotionFiled Sep 22, 2026Sep 22, 2026
- Dkt. 3027Trust Term ExtendedFiled Oct 19, 2026Oct 19, 2026
- Webfiled its second chapter 11 petitionprnewswire.com · Outside source, not verified by ElevenFlo
- Webassets and liabilities each exceeding $1 billionfinance.yahoo.com · Outside source, not verified by ElevenFlo
- Webspinoff from Peabody Energy Corporationgem.wiki · Outside source, not verified by ElevenFlo
- Webtransferred to the Eastern District of Missouristudicata.com · Outside source, not verified by ElevenFlo
- Webexit financing arranged by Barclays and Deutsche Bankfinancierworldwide.com · Outside source, not verified by ElevenFlo
- WebPeabody Settlementpsmag.com · Outside source, not verified by ElevenFlo
- WebHighland Mine and Dodge Hill complexthesouthern.com · Outside source, not verified by ElevenFlo
- WebBlackhawk Mining LLC247wallst.com · Outside source, not verified by ElevenFlo
- Webthe remaining assetsnrc.gov · Outside source, not verified by ElevenFlo
- Webcombined sale and confirmation orderwvmetronews.com · Outside source, not verified by ElevenFlo
- Webdeemed the securities worthlessfinra.org · Outside source, not verified by ElevenFlo
- Webadversary proceeding for $5 million in tax refundscasemine.com · Outside source, not verified by ElevenFlo
- Web208 retired miners and their familiesgrist.org · Outside source, not verified by ElevenFlo
- Webcalled the proposal "outrageous"propublica.org · Outside source, not verified by ElevenFlo
- Webfunded status of 37.7% as of 2018congress.gov · Outside source, not verified by ElevenFlo
- Webfiled suit against ERP Environmental Fund, Inc.wvpublic.org · Outside source, not verified by ElevenFlo
- WebDOL stopped accepting Patriot as responsible operatordol.gov · Outside source, not verified by ElevenFlo
- Webvacated a Benefits Review Board decisionlaw.justia.com · Outside source, not verified by ElevenFlo
- Webcoal self-bondingdebbiedingell.house.gov · Outside source, not verified by ElevenFlo
- Webprepackaged plan to deleverage $1.09 billionminedocs.com · Outside source, not verified by ElevenFlo
- Web"Phase 2" wave of coal bankruptciessierraclub.org · Outside source, not verified by ElevenFlo
- Weblead restructuring counselkirkland.com · Outside source, not verified by ElevenFlo