RTW Retailwinds liquidation trust seeks at least $5.9 million in undelivered IRS refunds after paying unsecured creditors 39%
ElevenFlo ·
RTW Retailwinds’ liquidation trustee wants the court to compel the IRS to turn over at least $5,929,340.15 in employee retention credit refunds that it says the IRS allowed but repeatedly sent to the wrong address Dkt. 1259; the United States disputes the credits and the court’s jurisdiction Dkt. 1256. A hearing was held October 27, 2026, and no order appears in the filings through November 1; the outcome bears on any final distribution to unsecured creditors, who have received about 39% Dkt. 1258.
Jump to section
The United States disputes the credits and argues the trust must sue for them in another federal court. A hearing was held on October 27, 2026, the date set for the motion.
RTW Retailwinds, Inc., formerly New York & Company, Inc., ran a sale process for substantially all of its assets and confirmed a liquidation plan in 2020. What remains is the RTW Liquidation Trust, run by trustee META Advisors LLC, which is trying to collect employee retention credit refunds from the IRS. The trust’s report for the quarter ended September 30, 2026 says allowed administrative, secured and priority claims have been paid in full and general unsecured creditors have received about 39% through interim distributions. Any final distribution depends in part on the refund proceeds and the trust’s operating expenses Dkt. 1258.
The trustee has moved to compel the IRS to turn over refunds it says the IRS has already allowed. Its October 22, 2026 reply says the IRS issued checks for affiliate Lerner New York’s second, third and fourth quarters of 2020 and for RTW’s second quarter of 2020, that the checks were returned as undeliverable, and that at least $5,929,340.15 was owed on them when the motion was filed, with interest accruing Dkt. 1259. The United States disputes the trust’s entitlement to all of the credits, argues that the bankruptcy court lacks jurisdiction, and asks the court to deny the motion, defer a ruling for discovery, or abstain Dkt. 1256.
A hearing was held on October 27, 2026, the date set for the motion, and its transcript was filed on November 1 Dkt. 1265. No order on the motion, or on the United States’ request to file a sur-reply, appears in the filings through that date. The trustee’s October report gives March 31, 2027 as a placeholder date for applying for a final decree and says the date cannot be predicted with certainty Dkt. 1258; its July report had used December 31, 2026 Dkt. 1251.
The IRS issued the refunds repeatedly, then declared them disputed
The refund requests were filed on October 31, 2022, on amended Forms 941-X in the names of the debtors Lerner New York, Inc. and RTW Retailwinds, Inc., not the trust or the trustee, according to a declaration by Michael Infanti of Giuliano Miller & Co. filed with the trustee’s reply Dkt. 1260. He reports that the IRS sent Lerner’s checks to an incorrect addressee or address five times for the second quarter of 2020, four times for the third and three times for the fourth, and understands that RTW’s checks were misissued twice, in June 2023 and August 2026. None had reached the trust as of October 22, 2026.
Infanti says the IRS asked for another change-of-address form (Form 8822-B) and, at IRS counsel’s direction, was to stop payment on the outstanding checks and reissue them directly to META Advisors. He was then told that the government, through the Department of Justice, would not reissue the checks and now treats them as disputed Dkt. 1260. The United States’ September 14, 2026 response confirms that position: it says it will not reissue checks for the periods at issue because no audit had been conducted, and that the tax periods were referred to the Department of Justice on September 9, 2026 Dkt. 1256.
The trustee first noticed the motion for a July 28, 2026 hearing Dkt. 1248. It also asked the court to take judicial notice of a June 15, 2026 order in the Boxed, Inc. bankruptcy directing turnover of an employee retention credit refund; the related motion described a $1,574,515.32 check issued to Giddy, Inc. that it said had been returned to the IRS undelivered Dkt. 1249.
The United States treats the motion as a contested refund suit
The government’s response argues that the court lacks subject-matter jurisdiction because the post-confirmation trustee, rather than a debtor in possession, filed the administrative refund claims, and that any refund must be sought in federal district court or the Court of Federal Claims. It says discovery is needed and that the relevant records are largely in the trust’s possession. It points to possible problems drawn from the debtors’ own earlier statements, including whether employees were paid for periods when they were not performing services and whether the $10,000 qualified-wage cap was applied correctly, but presents these as questions for discovery, not findings Dkt. 1256.
On October 24, 2026, the United States moved for leave to file a sur-reply Dkt. 1261, with an application to shorten time so the request could be heard by October 27 Dkt. 1262. The motion accuses the trust’s reply of making demonstrably false representations about tax refund law and wage eligibility. The proposed sur-reply argues that a disputed claim is a refund request governed by section 505 of the Bankruptcy Code and 26 U.S.C. § 7422, reviewed de novo with the burden on the taxpayer; that 26 U.S.C. § 1313 reaches only the tax code’s mitigation provisions; and that for large employers the wage restriction applies under either the suspension test or the gross-receipts test. It suggests the trust’s professionals may have calculated the second- through fourth-quarter credits using wages paid to employees who were performing services Dkt. 1261.
The trustee says it is collecting allowed refunds, not litigating a tax claim
The reply frames the motion as turnover, under sections 542 and 1142(b) of the Bankruptcy Code, of refunds the IRS already allowed, not a first-instance tax determination under section 505. It says the problem is misdirected delivery, including checks reissued in September 2026, not entitlement. It opposes a delay for discovery because the IRS processed and repeatedly issued the refunds before raising eligibility, and says the objection addresses only one of two independent eligibility bases. It opposes abstention because the dispute involves federal turnover and plan implementation, with no state-law issue or parallel proceeding, and because the recovery is needed for final distributions to unsecured creditors Dkt. 1259.
Infanti’s declaration supplies the second basis. He states that gross sales in each of the second, third and fourth quarters of 2020 were 50% lower than in the same 2019 quarter, and that third-quarter 2020 sales did not exceed 80% of third-quarter 2019 sales. On his account, only the first-quarter 2020 claims rest solely on employees not performing services because of a governmental order; the later quarters qualify under both the gross-receipts and governmental-order tests Dkt. 1260.
A separate first-quarter 2020 refund claim for Lerner remains unresolved. For those “Open ERCs,” the trustee asks only that the court direct the United States to name a knowledgeable contact authorized to address the claim, such as the assigned Justice Department trial attorney, not that it order a settlement or decide the merits Dkt. 1259. The United States says the September 9 referral gave the Justice Department primary settlement authority and left the IRS unable to resolve the claims Dkt. 1256.
Unsecured creditors have received $92.3 million on $238.3 million of allowed claims
The trust’s report for the quarter ended June 30, 2026 puts cumulative distributions to general unsecured creditors at $92,310,180, or 39% of allowed claims listed at $238,308,758. It describes a possible fourth and final distribution that depends on future litigation and asset-liquidation receipts and on the trust’s operating expenses and duration. The allowed-claims pool may also change because of potential disallowances tied to missing tax documents or uncashed interim checks, and the report lists anticipated plan payments to unsecured creditors as $0 because the amount is unknown Dkt. 1251. The plan provides no distributions on equity interests.
The trust began with about $102.8 million in initial trust funds Dkt. 1251. Through September 30, 2026 it had disbursed $104,543,810 since the effective date, including $114,331 in the third quarter of 2026, and it made no distributions in the second or third quarter of 2026. Cumulative approved and paid bankruptcy professional fees and expenses stand at $4,737,519 Dkt. 1258.
The reports also flag a possible fee dispute with the U.S. Trustee. The trust says it previously paid the statutory maximum fee on the initial trust funds and has paid only the $250 quarterly minimum since the first quarter of 2021. Its September report notes that cumulative disbursements now exceed the effective-date cash on which fees were paid by $1,744,717, maintains that no additional fee is due, and reserves its rights Dkt. 1258.
- Allowed general unsecured claimsTrust report, quarter ended June 30, 2026$238.3M
- Paid to unsecured creditors to dateTrust report, quarter ended June 30, 2026$92.3M
- Issued refunds sought from the IRSTrustee’s reply, October 22, 2026$5.9M
Show the numbers
| Item | Source | Amount |
|---|---|---|
| Allowed general unsecured claims | Trust report, quarter ended June 30, 2026 | $238.3M |
| Paid to unsecured creditors to date | Trust report, quarter ended June 30, 2026 | $92.3M |
| Issued refunds sought from the IRS | Trustee’s reply, October 22, 2026 | $5.9M |
RTW filed owing $24.1 million on one secured facility and more than $115 million to unsecured creditors
RTW was a New York-based specialty women’s retailer selling through 387 stores in 32 states and online under the New York & Company and Fashion to Figure brands, with about 4,556 employees and distribution handled by third-party facilities in Ohio and Virginia. Twelve affiliated debtors filed chapter 11 petitions in New Jersey on July 13, 2020 Dkt. 25 · p. 1, and the cases were jointly administered Dkt. 7.
The debtors’ only funded debt was an asset-based revolving facility under a Fourth Amended and Restated Loan and Security Agreement dated October 24, 2014, with Wells Fargo Bank, National Association as administrative agent and lender. It provided $75 million of revolving commitments, including a $10 million letter-of-credit sub-facility, matured October 24, 2024, and bore interest by reference to LIBOR or a base rate Dkt. 25 · p. 12. The first-day declaration of Robert Shapiro states that $24,074,309 in aggregate principal was outstanding under the facility at the petition date Dkt. 25 · p. 11. The facility was secured by a first-priority lien on substantially all assets, including receivables, inventory, deposit accounts and cash but excluding intellectual property, and deposit account control agreements placed substantially all of the debtors’ cash under the lender’s perfected security interest Dkt. 25 · p. 12.
The cash collateral papers describe the balance differently. The motion puts revolving loans at not less than approximately $12,716,045.60 as of July 10, 2020, plus letters of credit with an undrawn face amount of approximately $7,124,274.20 and accrued interest, fees and other obligations Dkt. 24 · p. 4; the interim order recites the same two figures as of the petition date Dkt. 49 · p. 7.
Unsecured claims were far larger. The declaration estimated them at more than $115 million at the petition date, covering trade and vendor debt and rent and other lease obligations, and expected them to exceed $200 million as leases were rejected Dkt. 25 · p. 13. Allowed general unsecured claims now stand at $238,308,758, according to the trust’s June 2026 report.
Wells Fargo consented to the use of its cash collateral through three orders
The debtors financed the case with consensual use of the lender’s cash collateral. The court entered an interim order on July 15, 2020 Dkt. 49, a second interim order on August 26, 2020 Dkt. 259, and a final order on October 29, 2020 that incorporated both interim orders and granted their adequate protection on a final basis Dkt. 511. The second interim order preserved rights to contest the priority, validity, amount and extent of claims and liens asserted by Texas taxing authorities.
The interim order set two lender milestones: entry of an acceptable final order by August 10, 2020, and payment in full of the outstanding obligations by August 31, 2020, each unless the agent consented in writing. The second interim order scheduled the final hearing for October 6, 2020. Separately, a September 15, 2020 order authorized the debtors to obtain postpetition unsecured credit in the ordinary course of business Dkt. 337.
A sale process and a liquidation plan took five months
On August 10, 2020, the court approved bidding procedures and a form of asset purchase agreement for a sale of substantially all of the debtors’ assets, together with procedures for assuming and assigning contracts and leases Dkt. 192. A November 16, 2020 order authorized a private sale of real property free and clear of liens, claims and interests Dkt. 580.
The debtors filed their disclosure statement on September 30, 2020 Dkt. 389. The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission objected to its approval; the debtors answered on October 26 with a supplemental submission and revised versions of the plan and disclosure statement Dkt. 498, and filed the solicitation versions on October 29 Dkt. 523. The court confirmed the joint plan of liquidation on December 11, 2020 Dkt. 690, and the plan became effective on December 31, 2020 Dkt. 742.
On February 22, 2021, the court entered an order granting a motion for a final decree Dkt. 844. The trust has continued to report and litigate in the case since then, and its 2026 reports treat a final-decree application as a step still to come.
Sources
- Dkt. 7ORDER PURSUANT TO FED. R. BANKRUPTCY P. 1015(b) DIRECTING JOINT ADMINISTRATION OF RELATED CHAPTER 11 CASES. Lead Case: 20-18445 Member Cases: 20-18448 (Related Doc # 4). Service of notice of the entry of this order pursuant to Rule 9022 was made on the appropriate parties. See BNC Certificate of Notice. Signed on 7/15/2020.Filed Jul 16, 2020Jul 16, 2020
- Dkt. 24Motion re: Debtors' Motion for Entry of Interim and Final Orders (I) Authorizing Use of Cash Collateral and Affording Adequate Protection; (II) Modifying Automatic Stay; (III) Scheduling a Final Hearing; and (IV) Granting Related Relief Filed by Stuart Komrower on behalf of RTW Retailwinds, Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit A - Proposed Interim Order # 2 Exhibit B - Loan Abstract # 3 Exhibit C - Budget)Cited at p. 4 · Filed Jul 13, 2020Jul 13, 2020
- Dkt. 25Document re: Declaration of Robert Shapiro in Support of Debtors' Chapter 11 Petitions and First Day Motions filed by Michael D. Sirota on behalf of RTW Retailwinds, Inc..Filed Jul 13, 2020Jul 13, 2020
- Dkt. 49INTERIM ORDER (I) AUTHORIZING USE OF CASH COLLATERAL AND AFFORDING ADEQUATE PROTECTION; (II) MODIFYING AUTOMATIC STAY; (III) SCHEDULING A FINAL HEARING; AND (IV) GRANTING RELATED RELIEF (Related Doc # 24). Service of notice of the entry of this order pursuant to Rule 9022 was made on the appropriate parties. See BNC Certificate of Notice. Signed on 7/15/2020.Cited at p. 7 · Filed Jul 15, 2020Jul 15, 2020
- Dkt. 192ORDER (A) APPROVING BIDDING PROCEDURES AND FORM OF ASSET PURCHASE AGREEMENT IN CONNECTION WITH THE SALE OF SUBSTANTIALLY ALL OF THE DEBTORS ASSETS, (B) APPROVING PROCEDURES FOR THE ASSUMPTION AND ASSIGNMENT OF EXECUTORY CONTRACTS AND UNEXPIRED LEASES, AND (C) GRANTING RELATED RELIEF (Related Doc # 80). Service of notice of the entry of this order pursuant to Rule 9022 was made on the appropriate parties. See BNC Certificate of Notice. Signed on 8/8/2020.Filed Aug 10, 2020Aug 10, 2020
- Dkt. 259SECOND INTERIM ORDER (I) AUTHORIZING USE OF CASH COLLATERAL AND AFFORDING ADEQUATE PROTECTION; (II) MODIFYING AUTOMATIC STAY; (III) SCHEDULING A FINAL HEARING; AND (IV) GRANTING RELATED RELIEF (related document:24 Motion re: Debtors' Motion for Entry of Interim and Final Orders (I) Authorizing Use of Cash Collateral and Affording Adequate Protection; (II) Modifying Automatic Stay; (III) Scheduling a Final Hearing; and (IV) Granting Related Relief Filed by Stuart Komrower on behalf of RTW Retailwinds, Inc.). Service of notice of the entry of this order pursuant to Rule 9022 was made on the appropriate parties. See BNC Certificate of Notice. Signed on 8/26/2020.Filed Aug 26, 2020Aug 26, 2020
- Dkt. 337Order Granting Motion for Entry of an Order Authorizing the Debtors to Obtain Postpetition Unsecured Credit and Incur Postpetition Unsecured Debt in the Ordinary Course of Business. (Related Doc # 225). Service of notice of the entry of this order pursuant to Rule 9022 was made on the appropriate parties. See BNC Certificate of Notice. Signed on 9/15/2020.Filed Sep 15, 2020Sep 15, 2020
- Dkt. 389Disclosure Statement Filed by Michael D. Sirota on behalf of RTW Retailwinds, Inc..Filed Sep 30, 2020Sep 30, 2020
- Dkt. 498Debtors' (I) Supplemental Submission in Support of Motion for Entry of an Order (A) Approving the Adequacy of the Disclosure Statement, (B) Scheduling a Hearing on Plan Confirmation and Deadlines Related Thereto, (C) Approving the Solicitation, Notice and Tabulation Procedures and the Forms Related Thereto, and (D) Granting Related Relief, and (II) Reply to the Objection Thereto Filed by the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission in support of (related document:392 Motion (Generic) filed by Debtor RTW Retailwinds, Inc.) filed by Ryan T. Jareck on behalf of RTW Retailwinds, Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit A-1 - Proposed Order # 2 Exhibit A-2 - Redline of Proposed Order # 3 Exhibit B - Transcript Excerpts # 4 Exhibit C-1 - Plan # 5 Exhibit C-2 - Redline of Plan # 6 Exhibit D-1 - Disclosure Statement # 7 Exhibit D-2 - Redline of Disclosure Statement)Filed Oct 26, 2020Oct 26, 2020
- Dkt. 511FINAL ORDER (I) AUTHORIZING USE OF CASH COLLATERAL AND AFFORDING ADEQUATE PROTECTION; (II) MODIFYING AUTOMATIC STAY; AND (III) GRANTING RELATED RELIEF (related document:24 Motion re: Debtors' Motion for Entry of Interim and Final Orders (I) Authorizing Use of Cash Collateral and Affording Adequate Protection; Filed by Stuart Komrower on behalf of RTW Retailwinds, Inc.). Service of notice of the entry of this order pursuant to Rule 9022 was made on the appropriate parties. See BNC Certificate of Notice. Signed on 10/29/2020.Filed Oct 29, 2020Oct 29, 2020
- Dkt. 523Document re: Notice of Filing of Solicitation Version of Debtors' Disclosure Statement and Joint Plan of Liquidation filed by Ryan T. Jareck on behalf of RTW Retailwinds, Inc..Filed Oct 29, 2020Oct 29, 2020
- Dkt. 580Order Authorizing the Private Sale of Real Property Free and Clear of Liens, Claims, Encumbrances and Interests. (Related Doc # 424). Service of notice of the entry of this order pursuant to Rule 9022 was made on the appropriate parties. See BNC Certificate of Notice. Signed on 11/16/2020.Filed Nov 16, 2020Nov 16, 2020
- Dkt. 690FINDINGS OF FACT, CONCLUSIONS OF LAW, AND ORDER CONFIRMING THE JOINT PLAN OF LIQUIDATION OF RTW RETAILWINDS, INC. AND AFFILIATED DEBTORS PURSUANT TOCHAPTER 11 OF THE BANKRUPTCY CODE . (related document:390 Chapter 11 Plan filed by Debtor RTW Retailwinds, Inc.). Service of notice of the entry of this order pursuant to Rule 9022 was made on the appropriate parties. See BNC Certificate of Notice. Signed on 12/10/2020.Filed Dec 11, 2020Dec 11, 2020
- Dkt. 742Document re: Notice of (A) Entry of Order Confirming the Joint Plan of Liquidation of RTW Retailwinds, Inc. and Affiliated Debtors Pursuant to Chapter 11 of the Bankruptcy Code; (B) the Effective Date Thereof; and (C) Certain Deadlines (related document:690 Order Confirming Chapter 11 Plan) filed by Ryan T. Jareck on behalf of RTW Retailwinds, Inc..Filed Dec 31, 2020Dec 31, 2020
- Dkt. 844Order Granting Motion For Final Decree (Related Doc # 808). Service of notice of the entry of this order pursuant to Rule 9022 was made on the appropriate parties. See BNC Certificate of Notice. Signed on 2/22/2021.Filed Feb 22, 2021Feb 22, 2021
- Dkt. 1248Hearing Notice on IRS MotionFiled Jun 25, 2026Jun 25, 2026
- Dkt. 1249Request for Judicial NoticeFiled Jul 6, 2026Jul 6, 2026
- Dkt. 1251Quarterly Trust ActivityFiled Jul 13, 2026Jul 13, 2026
- Dkt. 1256United States’ ERC ResponseFiled Sep 14, 2026Sep 14, 2026
- Dkt. 1258Third Quarter Trustee ReportFiled Oct 15, 2026Oct 15, 2026
- Dkt. 1259Trustee Reply on IRS RefundsFiled Oct 22, 2026Oct 22, 2026
- Dkt. 1260Infanti Declaration on ERC RefundsFiled Oct 22, 2026Oct 22, 2026
- Dkt. 1261Motion for Sur-Reply LeaveFiled Oct 24, 2026Oct 24, 2026
- Dkt. 1262Sur-Reply Time ApplicationFiled Oct 24, 2026Oct 24, 2026
- Dkt. 1265Transcript Filing NoticeFiled Nov 1, 2026Nov 1, 2026