SafeMoon chapter 7 trustee pursues former executives over alleged $100 million liquidity-pool scheme
ElevenFlo ·
SafeMoon US, LLC remains in chapter 7 liquidation. Trustee Ellen E. Ostrow is pursuing five adversary suits filed December 12, 2025, the largest alleging that former executives misappropriated assets from the SafeMoon token's liquidity pool in a scheme of at least $100 million Dkt. 1. On November 3 and 4, 2026, the court allowed interim fees to four estate professionals, including $644,475.59 for Foley & Lardner Dkt. 433. A fee-application hearing is set for November 18, 2026.
Jump to section
Recoveries in the liquidation depend on cryptocurrency sales and five adversary suits filed in December 2025. Meanwhile, the court continues to allow interim fees for the trustee's professionals.
SafeMoon US, LLC is in chapter 7 liquidation in the District of Utah under trustee Ellen E. Ostrow. The cryptocurrency company filed its chapter 7 petition on December 14, 2023 Dkt. 1. The estate's path centers on two sources of value: cryptocurrency the court has authorized the trustee to sell, and five adversary suits filed on December 12, 2025 to recover transferred assets and challenge claims.
The latest activity is fee administration. On November 3 and 4, 2026, the court entered interim orders allowing compensation to four estate professionals. The largest award is $644,475.59 in fees and expenses for Foley & Lardner LLP, the trustee's general bankruptcy counsel Dkt. 433. A proposed order on a fifth application was lodged on November 6, and a fee-application hearing is scheduled for November 18, 2026.
What remains to be decided is mostly litigation. The largest suit alleges that former executives misappropriated assets from the SafeMoon token's liquidity pool in a scheme of no less than $100 million Dkt. 1. The other four seek turnover of tokens held by the BitMart exchange, recovery of cryptocurrency taken in a March 2023 exploit, and avoidance of payments to service providers whose claims the trustee also seeks to disallow. Each complaint states allegations and requested relief. Their outcomes, together with crypto sale proceeds and the cost of administration, will determine what creditors receive.
The token's liquidity pool is at the center of the estate's claims
SafeMoon US, LLC, based in Pleasant Grove, Utah, with offices in Miami, created and issued the SafeMoon token (SFM), a digital asset trading on the BNB Chain. Kyle Nagy founded the company in March 2021. By April 2021 the token's total market capitalization had reached the billions of dollars, with Braden John Karony as chief executive. The business covered token issuance, liquidity pool management and a portfolio of blockchain-related patents and trademarks.
The trustee's complaint against the former executives describes how the token was marketed. It alleges that the executives said a 10% tax on each transaction would fund a "locked" liquidity pool for token holders. Instead, it alleges, they used a "Swap and Liquify" function to mint liquidity tokens they controlled and withdrew tens of millions of dollars in BNB tokens and fiat currency Dkt. 1. The complaint recounts that the former executives were indicted in the Eastern District of New York in 2023. It says chief technology officer Thomas Smith pleaded guilty in February 2025 and a jury convicted Karony in May 2025 of conspiracy to commit securities fraud, wire fraud and money laundering.
A second loss came in March 2023, when the company deployed a smart contract with a flaw in its burn function. According to the trustee, an automated bot intercepted a hacker's attempt to manipulate the SFM/BNB liquidity pool and took about 27,388.6 BNB, then worth about $8.58 million Dkt. 1. A party describing itself as a "white hat" hacker, represented by Alston & Bird LLP, returned 80% (21,904 BNB) before the petition and kept the rest. The U.S. government later seized about 2,652 BNB, valued at about $831,210, which the trustee says remains in federal custody Dkt. 1. The company filed for chapter 7 nine months after the exploit.
Five suits filed on December 12, 2025 carry the estate's main recovery claims
The trustee filed five adversary proceedings on the same day. They seek recovery from insiders and promoters, an exchange, unidentified hackers and two groups of service providers. Each also asks the court to disallow any claims the defendants filed until the property at issue is returned.
| Adversary no. | Defendants | Main claims | Amount at issue |
|---|---|---|---|
| 25-02180 | Braden John Karony, Kyle Nagy, Thomas Smith, Karony family members, promoters Jake Paul and Ben Phillips, Ronin and other affiliated entities | Breach of fiduciary duty, fraudulent transfer, conversion, unjust enrichment, tortious interference, claim disallowance | Alleged scheme of at least $100 million |
| 25-02179 | BitMart Exchange | Turnover, conversion, unjust enrichment, claim disallowance | At least $1.474 million in withheld tokens |
| 25-02178 | Lynn Spraggs, Robert Spraggs, AEGIS Systems Canada, Inc., Anonymous Key Technology Inc., Doe defendants | Constructive fraudulent transfer, claim disallowance, civil theft | About $920,000 in transfers; $1,764,536 in claims |
| 25-02177 | Unidentified hacker, bot owner and white hat (Does 1–20) | Civil theft, conversion, fraud, turnover, claim disallowance | At least $887,660.32 |
| 25-02176 | WebDBTech, Inc., Dr. Adel ElMessiry, Doe defendants | Constructive fraudulent transfer, unjust enrichment, transferee liability, claim disallowance | At least $5,000,000 in transfers; $900,000 claim |
Source: adversary complaints Dkt. 1 Dkt. 1 Dkt. 1 Dkt. 1 Dkt. 1
Former executives, family members and promoters
The suit against the former executives names Karony, Nagy, Smith and former chief operating officer Jack Haines-Davies. It also names Karony family members, promoters Jake Paul and Ben Phillips, and entities including Slashdot, LLC, four Ronin entities, Tano, LLC, Emanations Communications Group, LC and ECG Operations, LC Dkt. 1. It attributes estimated withdrawals of more than $178.3 million to Karony, more than $169.5 million to Smith and more than $20.1 million to Nagy. It alleges that Phillips received $5.3 million in SafeMoon tokens and Paul $190,314 for promoting the token. The complaint traces proceeds into real estate in Lindon, Utah, Vero Beach, Florida and Bethlehem, New Hampshire, and into luxury cars. It asserts 11 causes of action. These include breach of fiduciary duty, actual and constructive fraudulent transfer under sections 544 and 548 and Utah law, conversion, unjust enrichment and tortious interference. It also asks the court to disallow the defendants' claims under section 502(d) until the transfers are returned.
BitMart
In the BitMart suit, the trustee seeks turnover of tokens or their cash equivalent. The complaint alleges that the exchange withheld assets valued at approximately $1.474 million: 1.35 million USDT, 124,000 USDC and 390 million SafeMoon tokens Dkt. 1. The debtor and BitMart signed a listing agreement on March 30, 2021. According to the complaint, BitMart ignored a July 2022 withdrawal request. In February 2024 it refused the trustee's demand, citing breaches of the listing and user agreements and asserting setoff and recoupment. The trustee pleads turnover under section 542, conversion with punitive damages, unjust enrichment and claim disallowance. The complaint also reserves the right to seek sanctions under section 362(k) for violations of the automatic stay.
The March 2023 exploit
A separate suit targets the unidentified hacker, bot owner and white hat. It seeks turnover or damages of at least $887,660.32, the value of at least 2,832 BNB that was neither returned nor seized Dkt. 1. The trustee says Alston & Bird has refused to identify its client. The counts include civil theft, conversion, fraud and turnover, and the complaint also seeks punitive damages and fees.
Service providers
Two suits challenge prepetition payments to service providers as constructive fraudulent transfers. Both allege that the debtor was insolvent when it made the payments. The WebDBTech suit seeks to avoid at least $5,000,000 in cash and cryptocurrency paid within two years before the petition. The payments covered a SafeMoon Defenders videogame that the trustee says was never completed and blockchain development work that missed contract milestones. The suit also seeks to disallow WebDBTech's $900,000 proof of claim Dkt. 1. The suit against Lynn and Robert Spraggs, AEGIS Systems Canada and Anonymous Key Technology seeks about $920,000 paid for what the complaint calls minimal services of two to three hours a month. It also seeks to avoid and disallow $1,764,536 in claims the two companies filed for royalties, contractor fees and licensing fees Dkt. 1.
The trustee may sell unlocked cryptocurrency on the open market without further approval
Early in the case, on March 22, 2024, the court approved bid procedures for a sale of estate assets and set a sale hearing for April 18, 2024 Dkt. 90.
On June 27, 2025, the court authorized the trustee to sell locked cryptocurrency assets that became available on May 1, 2025 Dkt. 281. The order allows one or more open-market sales at then-current market prices, at the trustee's discretion and without further court approval. Within five business days after each closing, the trustee must file a notice identifying the assets sold and the prices received. The order does not itself establish that a sale occurred.
The court found compelling circumstances for a prompt sale because the assets risked losing value. It waived the 14-day stay under Bankruptcy Rule 6004(h) and gave open-market buyers good-faith protection under section 363(m). Sales are free and clear of liens, claims and interests, which attach to the proceeds with the same priority they held against the assets. The order makes no finding on whether the assets or the sales involve securities, and the Securities and Exchange Commission reserved its right to challenge the transactions.
The largest claims identified in the suits are ones the trustee is contesting
The deadline to file proofs of claim was July 22, 2024 Dkt. 1. The service-provider complaints allege that management misconduct and fraud left the debtor with hundreds of millions of dollars in liabilities Dkt. 1. The individual claims named in the suits are ones the trustee wants disallowed. They include WebDBTech's $900,000 unsecured claim, filed July 2, 2024, and $1,764,536 in claims filed by Anonymous Key Technology and AEGIS. They also include any claims by the insider defendants until those defendants return the transfers at issue. According to the trustee, BitMart filed no claim and instead asserts setoff and recoupment rights against the tokens it holds. Administrative expenses, including professional fees, are paid ahead of general unsecured claims.
Interim professional fees are paid from the estate ahead of creditors
A chapter 7 estate has no plan and no debtor-in-possession financing. The trustee's administration, including the litigation, is paid from estate assets, and professionals' allowed fees are administrative expenses Dkt. 429.
On November 3 and 4, 2026, the court entered interim orders on four applications. Foley & Lardner received $627,933.50 in fees and $16,542.09 in expenses, $644,475.59 in total, for November 1, 2025 through June 30, 2026 Dkt. 433. The proposed order lodged before entry reflected reductions under a stipulation and a further $2,896 cut stated at the hearing Dkt. 432. Dundon Advisers, the trustee's financial advisor, was allowed $127,168.00 for the same period. That order approved the application as amended by a stipulation with the Ronin Entities and overruled the objection Dkt. 430. Four Ronin entities are defendants in the insider suit. Inca Digital was allowed $20,295.00 for cryptocurrency-investigation work in the same period Dkt. 429. HEB Advisors was allowed $13,581.00 for tax-accounting work from May 9 through June 30, 2025, after a stipulation resolved the U.S. Trustee's objection Dkt. 431. The orders authorize the trustee to pay the awards. Each award is interim and subject to further review when final fees are requested.
- Foley & Lardner LLPGeneral bankruptcy counsel to the trustee · Nov. 1, 2025–June 30, 2026$644,475.59
- Dundon Advisers, LLCFinancial advisor · Nov. 1, 2025–June 30, 2026$127,168.00
- Inca DigitalCryptocurrency investigation · Nov. 1, 2025–June 30, 2026$20,295.00
- HEB AdvisorsTax accounting · May 9–June 30, 2025$13,581.00
Total$805,519.59
Show the numbers
| Professional | Role | Period | Allowed |
|---|---|---|---|
| Foley & Lardner LLP | General bankruptcy counsel to the trustee | Nov. 1, 2025–June 30, 2026 | $644,475.59 |
| Dundon Advisers, LLC | Financial advisor | Nov. 1, 2025–June 30, 2026 | $127,168.00 |
| Inca Digital | Cryptocurrency investigation | Nov. 1, 2025–June 30, 2026 | $20,295.00 |
| HEB Advisors | Tax accounting | May 9–June 30, 2025 | $13,581.00 |
| Total | $805,519.59 |
A proposed order on the application of Cohne Kinghorn, P.C., lodged November 6, 2026, would allow $960.00 in compensation and $33.54 in expenses as a priority administrative expense Dkt. 434. A fee-application hearing is scheduled for November 18, 2026.
Sources
- Dkt. 1Complaint for Fraudulent Transfer and Fiduciary BreachFiled Dec 12, 2025Dec 12, 2025
- Dkt. 1Chapter 7 Voluntary Petition. Filed by SafeMoon US, LLC. (Rose, Mark) (EOD: 12/14/2023)Filed Dec 14, 2023Dec 14, 2023
- Dkt. 1Complaint for Turnover and Recovery of Stolen CryptocurrencyFiled Dec 12, 2025Dec 12, 2025
- Dkt. 1Complaint to Recover Cryptocurrency and Avoid Fraudulent TransfersFiled Dec 12, 2025Dec 12, 2025
- Dkt. 1Complaint for Turnover Against BitMartFiled Dec 12, 2025Dec 12, 2025
- Dkt. 1Complaint to Avoid Fraudulent TransfersFiled Dec 12, 2025Dec 12, 2025
- Dkt. 90Order Granting Motion to Approve Bid Procedures For Sale of Asset(s) (Related Doc 75). Sale Hearing scheduled for 04/18/2024 at 02:00 PM at ZoomGov.com/join - JTM: Meeting ID: 161 5478 8875, Passcode: 3834658, Phone 1-669-254-5252.) (js) Modified on 4/10/2024 (mfr). (EOD: 03/22/2024)Filed Mar 22, 2024Mar 22, 2024
- Dkt. 281Order Authorizing Cryptocurrency SaleFiled Jun 27, 2025Jun 27, 2025
- Dkt. 429Inca Digital Interim FeesFiled Nov 3, 2026Nov 3, 2026
- Dkt. 430Dundon Interim FeesFiled Nov 3, 2026Nov 3, 2026
- Dkt. 431HEB Interim Fee OrderFiled Nov 3, 2026Nov 3, 2026
- Dkt. 432Third Interim Fee AwardFiled Nov 3, 2026Nov 3, 2026
- Dkt. 433Third Interim Fee AwardFiled Nov 4, 2026Nov 4, 2026
- Dkt. 434Special Counsel Fee ApprovalFiled Nov 6, 2026Nov 6, 2026