Smallhold Bankruptcy: Subchapter V Cramdown and Opt-Out Release Ruling
ElevenFlo ·
Smallhold’s Subchapter V reorganization plan has taken effect, and the court entered an amended confirmation order Dkt. 306 on November 20, 2024. The reorganized company’s path is to implement the plan’s creditor payments and file quarterly post-confirmation reports.
Jump to section
Smallhold, Inc. exited chapter 11 in September 2024 with a sponsor-backed Subchapter V plan confirmed over the rejection of its general unsecured creditors Dkt. 265, and produced a Delaware memorandum opinion on opt-out third-party releases Dkt. 288 addressing consent mechanics after Harrington v. Purdue Pharma. The Brooklyn-based specialty mushroom grower filed under Subchapter V Dkt. 8 on February 18, 2024 in the U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the District of Delaware (Case No. 24-10267), before Judge Craig T. Goldblatt.
The restructuring paired a $900,000 DIP facility Dkt. 69 from new majority owner Monomyth with an operational reset and a five-year disposable-income plan confirmed under Section 1191(b) Dkt. 306. General unsecured creditors, holding roughly $8.6 million in claims, were assigned to a sponsor-guaranteed $155,000 recovery pool, a treatment that drew objections from the U.S. Trustee and the debtor's largest equipment lessor before the court confirmed the plan as a cramdown. The plan went effective on September 6, 2024 Dkt. 277, and a post-emergence announcement businesswire.com: Business Wire - Smallhold Emerges from Bankruptcy and Debuts Resilient Partner Farm Network (outside source) described a partner-farm network and continued investment led by Monomyth.
| Debtor | Smallhold, Inc. (Delaware public benefit corporation) |
| Court | U.S. Bankruptcy Court, District of Delaware |
| Case Number | 24-10267 |
| Judge | Hon. Craig T. Goldblatt |
| Petition Date | February 18, 2024 |
| Effective Date | September 6, 2024 |
| Confirmation Date | September 2024 (amended confirmation order entered November 20, 2024) |
| DIP Facility | $900,000 commitment from Monomyth Sponsor Group, LLC |
Table: Case Snapshot
Monomyth Takeover and the Path to Subchapter V
Smallhold was founded in 2017 foodandwine.com: Food & Wine - Smallhold Is Shaking Up the Way We Buy Mushrooms (outside source) by Adam DeMartino and Andrew Carter and grew from a Brooklyn shipping-container farm cbsnews.com: CBS New York - Brooklyn-Based Mushroom Farm Supplies Restaurants and Stores (outside source) into indoor farms in New York City, Austin, and Los Angeles. At its peak the brand was valued at $90 million theguardian.com: The Guardian - Sustainable Food Brands and the Pullback in Funding (outside source) and sold into roughly 1,400 stores before the founding pair stepped aside whitneybauck.substack.com: What happened at Smallhold? - by Whitney Bauck (outside source) in early 2024. By the petition date its specialty mushrooms reached more than 500 retail locations across 10 states.
The First Day Declaration Dkt. 8 describes a control change in the weeks before filing. Monomyth, LLC acquired shares on February 7, 2024 to reach 90.77% of Smallhold's common stock, the founders resigned from the board around February 10, 2024, and the company installed Gustavo Reichmann as interim CEO and Tariq Jawad as interim CFO. Smallhold retained Pashman Stein Walder Hayden, P.C. Dkt. 38 as counsel and entered chapter 11 as a Delaware public benefit corporation with no secured funded debt and approximately $1.4 million in unsecured trade debt against roughly 81 employees.
Management attributed the filing to a venture-capital fundraising downturn and a flat fresh-mushroom category Dkt. 8, compounded by pressure from certain lessors. Trade coverage described the company as being in substantially worse financial shape than previously disclosed agfundernews.com: substantially worse financial shape than previously disclosed (outside source), with farm closures and headcount reductions, and tied Smallhold to the broader wave verticalfarmdaily.com: tied Smallhold to the broader wave (outside source) of controlled-environment agriculture failures struggling with unit economics. Bowery Farming techcrunch.com: Bowery Farming Ceases Operations (TechCrunch, 2024-11-04) (outside source), a New York-based vertical farming operator, ceased operations in November 2024. A founder account described venture investors pulling funding as profitability lagged theguardian.com: The Guardian - Sustainable Food Brands and the Pullback in Funding (outside source), leaving the company without adequate cashflow.
First-Day Relief and Operational Reset
Smallhold's first-day motion package Dkt. 34 focused on keeping logistics moving while the company shrank its physical footprint. An interim order Dkt. 44 authorized — but did not require — payment of up to $150,000 in prepetition shipper claims, conditioned on continued service on historical trade terms and allowing the estate to recover amounts paid if a shipper failed to perform.
The supplemental First Day Declaration Dkt. 35 describes an orderly shutdown of the Texas and New York farming operations while the Los Angeles farm stayed open as a bridge to an interim strategy built around partner-farm relationships and renegotiated shipping and packaging costs. To cut overhead, the debtor moved to reject Dkt. 49 its Brooklyn office lease with ACP BK I LLC and a schedule of vendor contracts effective February 29, 2024. A post-emergence announcement businesswire.com: Business Wire - Smallhold Emerges from Bankruptcy and Debuts Resilient Partner Farm Network (outside source) later confirmed that farms in Texas, New York, and California all closed during the reorganization as the company shifted to a partner-farm network supplying more than 700 retail locations.
Monomyth's Revenue-Tiered DIP Facility
The debtor financed the case with a $900,000 DIP facility Dkt. 69 from the Monomyth Sponsor Group, LLC — an affiliate of its new majority owner. The interim order Dkt. 95 made $300,000 available, with the remaining $600,000 unlocked on entry of the final order Dkt. 129, subject to budget compliance. Draws were capped at one per seven-day period, with a $100,000 minimum and a $200,000 ceiling other than the initial advance, and repaid amounts could not be reborrowed.
Pricing stepped with the company's revenue rather than a fixed spread. The DIP motion Dkt. 69 set the rate against trailing two-week average revenue, starting at 17% and declining to 14% as revenue rose, with a 2% default premium available at the lender's election. The final order Dkt. 129 added a 1% commitment fee and a facility fee payable at maturity, and approved superpriority liens intended to survive plan confirmation.
| Two-week average revenue | Interest rate |
|---|---|
| $75,000 or less | 17% |
| Over $75,000 to $100,000 | 16% |
| Over $100,000 to $125,000 | 15% |
| Over $125,000 | 14% |
The final order Dkt. 129 imposed a detailed reporting and variance package: an updated 13-week cash forecast every other Thursday, written explanations for variances above 10%, line-item receipts held at no less than 90% of budget, line-item disbursements (excluding professional fees) held within 110% of budget, and a rolling four-week receipts test of at least 90%. It also carried a carve-out for estate professionals and the Subchapter V trustee — budgeted amounts before a carve-out notice, then capped at $50,000 afterward and $20,000 in any chapter 7 conversion. Missing the facility's milestones — a final DIP order by April 30, 2024, a plan on file by May 26, 2024, confirmation within 40 days of the plan, and an effective date within 30 days of confirmation — would have been an immediate event of default.
The August 2024 monthly operating report Dkt. 286 showed a net cash outflow for the month and DIP payables of $939,000 — at the ceiling of the $900,000 commitment plus accrued amounts.
| August 2024 operating report | Amount |
|---|---|
| Beginning cash | -$227,262 |
| Cash receipts | $691,266 |
| Cash disbursements | -$1,163,885 |
| Net cash flow | -$472,619 |
| Ending cash | -$245,357 |
| DIP financing payables | $939,000 |
Subchapter V Plan and the GUC Recovery Pool
The confirmed plan Dkt. 250 applied all of Smallhold's projected disposable income over a five-year period beginning in the fourth quarter of 2024 to creditor distributions, with Monomyth structuring the exit so the reorganized debtor would carry no secured debt. The DIP loan converts into convertible notes on the effective date, maturing at a conversion date five years out, and Monomyth committed an additional $500,000 of exit financing in the form of convertible notes. Those notes convert to equity if not repaid, with pricing tied to a future "Next Equity Financing" of at least $4 million — a 20% discount to the lowest price per share in that round, capped by a $10 million pre-money valuation on a fully diluted basis.
Administrative claimants, whose components the plan estimated at roughly $1.1 million, could elect cash paid pro rata from disposable income or convertible notes bearing 8% interest, with Monomyth guaranteeing up to $750,000 of cash payments to non-investor administrative holders. General unsecured creditors — whose claims the plan put at $8,639,507 — were assigned to a GUC Recovery Pool Dkt. 250 capped at $155,000 and fully guaranteed by the sponsor, with $75,000 scheduled for the third quarter of 2025 and the remaining $80,000 spread across the balance of the plan term. The plan separately delayed distributions on the Camber Road claim pending resolution of a related transfers dispute. Equity interests were retained.
| Class | Treatment | Status |
|---|---|---|
| Administrative claims (about $1.1M) | Cash pro rata from disposable income, or 8% convertible notes; up to $750,000 sponsor-guaranteed | Unclassified |
| Class 1 — DIP lender secured claim | DIP loan converts to convertible notes, then equity if unpaid | Impaired; accepted |
| Class 2 — general unsecured (about $8.6M) | $155,000 sponsor-guaranteed GUC Recovery Pool | Impaired; rejected |
| Equity interests | Retained | Unimpaired |
Table: Plan Treatment by Class
Confirmation Objections and the Section 1191(b) Cramdown
Two parties opposed confirmation. The United States Trustee objected Dkt. 236 that the plan's release package imposed third-party releases without affirmative consent after Purdue Pharma, targeting creditors who voted to accept, creditors who voted to reject but failed to check the opt-out box, unimpaired or deemed-accepting parties asked to opt out through notice rather than a ballot, and creditors who did not vote at all. The U.S. Trustee also challenged the debtor's characterization of the plan as a global compromise under Section 1123(b)(3)(A) and asked the court to deny confirmation or strip the nonconsensual release features.
Camber Road Partners, the debtor's principal equipment lessor and an unsecured claimant, separately objected Dkt. 204 that the plan was neither fair and equitable nor feasible and improperly shifted value away from non-insider creditors toward a sponsor-backed structure. The debtor's limited objection and response Dkt. 209 defended the five-year disposable-income framework, the guaranteed unsecured pool, and the separate treatment of the Camber claim while transfers litigation remained pending.
The certification of ballots Dkt. 212 showed Class 1, the DIP lender, accepting the plan and Class 2, general unsecured creditors, rejecting it — foreclosing a consensual Section 1191(a) path and requiring confirmation under Section 1191(b). The court confirmed the plan Dkt. 265 as a cramdown, finding it did not unfairly discriminate and was fair and equitable under Subchapter V, and later entered an amended confirmation order Dkt. 306 on November 20, 2024. Discharge was framed around the last distribution date, expected in the fourth quarter of 2029, consistent with Section 1191(b) timing. The Notice of Effective Date Dkt. 277 set September 6, 2024 as the effective date, October 7, 2024 as the administrative expense bar date, and September 23, 2024 as the rejection-claim bar date.
Opt-Out Releases After Purdue Pharma
Judge Goldblatt issued a memorandum opinion Dkt. 288 on opt-out third-party releases. The court read Purdue Pharma as leaving consensual third-party releases intact while rendering nonconsensual releases unlawful, and rejected the idea that silence — a failure to check an opt-out box — supplies the consent needed to surrender a creditor's claims against non-debtors. For creditors who actually cast a ballot, however, the court concluded that an affirmative vote combined with clear release disclosures and an opt-out checkbox could establish consent under ordinary contract principles.
The result narrowed the release package the confirmation order Dkt. 265 approved to the Class 1 lender, which voted to accept, and to Class 2 creditors who voted and did not opt out; unimpaired parties and other non-voting constituencies whose only purported consent was inaction were not bound. A Young Conaway case update emphasized the court's reliance on ballot and notice mechanics youngconaway.com: Young Conaway - Bankruptcy Case Update: Judge Goldblatt Considers Consensual Releases Post-Purdue (outside source) as the foundation of valid consent. The Harvard Law School Bankruptcy Roundtable cited the ruling as a significant post-Purdue clarification bankruptcyroundtable.law.harvard.edu: Judge Goldblatt Reconsiders What Constitutes“Consent” Post ... (outside source) on the limits of opt-out consent mechanics in chapter 11 plans. CSG Law noted implications for sureties who voted without opting out csglaw.com: CSG Law Alert: Delaware Bankruptcy Court Clarifies Meaning of ... (outside source) under the ruling's affirmative-consent framework. Restructuring GlobalView observed that voting on the plan, not inaction, establishes consent restructuring-globalview.com: Judge Goldblatt Reconsiders What Constitutes “Consent” Post Purdue Pharma (US) (outside source).
Mountain Meadow Remand and Post-Emergence PACA Compliance
Smallhold continued operating under Monomyth's direction following the September 2024 effective date. In February 2026, the company posted a $50,000 surety bond ams.usda.gov: New York Firm Posts $50,000 Surety Bond to Obtain PACA License (outside source) with the USDA Agricultural Marketing Service to obtain a PACA license — a compliance requirement arising from the bankruptcy.
A post-reorganization contract dispute arose when Mountain Meadow Mushroom Farms, which had contracted with Smallhold during the case, brought claims against the reorganized debtor. The Delaware Bankruptcy Court remanded the dispute to California state court law360.com: Bankruptcy Judge Sends Post-Reorg Dispute To Calif. Court - Law360 (outside source) in July 2025, finding that post-effective date claims against the reorganized debtor fell outside its narrow post-confirmation jurisdiction, even though the underlying contract had been executed during the bankruptcy.
Key Timeline
| Date | Event |
|---|---|
| February 7, 2024 | Monomyth reaches 90.77% of common stock |
| February 18, 2024 | Subchapter V petition filed (Case No. 24-10267) |
| February 28, 2024 | Interim shipper-claims order entered |
| February 29, 2024 | Lease and vendor-contract rejections effective |
| March 20, 2024 | Interim DIP order entered |
| April 17, 2024 | Final DIP order entered |
| May 20, 2024 | Initial Subchapter V plan filed |
| September 6, 2024 | Plan effective date |
| September 25, 2024 | Memorandum opinion on opt-out releases |
| November 20, 2024 | Amended confirmation order entered |
| July 2025 | Mountain Meadow breach of contract claim remanded to California state court law360.com: Bankruptcy Judge Sends Post-Reorg Dispute To Calif. Court - Law360 (outside source) |
| February 2026 | USDA PACA surety bond posted ams.usda.gov: New York Firm Posts $50,000 Surety Bond to Obtain PACA License (outside source) |
Frequently Asked Questions
Why did Smallhold file for Subchapter V? The company cited a venture-capital fundraising downturn and a flat fresh-mushroom category Dkt. 8, along with pressure from certain lessors. Trade coverage described the business as being in substantially worse financial shape than previously disclosed agfundernews.com: substantially worse financial shape than previously disclosed (outside source) and tied it to the wider wave of controlled-environment agriculture restructurings.
Who is Monomyth and what role did it play? Monomyth acquired shares to reach 90.77% of common stock shortly before the filing and became the DIP lender and plan sponsor. It provided the $900,000 DIP facility Dkt. 69, converted that debt into convertible notes, funded $500,000 of exit financing, and guaranteed both the administrative cash backstop and the unsecured recovery pool.
What was the DIP financing structure? The facility Dkt. 69 carried a $900,000 commitment with $300,000 available on an interim basis, revenue-tiered interest from 14% to 17%, draw minimums and frequency caps, and a rolling 13-week budget with receipt and disbursement variance tests. The final order Dkt. 129 added a 1% commitment fee and a facility fee payable at maturity.
What do unsecured creditors receive? General unsecured creditors, holding roughly $8.6 million in claims, share a sponsor-guaranteed GUC Recovery Pool Dkt. 250 totaling $155,000 — $75,000 in the third quarter of 2025 and $80,000 over the remainder of the five-year plan term.
How was the plan confirmed? Because Class 2 general unsecured creditors rejected the plan Dkt. 212 while Class 1 accepted, the court confirmed it under Section 1191(b) Dkt. 306 as a cramdown, finding the plan did not unfairly discriminate and was fair and equitable under Subchapter V standards.
What did the opt-out release opinion decide? Judge Goldblatt's memorandum opinion Dkt. 288 held that silence cannot establish consent to a third-party release after Purdue Pharma, but that a creditor who votes after receiving clear disclosure and an opt-out checkbox can be treated as consenting. The ruling limited the confirmed releases to voting creditors who did not opt out.
Has Smallhold emerged from bankruptcy? A September 2024 announcement businesswire.com: Business Wire - Smallhold Emerges from Bankruptcy and Debuts Resilient Partner Farm Network (outside source) described Smallhold's emergence with a partner-farm network and continued investment led by Monomyth.
For related coverage, see Bridge Diagnostics' Subchapter V cramdown confirmation, the opt-out release questions raised in Purdue Pharma, and Trinitas Farming's agricultural chapter 11.
Sources
- Dkt. 8First Day DeclarationFiled Feb 20, 2024Feb 20, 2024
- Dkt. 34Motion Regarding Chapter 11 First Day Motions /Debtor's Motion for Entry of an Order Authorizing the Payment of Certain Prepetition Shippers Claims and Granting Related Relief Filed By Smallhold, Inc. (Barsalona II, Joseph)Filed Feb 26, 2024Feb 26, 2024
- Dkt. 35First Day DeclarationFiled Feb 26, 2024Feb 26, 2024
- Dkt. 38Retention ApplicationFiled Feb 27, 2024Feb 27, 2024
- Dkt. 44Interim Order Authorizing the Payment of Certain Prepetition Shippers Claim[s] and Granting Related Relief (related document(s)[34]) Signed on 2/28/2024. (NAB)Filed Feb 28, 2024Feb 28, 2024
- Dkt. 49Omnibus Motion to Reject Lease or Executory Contract /Debtor's First Omnibus Motion for Entry of an Order (I) Authorizing the Rejection of (A) An Unexpired Lease and (B) Certain Executory Contracts, Each Effective as of the Rejection Date, and (II) Granting Related Relief Filed by Smallhold, Inc.. Hearing scheduled for 3/19/2024 at 03:30 PM at US Bankruptcy Court, 824 Market St., 3rd Fl., Courtroom #7, Wilmington, Delaware. Objections due...Filed Feb 29, 2024Feb 29, 2024
- Dkt. 69Emergency Motion to Approve Debtor In Possession Financing Filed by Smallhold, Inc.. (Attachments: # (1) Exhibit A # (2) Exhibit B) (Barsalona II, Joseph)Filed Mar 14, 2024Mar 14, 2024
- Dkt. 95Interim Order Pursuant to 11 U.S.C. §§ 105, 361, 362, 363, 364, and 507, Bankruptcy Rules 2002, 4001, 6004, and 9014, and Local Rule 4001-2(I) Authorizing the Debtor to Use Cash Collateral and Obtain Post-Petition Financing, (II) Granting Liens and Providing Super Priority Administrative Expense Status, (III) Granting Adequate Protection, (IV) Scheduling a Final Hearing, and (V) Granting Related Relief (related document(s)[92]) Signed on ...Filed Mar 20, 2024Mar 20, 2024
- Dkt. 129Final Order (I) Authorizing the Debtor to use Cash Collateral and Obtain Post-Petition Financing, (II) Granting Liens and Providing Super-Priority Administrative Expense Status, (III) Granting Adequate Protection, and (IV) Granting Related Relief Signed on 4/17/2024. (Attachments: # (1) Exhibit 1) (NAB)Filed Apr 17, 2024Apr 17, 2024
- Dkt. 204Objection to Confirmation of Plan // Camber Road Partners, Inc.'s Objection to Debtor's First Amended Plan of Reorganization Filed by Camber Road Partners, Inc. (related document(s)[180]). (Attachments: # (1) Exhibit A) (Harvey, Matthew)Filed Jul 3, 2024Jul 3, 2024
- Dkt. 209Objection /Debtor's Limited Objection to Camber Road Partners, Inc.'s Motion for Entry of an Order Allowing Administrative Expense Claim Pursuant to 11 U.S.C. §§ 503(B) and 507(A)(2) and Compelling Debtors Immediate Payment of Same [D.I. 202] (related document(s)[202]) Filed by Smallhold, Inc. (Attachments: # (1) Exhibit A # (2) Exhibit B # (3) Exhibit C) (Jaffe, Henry)Filed Jul 11, 2024Jul 11, 2024
- Dkt. 212Certification of Ballots (related document(s)[179], [182], [193]) Filed by Smallhold, Inc. (Attachments: # (1) Exhibit A # (2) Exhibit B # (3) Exhibit C) (Barsalona II, Joseph)Filed Jul 12, 2024Jul 12, 2024
- Dkt. 236Objection United States Trustee's Objection to Confirmation of the Subchapter V Debtor's Second Amended Plan of Reorganization (related document(s)[228]) Filed by U.S. Trustee (Attachments: # (1) Certificate of Service) (Cudia, Joseph)Filed Aug 13, 2024Aug 13, 2024
- Dkt. 250Chapter 11 PlanFiled Aug 20, 2024Aug 20, 2024
- Dkt. 265Confirmation OrderFiled Aug 22, 2024Aug 22, 2024
- Dkt. 277Notice of Effective Date (related document(s)[250], [265]) Filed by Smallhold, Inc.. (Gambale, Alexis)Filed Sep 6, 2024Sep 6, 2024
- Dkt. 286Monthly Operating Report for Filing Period August 2024 September 6, 2024 Filed by Smallhold, Inc.. (Gambale, Alexis)Filed Sep 25, 2024Sep 25, 2024
- Dkt. 288Memorandum Opinion regarding Opt-Out Third-Party Releases (related document(s) [250]) (DCY)Filed Sep 25, 2024Sep 25, 2024
- Dkt. 306Confirmation OrderFiled Nov 20, 2024Nov 20, 2024
- WebBusiness Wire - Smallhold Emerges from Bankruptcy and Debuts Resilient Partner Farm Networkbusinesswire.com · Outside source
- WebFood & Wine - Smallhold Is Shaking Up the Way We Buy Mushroomsfoodandwine.com · Outside source
- WebCBS New York - Brooklyn-Based Mushroom Farm Supplies Restaurants and Storescbsnews.com · Outside source
- WebThe Guardian - Sustainable Food Brands and the Pullback in Fundingtheguardian.com · Outside source
- WebWhat happened at Smallhold? - by Whitney Bauckwhitneybauck.substack.com · Outside source
- Websubstantially worse financial shape than previously disclosedagfundernews.com · Outside source
- Webtied Smallhold to the broader waveverticalfarmdaily.com · Outside source
- WebBowery Farming Ceases Operations (TechCrunch, 2024-11-04)techcrunch.com · Outside source
- WebYoung Conaway - Bankruptcy Case Update: Judge Goldblatt Considers Consensual Releases Post-Purdueyoungconaway.com · Outside source
- WebJudge Goldblatt Reconsiders What Constitutes“Consent” Post ...bankruptcyroundtable.law.harvard.edu · Outside source
- WebCSG Law Alert: Delaware Bankruptcy Court Clarifies Meaning of ...csglaw.com · Outside source
- WebJudge Goldblatt Reconsiders What Constitutes “Consent” Post Purdue Pharma (US)restructuring-globalview.com · Outside source
- WebNew York Firm Posts $50,000 Surety Bond to Obtain PACA Licenseams.usda.gov · Outside source
- WebBankruptcy Judge Sends Post-Reorg Dispute To Calif. Court - Law360law360.com · Outside source