Diocese of Buffalo abuse claimants vote 709 to 6 for $326.5 million trust plan; insurer buyback approval still open
ElevenFlo ·
Stretto’s final tabulation shows abuse claimants accepted the Diocese’s second amended joint plan 709 to 6 Dkt. 5246. Confirmation is still ahead. Final approval of $176,955,500 in insurer buybacks waits on language protecting Baker Hall’s own policies Dkt. 5212. On November 17, Baker Hall (OLV Human Services) said the insurers’ proposed carve-out covers only scheduled policies. It asked the court to adopt its own version and says the Diocese supports it Dkt. 5255.
Jump to section
The Diocese, a group of additional debtors and the creditors’ committee filed the plan jointly. Money reaches the trust only after three things happen: the court approves the insurer buybacks in final form, it confirms the plan, and the conditions to effectiveness are met.
Abuse claimants have accepted the second amended joint chapter 11 plan of the Diocese of Buffalo. Stretto’s final tabulation was filed November 16, 2026. It counts 709 of 715 tabulated Class 6 ballots (99.2%) as accepting and 6 as rejecting, with 29 ballots not tabulated. The voting deadline was November 3 Dkt. 5246. Class 6 was the only class entitled to vote. Each abuse claim was allowed at $1 for voting purposes only, so the class accepted by the same margin in number and in amount Dkt. 5057. The Buffalo Chronicle reported that the plan would resolve nearly 900 abuse claims, most of them filed under New York’s Child Victims Act buffalochronicle.com: Abuse survivors approve the Buffalo Diocese’s $327 million settlement plan, with court approval still to come | The Buffalo Chronicle (outside source).
Two court decisions and the funding itself stand between the vote and any payment. First, Chief Bankruptcy Judge Carl L. Bucki must give final approval to the insurer buybacks. That approval now depends on how much of Baker Hall’s own insurance the settlement leaves untouched. Second, he must confirm the plan. That includes ruling on the U.S. Trustee’s objection to the gatekeeper injunction, which the court reserved for confirmation Dkt. 5212. The injunction would govern specified claims against protected parties Dkt. 5056. After confirmation, the additional debtors must file their petitions, and the Diocese, contributing entities and insurers must pay into the trust Dkt. 5076.
The court entered an order setting a confirmation hearing on the second amended plan Dkt. 5076. According to the Buffalo Chronicle, the court’s notice set the hearing for October 27 and said it could be continued without further notice. Citing WGRZ, the Chronicle said the vote results would be reported to the judge at a November 18 hearing and that more hearings were expected in December and January. Steve Boyd, a lawyer for many of the claimants, said he expects payments in the first quarter of 2027 buffalochronicle.com: Abuse survivors approve the Buffalo Diocese’s $327 million settlement plan, with court approval still to come | The Buffalo Chronicle (outside source).
Final buyback approval depends on whether Baker Hall’s unscheduled policies are protected
In an October 26 opinion Dkt. 5212, the court held that the Diocese could sell insurance-policy rights back to insurers for $176,955,500. It deferred final approval until the parties resolve language on Baker Hall’s claimed co-ownership of some policies. Baker Hall does business as OLV Human Services. The settlements are contingent on plan confirmation.
On November 17, five insurers filed a proposed rider meant to resolve OLV’s remaining objection: ACE Property & Casualty, Century Indemnity, Federal Insurance, Pacific Employers and U.S. Fire. The rider would remove a schedule of post-1986 directors-and-officers policies from the policies the settlement covers. Two kinds of policies would stay in the settlement: Schedule 3 policies, and policies that give coverage rights both to a specified non-debtor entity and to the Diocese or an additional debtor. The rider would also add language to the approval order. That language would protect rights under the excluded policies from release, injunction, assignment or buyback Dkt. 5249.
OLV responded the same day that the rider does not resolve its objection. OLV says policies that insure it but not the Diocese or the additional debtors must stay available for claims against OLV and cannot be impaired over its objection. Its historical insurance records are incomplete. It therefore wants the carve-out to cover unknown policies of that kind as well as the ones it scheduled. The insurers’ language protects only scheduled policies, so any policy missing from OLV’s schedule would be left unprotected. OLV attached its own language and reports that the Diocese supports it Dkt. 5255.
The plan cannot take effect until the required insurer agreements and insurer payments are in place Dkt. 5076. The scope of the OLV carve-out therefore bears on effectiveness, not only on the buyback order.
Settling insurers would fund more than half of the trust
The Diocese filed for chapter 11 on February 28, 2020. Its second amended joint plan Dkt. 5076, filed August 27, 2026, proposes $326,452,500 for a trust and abuse claims settlement fund. Of that, $150 million would come from the Diocese, additional debtors and contributing non-debtor entities, potentially including up to $25 million through a trust note. The other $176,452,500 would come from settling insurers. The October 26 opinion identifies $176,955,500 in proposed insurer repurchases. Settlements with non-settling insurers reached before the confirmation hearing could add to the fund Dkt. 5056.
The disclosure statement’s projections assume the Diocese pays the trust $40 million, directly or through another party, on the effective date. They project ending unrestricted cash of $5.63 million to $6.43 million from the effective date through fiscal 2028 Dkt. 5057. The plan lets the Diocese borrow at its discretion to fund its cash payment, before or after the effective date, without court approval Dkt. 5076.
- CNA$85.0M
- Wausau$37.5M
- SICNY$35.5M
- Catholic Mutual$9.0M
- Travelers Indemnity$2.0875M
- TNCRRG$1.5M
- Hartford$1.5M
- Century$1.5M
- Other settling insurers, collectively$1.465M
- AIG Insurers$1.4M
Total$176.4525M
Show the numbers
| Settling insurer | Agreed payment |
|---|---|
| CNA | $85.0M |
| Wausau | $37.5M |
| SICNY | $35.5M |
| Catholic Mutual | $9.0M |
| Travelers Indemnity | $2.0875M |
| TNCRRG | $1.5M |
| Hartford | $1.5M |
| Century | $1.5M |
| Other settling insurers, collectively | $1.465M |
| AIG Insurers | $1.4M |
| Total | $176.4525M |
Source: disclosure statement Dkt. 5057
The disclosure statement warns that contributions may not arrive if claimants do not opt into releases, or if parish contributions lack required approvals Dkt. 5057. The Buffalo Chronicle, citing WGRZ, reported that some parishes appealed their required contributions to the Vatican’s Dicastery for the Clergy. A spokesperson for Save Our Churches Buffalo said most of those decisions went in the parishes’ favor and some are still pending. In May, the Diocese said the rulings do not affect the settlement plan. It said parish funds designated for the settlement sit in separate accounts that the parishes administer until the money is turned over buffalochronicle.com: Abuse survivors approve the Buffalo Diocese’s $327 million settlement plan, with court approval still to come | The Buffalo Chronicle (outside source).
The insurer settlements trace back to coverage litigation that began on the petition date. That day, the Diocese sued Continental Insurance, Employers Insurance Company of Wausau, Catholic Mutual Group, the National Catholic Risk Retention Group and other insurers for a declaratory judgment Dkt. 1. In January 2021, the Diocese and parish church societies filed a second coverage action against a longer list of insurers, including Travelers, Hartford and Century Indemnity entities Dkt. 1. The trust would also receive certain claims against non-settling insurers. The disclosure statement warns that litigating those claims could take years, cost several million dollars and recover nothing Dkt. 5057.
Banks and general unsecured creditors are paid in full; abuse claims go to the trust
The plan pays administrative, priority tax, non-tax priority, professional-fee and U.S. Trustee fee claims in full. It leaves Classes 1 through 5 and 8 unimpaired. Allowed general unsecured claims would be paid in full in cash on the later of the effective date or allowance. Class 7 inbound contribution claims would be disallowed without distribution and are deemed to reject. Claims for punitive or exemplary damages would be disallowed as penalty claims Dkt. 5076. Non-abuse claims against the additional debtors would ride through and be paid in the ordinary course Dkt. 5057.
Secured claims sit in the first three classes: Bank of America in Class 1, M&T Bank in Class 2 and National Fuel in Class 3. The plan says the Diocese is current on all three and will keep paying them on their terms. It would assume the underlying debt documents. Each lien would attach to the Diocese’s residual assets with the same validity and priority it had before the petition date Dkt. 5076. The plan does not state the balances.
Class 6 abuse claims would be paid only from the trust, under the trust agreement and an allocation protocol. No claimant would be paid before delivering an abuse claim release agreement Dkt. 5076. Unknown abuse claimants would be paid only from a fund equal to 5% of the insurance recovery sub-fund Dkt. 5056. Boyd told WGRZ that an allocator will value each claim under the agreed protocol. He said claimants who dispute their award can seek reconsideration for a fee of about $500 buffalochronicle.com: Abuse survivors approve the Buffalo Diocese’s $327 million settlement plan, with court approval still to come | The Buffalo Chronicle (outside source).
The liquidation analysis reports $67,651,998 of assets at book value and $44,338,401 of liquidation value after $23,313,597 of adjustments. The proponents estimate that abuse claimants would recover more under the plan than in chapter 7 Dkt. 5057.
Insurer releases wait for payment, and non-debtor releases depend on opt-ins
Channeled claims would go to the trust as the holders’ sole and exclusive remedy Dkt. 5076. A settling insurer’s injunctions, releases and discharge would take effect only after the trust receives that insurer’s full settlement amount and the other settlement conditions are met Dkt. 4901. Abuse claimants release a settling insurer when it pays the trust, but not before the effective date. Claims against excluded parties and non-settling insurers remain preserved, with one exception: a Class 6 claim brought together with a claim against a protected party is channeled as to the protected party Dkt. 5076.
The trust would take on abuse claims against a contributing non-debtor entity only to the extent that entity contributes Dkt. 5076. Ballots for claimants with abuse claims against contributing non-debtor entities included an opt-in election to release that entity Dkt. 5057. The tabulation reports 69 checked release elections. Class 6 1A voted 641 to 6, and all 68 tabulated Class 6 1B ballots accepted Dkt. 5246.
Effectiveness requires the additional debtors to file and the money to arrive
Effectiveness requires a confirmation order and final orders without stays. The trust must be formed and its trust agreement signed. The required contributions, insurer agreements and insurer payments must be in place. The additional debtors’ petition and bar-date requirements must also be met Dkt. 5076. The June plan required those petitions to be filed before the confirmation hearing. It also allowed no more than ten claims to be filed against the additional debtors after confirmation Dkt. 4901. The proposed notice for the additional debtors sets an abuse-claim deadline 21 days after their petition date Dkt. 5056.
The Diocese and the committee can waive conditions only by written consent. Settling insurers and additional debtors must also consent where their rights are affected Dkt. 5076. If effectiveness has not occurred within 90 days after the confirmation order becomes final, the Diocese or the committee may withdraw the plan Dkt. 5057. On emergence, the Diocese and the additional debtors would continue as tax-exempt not-for-profit corporations, and the committee would dissolve Dkt. 5076.
Real estate sales continue, with bids on one property due December 1
A May 29, 2026 sale order Dkt. 4844 approved a $4.6 million sale of five Main Street properties in Buffalo to PLK Enterprises. The sale was conditioned on a lease under which the Diocese rents the 801 Main Street Walsh Building from the buyer for three years. The order also authorized a $230,000 commission to Howard Hanna. The July operating report Dkt. 5233 records $4,314,443 in net proceeds from two commercial-property sales.
An October 13 bidding procedures order covers 5875 Ellicot Street Road in the Town of Bethany. It names Ricky Hale as stalking-horse bidder. Bids are due at noon on December 1, and an auction is set for December 4 if more than one qualified bid arrives. Approval of the sale is left for a later hearing Dkt. 5155.
On November 16, the Diocese sought bidding and sale approval for 760 Ellicott Street in Buffalo, a half-acre site with a chapel, house, garage and parking lots Dkt. 5239. SBSquared Properties LLC is the proposed stalking horse at $600,000: a $60,000 deposit and the balance at closing. Competing bids must beat that cash price by at least $10,000 and carry a 10% deposit. They are due at noon 30 days after the procedures order is entered. Auction overbids would rise in steps of at least $5,000. The Diocese asked for a December 7 hearing on the procedures Dkt. 5239.
Also on November 16, the court approved the Diocese’s hiring of Danahy Real Estate as broker, effective September 28, 2026 Dkt. 5238. BTPM News reported that Danahy will market the former St. Mary’s Church and rectory in the Village of Cattaraugus, listed at $135,000. Diocese counsel Justin Krell told the court a prospective buyer had made an offer. No sale of that property has been approved btpm.org: Judge approves broker for sale of former St. Mary’s Church in Cattaraugus (outside source).
Sources
- Dkt. 1Adversary case 1-20-01009. 91 (Declaratory judgment) 14 (Recovery of money/property - other). Complaint Filed by The Diocese of Buffalo, N.Y. vs The Continental Insurance Company, Employers Insurance Company of Wausau (formally known as Employers Insurance of Wausau A Mutual Company formerly known as Employers Mutual Liability Insurance Company of Wisconsin), Wausau Underwriters Insurance Company, Selective Insurance Company of America (formerly known as Exchange Mutual Insurance Company), National Union Fire Insurance Company of Pittsburgh, PA, Fireman's Fund Insurance Company, Catholic Mutual Group, The National Catholic Risk Retention Group. Statutory Fee Due: $350 - DEFERRED. (Attachments: # 1 Summons) (Flag set: AP, APpending, DEFER) (Butler, Brian) (Entered: 02/28/2020)Filed Feb 28, 2020Feb 28, 2020
- Dkt. 1Adversary case 1-21-01001. 91 (Declaratory judgment) 14 (Recovery of money/property - other). Complaint Filed by All Saints Roman Catholic Church Society of Buffalo, All Saints Roman Catholic Parish of Lockport, New York, Assumption Roman Catholic Church Society of Buffalo, N.Y., Assumption Hungarian R.C. Church Society of Lackawanna, Blessed Sacrament R.C. Church Society of Tonawanda Township, Blessed Sacrament Roman Catholic Church Society of Andover, Blessed Sacrament Roman Catholic Church Society of Delevan, N.Y. n/k/a St. Mary Roman Catholic Church Society of Arcade, N.Y., Blessed Sacrament Roman Catholic Church Society of Tonawanda, Blessed Trinity Roman Catholic Church Society of Buffalo, N.Y., Catholic Society of St. Marys Church, Lockport, NY n/k/a All Saints Roman Catholic Parish of Lockport, New York, Church of Christ, the King, Church of the Holy Trinity Dunkirk N.Y., Church of St. John Baptist of West Valley, N.Y., Coronation of the Blessed Virgin Mary Roman Catholic Church Society of Buffalo, N.Y., Holy Apostles Peter and Paul Roman Catholic Church Society of Buffalo, N.Y. n/k/a St. Clare Roman Catholic Church Society Buffalo, N.Y., Holy Cross Roman Catholic Church Society of Buffalo, New York, Holy Family Roman Catholic Church Society, Holy Family Roman Catholic Church Society of Machias, N.Y. n/k/a St. Philomenas Roman Catholic Church Society of Franklinville, N.Y., Holy Name of Jesus Roman Catholic Church, Holy Spirit Roman Catholic Church Society of North Collins, N.Y., Holy Trinity Roman Catholic Church Society of Niagara Falls, N.Y. n/k/a Divine Mercy Roman Catholic Parish of Niagara Falls, N.Y., Immaculate Conception Rom. Catholic Church Society of Buffalo n/k/a Holy Cross Roman Catholic Church Society of Buffalo, New York, Immaculate Conception Roman Catholic Church Society of Cassadaga, N.Y. n/k/a Saint Anthonys Roman Catholic Church Society of Fredonia New York, Immaculate Conception Roman Catholic Church Society of Eden Center, N.Y., Immaculate Conception, East Bethany n/k/a Mary Immaculate Roman Catholic Parish of Pavilion, N.Y., Immaculate Heart of Mary Roman. Catholic Church Society of Buffalo, New York n/k/a St. Aloysius Gonzaga Roman Catholic Church Society of Cheektowaga, New York, Incorporated, Infant of Prague Roman Catholic Church Society of Cheektowaga, New York, Most Precious Blood Rom. Cath. Church Society of Angola, Nativity of the Blessed Virgin Mary Roman Catholic Church Society of Harris Hill, N.Y., Nativity of the Blessed Virgin Roman Catholic Church Society of Buffalo n/k/a Our Lady of Hope Roman Catholic Parish of Buffalo, New York, Our Lady Help of Christians, East Bennington n/k/a Immaculate Heart of Mary Roman Catholic Parish, Our Lady Help of Christians Roman Catholic Church of Cheektowaga, New York, Our Lady of Czestochowa R.C. Church Society, Our Lady of Czestochowa Roman Catholic Church Society of Forks, Cheektowaga, Our Lady of Czestochowa Roman Catholic Church Society of North Tonawanda, New York, Our Lady of Fatima Roman Catholic Church Society of Elba, New York n/k/a Saint Padre Pio Roman Catholic Parish, Our Lady of Good Counsel Roman Catholic Church Society of Darien Center, N.Y. n/k/a Immaculate Heart of Mary Roman Catholic Parish, Our Lady of Grace Roman Catholic Church Society of Woodlawn, New York n/k/a Queen of Angels R.C. Church of Lackawanna, NY, Our Lady of Lebanon Roman Catholic Church Society of Niagara Falls n/k/a Divine Mercy Roman Catholic Parish of Niagara Falls, N.Y., Our Lady of Loretto Roman Catholic Church Society of Buffalo, New York, Incorporated n/k/a Our Lady of Hope Roman Catholic Parish of Buffalo, New York, Our Lady of Loretto Roman Catholic Church Society, Our Lady of Lourdes, Buffalo, Our Lady of Mount Carmel Roman Catholic Church Society of Niagara Falls, New York n/k/a Holy Family of Jesus, Mary, and Joseph Roman Catholic Church of Niagara Falls, N.Y., Our Lady of Mount Carmel Roman Catholic Church Society of Silver Creek, N.Y., Our Lady of Mt. Carmel Roman Catholic Church Society of Brant, New York n/k/a Saint Anthonys Roman Catholic Church Society of Farnham, New York, Our Lady of Peace Roman Catholic Church Society of Clarence, Our Lady of Perpetual Help Roman Catholic Church Society of Buffalo, N.Y., Our Lady of Perpetual Help Roman Catholic Church Society of Lakeview n/k/a Blessed John Paul II Roman Catholic Parish Community, Our Lady of Pompeii Roman Catholic Church of Lancaster, Our Lady of Sacred Heart R.C. Church Society, Our Lady of the Angels Roman Catholic Church Society of Cuba, Our Lady of the Rosary Roman Catholic Church Society of Niagara Falls, N.Y. n/k/a Divine Mercy Roman Catholic Parish of Niagara Falls, N.Y., Our Lady of the Sacred Heart of Jesus R.C. Church Society, Our Lady of Victory National Shrine, Lackawanna, Our Lady of Victory Roman Catholic Church Society of Frewsburg, N.Y. n/k/a St. James Roman Catholic Church Society of Jamestown, N.Y., Our Mother of Good Counsel R.C. Church Society Inc., Our Mother of Good Counsel Roman Catholic Church Society of Blasdell, N.Y., Prince of Peace of Roman Catholic Church Society and St. Charles Borromeo Chapel n/k/a St. Vincent de Paul Roman Catholic Parish of Niagara Falls, New York, Queen of All Saints, Lackawanna, Queen of Heaven Roman Catholic Church Society, Inc., Queen of Heaven Roman Catholic Church Society of West Seneca, New York, Queen of the Most Holy Rosary, Buffalo, Queen of Martyrs Roman Catholic Church Society of Cheektowaga, New York, Resurrection Roman Catholic Church Society of Cheektowaga, New York, Roman Catholic Church of St. Marys n/k/a St. Mary Roman Catholic Church Society of Arcade, N.Y., Sacred Heart of Jesus Roman Catholic Church Society of N. Collins, NY, Sacred Heart of Jesus Roman Catholic Church Society of Bowmansville, N.Y., Sacred Heart R.C. Church Society of Buffalo, NY, Sacred Heart Roman Catholic Church Society of Angelica, N.Y. n/k/a Holy Family of Jesus, Mary, and Joseph Roman Catholic Church Society of Belmont, N.Y., Sacred Heart Roman Catholic Church Society of Bennington, N.Y. n/k/a Immaculate Heart of Mary Roman Catholic Parish, Sacred Heart Roman Catholic Church Society of Friendship n/k/a Our Lady of Angels Roman Catholic Church Society of Cuba, Sacred Heart Roman Catholic Church Society of Lakewood, New York, Sacred Heart Roman Catholic Church Society of Portville, New York n/k/a The Church of St. Mary of the Angels, Olean, Sacred Heart Roman Catholic Church Society of Suspension Bridge, N.Y., Niagara Falls n/k/a St. Raphaels Roman Catholic Parish of Niagara Falls, N.Y., Saint Anthonys Roman Catholic Church Society of Farnham, New York, Saint Anthonys Roman Catholic Church Society of Fredonia New York, Saint Bernards Roman Catholic Church Society of Buffalo, N.Y., Saint Casimirs Roman Catholic Church Society of Buffalo, N.Y., Saint Gerards Roman Catholic Church Society of Buffalo, N.Y. n/k/a Blessed Trinity Roman Catholic Church Society of Buffalo, N.Y., Saint Georges Roman Catholic Church Society of Niagara Falls, N.Y. n/k/a Divine Mercy Roman Catholic Parish of Niagara Falls, N.Y., Saint John Gualbertus Roman Catholic Church Society of Cheektowaga, Erie Co., N.Y., Saint Martins Roman Catholic Church Society, Saint Nicholas Roman Catholic Church Society, Saint Patricks Roman Catholic Church Society, Saint Patricks Roman Catholic Church Society, Fillmore, Saints Peter and Pauls Church of Jamestown, N.Y. n/k/a Holy Apostles Roman Catholic Parish of Jamestown, N.Y., Saints Peter and Pauls Roman Catholic Church Society of Williamsville, S. S. Peter & Pauls German Catholic Church Hamburg N.Y., SS. Peter and Paul Roman Catholic Church Society of Depew, New York n/k/a Our Lady of Pompeii Roman Catholic Church of Lancaster, St. Adalberts Rom. Cath. Church Society of Buffalo, N.Y. n/k/a St. John Kanty Roman Catholic Church Society of Buffalo, St. Agnes Catholic Church Society, Buffalo n/k/a St. Katharine Drexel Roman Catholic Church Society of Buffalo, N.Y., St. Ambroses Roman Catholic Church of Buffalo n/k/a Our Lady of Charity Catholic Parish, St. Anthonys Roman Catholic Church Society of Buffalo, St. Anthonys Roman Catholic Church Society of Batavia, N.Y. n/k/a Ascension Roman Catholic Parish of Batavia, N.Y., St. Anthonys Roman Catholic Church Society of Lackawanna, New York, St. Anthonys Roman Catholic Church Society of Lime Rock, New York n/k/a Our Lady of Mercy Roman Catholic Parish of LeRoy, New York, St. Anthonys Roman Catholic Church Society of Lockport n/k/a All Saints Roman Catholic Parish of Lockport, New York, St. Albert the Great Roman Catholic Church Society of North Tonawanda, N.Y. n/k/a Saint Jude the Apostle Roman Catholic Parish of North Tonawanda, New York, St. Aloysius Church of Springville, St. Aloysius Gonzaga Roman Catholics Church Society of Cheektowaga, New York, St. Amelias Roman Catholic Church Society of the Town of Tonawanda, N.Y., St. Andrews Roman Catholic Church Society, St. Anns Roman Catholic Church of Buffalo, N.Y. n/k/a Sts. Columba-Brigid Roman Catholic Church of Buffalo, N.Y., St. Augustines Roman Catholic Church Society of Depew, N.Y. n/k/a Blessed Mother Teresa of Calcutta Roman Catholic Parish of Depew, New York, St. Augustines Roman Catholic Church Society of Rapids-Clarence Center, New York n/k/a The Good Shepherd Roman Catholic Church Society of Pendleton, N.Y., St. Barbaras Roman Catholic Church Society n/k/a Queen of Angels R.C. Church of Lackawanna, N.Y., St. Barnabas Church Society of New York, St. Bartholomews R.C. Church Society of Buffalo, NY, St. Benedicts Roman Catholic Church Society of Eggertsville, St. Bernadette R.C. Church Society of Armor, NY, St. Bernards Roman Catholic Church Society of Youngstown, N.Y., St. Bonaventures Roman Catholic Church Society of West Seneca, N.Y. n/k/a Saint John XXIII Roman Catholic Parish of West Seneca, New York, St. Bonaventures Roman Catholic Church Society of Allegany, St. Boniface Roman Catholic Church Society, St. Brendans Roman Catholic Church Society of Almond, N.Y., (Alfred), St. Bridgets Roman Catholic Church Society of Newfane, N.Y. n/k/a St. Brendan on the Lake Roman Catholic Parish of Newfane, Olcott, St. Brigid, Buffalo, St. Brigids Roman Catholic Church Society of Bergen, N.Y., formerly known as St. Bridget Bergen, St. Brigids Roman Catholic Church Society, Inc., St. Cecilias Church, Sheldon n/k/a St. John Neumann Roman Catholic Church of Wyoming County, St. Cecilias Roman Catholic Church Society of Oakfield, New York n/k/a Saint Padre Pio Roman Catholic Parish, St. Charles Borromeo Roman Catholic Church of Olcott, n/k/a St. Brendan on the Lake Roman Catholic Parish of Newfane, Olcott, and Wilson, St. Charles Roman Catholic Church Society, St. Christophers Roman Catholic Church Society of Tonawanda, St. Columbas Roman Catholic Church Society of Buffalo, N.Y. n/k/a Sts. Columba-Brigid Roman Catholic Church of Buffalo, N.Y., St. Edmunds Roman Catholic Church Society of Tonawanda, N.Y. n/k/a St. Christophers Roman Catholic Church Society of Tonawanda, St. Elizabeth, Cherry Creek, St. Elizabeths Roman Catholic Church of Buffalo, N.Y. n/k/a Assumption Roman Catholic Church Society of Buffalo, N.Y., St. Florians Roman Catholic Church Society of Buffalo, N.Y. n/k/a All Saints Roman Catholic Church Society of Buffalo, St. Frances Cabrini Parish (Collins Center, NY) n/k/a Epiphany of Our Lord Roman Catholic Parish Community, Langford, N.Y, St. Francis Church Society of Tonawanda Village, Tonawanda, St. Francis de Sales, Buffalo, St. Francis of Assisi Roman Catholic Church Society of Athol Springs, New York, St. Francis of Assisi Roman Catholic Church Society of Corfu, New York n/k/a Saint Maximilian Kolbe Roman Catholic Parish of Corfu, N.Y., St. Francis of Assisi Roman Catholic Church Society of Buffalo n/k/an/k/a St. Katharine Drexel Roman Catholic Church Society of Buffalo, N.Y, St. Gabriels Roman Catholic Church Society of Blossom, St. Georges Roman Catholic Church Society, St. Georges Roman Catholic Church Society of Jewettville, New York, St. Helens Church n/k/a St. Johns Roman Catholic Church Society of Olean, N.Y, St. Hiacinth Roman Catholic Church Society of Dunkirk N.Y. n/k/a Blessed Mary Angela R.C. Parish of Dunkirk, N.Y., St. Hyacinth Roman Catholic Church Society of Dunkirk, New York n/k/a Blessed Mary Angela R.C. Parish of Dunkirk, N.Y., St. Hyacinths Roman Catholic Church Society of Lackawanna n/k/a Queen of Angels R.C. Church of Lackawanna, NY, St. Isidores Roman Catholic Church Society of East Otto, N.Y., St. James Roman Catholic Church Society of Depew, N.Y., n/k/a Blessed Mother Teresa of Calcutta Roman Catholic Parish of Depew, New York, St. James Roman Catholic Church Society of Jamestown, N.Y. n/k/a Holy Apostles Roman Catholic Parish of Jamestown, N.Y., St. James Major Roman Catholic Church Society of Westfield, N.Y. n/k/a St. Dominic Roman Catholic Church of Chautauqua, St. James Roman Catholic Church Society of Buffalo, N.Y. n/k/a Blessed Trinity Roman Catholic Church Society of Buffalo, N.Y., St. Joachim, Buffalo, St. Joan of Arc Roman Catholic Church Society of Perrysburg, N.Y. n/k/a St. Josephs Roman Catholic Church Society of Gowanda, N.Y., St. John Baptist Roman Catholic Church Society of Carrollton, Vandalia n/k/a St. Bonaventures Roman Catholic Church Society of Allegany, St. John Baptists Rom. Cath. Church Society of Boston, N.Y., St. John Bosco Roman Catholic Church Society of Sheridan, N.Y. n/k/a Our Lady of Mount Carmel Roman Catholic Church Society of Silver Creek, N.Y.,, St. John Cantius R.C. Church Society, St. John De La Salle Roman Catholic Church of LaSalle, N.Y., St. John Fisher Roman Catholic Church Society of South Dayton, N.Y. n/k/a St. Josephs Roman Catholic Church Society of Gowanda, N.Y., St. John Kanty Roman Catholic Church Society of Buffalo, St. John Maron Roman Catholic Church Society of Buffalo, New York, St. John of the Cross, Whitesville, St. John the Baptist R.C. Church Society of Alden Center, New York, St. John the Baptist Roman Catholic Church Society of Carrollton n/k/a St. Bonaventures Roman Catholic Church Society of Allegany, St. John the Baptist Roman Catholic Church, Kenmore, N.Y., St. John the Baptists Roman Catholic Church Society of N. Collins, NY, St. John the Evangelist Roman Catholic Church Society of Sinclairville, N.Y. n/k/a Saint Anthonys Roman Catholic Church Society of Fredonia, St. John Vianney Roman Catholic Church Society of Orchard Park, N.Y., St. Johns Roman Catholic Church Society of Jamestown n/k/a Holy Apostles Roman Catholic Parish of Jamestown, N.Y., St. Johns Roman Catholic Church Society of Olean, N.Y., St. Josephats Roman Catholic Church of Cheektowaga, N.Y., St. Joseph New Cathedral, Buffalo, St. Joseph Roman Catholic Church Society of Albion, New York n/k/a Holy Family Roman Catholic Parish of Albion, N.Y., St. Joseph Roman Catholic Church Society of Lyndonville, N.Y. n/k/a Our Lady of the Lake Roman Catholic Parish of Barker and Lyndonville, N.Y., St. Josephs Cath. Church of Holland, St. Josephs R.C. Church, St. Josephs Rom. Cath. Church Society of Batavia, N.Y., n/k/a Resurrection Roman Catholic Parish of Batavia, N.Y., St. Josephs Roman Catholic Church Society of Bliss, N.Y. n/k/a Saint Isidore Roman Catholic Parish of Perry, New York, St. Josephs Roman Catholic Society of Buffalo, NY, St. Josephs Roman Catholic Church of Fredonia, N.Y., St. Josephs Roman Catholic Church Society of Gowanda, N.Y., St. Josephs Roman Catholic Church Society of Leroy, New York n/k/a Our Lady of Mercy Roman Catholic Parish of LeRoy, St. Josephs Roman Catholic Church Society of Lockport, N.Y., n/k/a All Saints Roman Catholic Parish of Lockport, New York, St. Josephs Roman Catholic Church of Niagara Falls, N.Y. n/k/a Holy Family of Jesus, Mary, and Joseph Roman Catholic Church of Niagara Falls, N.Y., St. Josephs Roman Catholic Church Society of North Tonawanda, New York n/k/a Our Lady of Czestochowa Roman Catholic Church Society of North Tonawanda, New York, St. Josephs Roman Catholic Church Society of Perry (Wyom. Co. NY) n/k/a Saint Isidore Roman Catholic Parish of Perry, St. Judes Roman Catholic Church Society of Sardinia, New York, St. Josephs Roman Catholic Church Society of Scio, N.Y. n/k/a Holy Family of Jesus, Mary, and Joseph Roman Catholic Church Society of Belmont, N.Y., St. Josephs Roman Catholic Church Society of Varysburg, New York n/k/a SS. Joachim & Anne Roman Catholic Church of Attica, New York, St. Lawrences Roman Catholic Church Society of Buffalo, St. Leos Roman Catholic Church Society, St. Leo the Great Roman Catholic Church, Amherst, New York, St. Leos Roman Catholic Church Society of Niagara Falls, N.Y. n/k/a St. Vincent de Paul Roman Catholic Parish of Niagara Falls, New York, St. Leos Roman Catholic Society of Eggertsville, N.Y., St. Louis Roman Catholic Church of Buffalo, N.Y., St. Lucys Roman Catholic Church, St. Luke R.C. Church Society of Buffalo, NY, St. Margarets Roman Catholic Church Society of Buffalo, New York, St. Marks Roman Catholic Church Society of Buffalo, N.Y., St. Marks Roman Catholic Church Society of Rushford, N.Y. n/k/a St. Patricks Roman Catholic Church Society of Belfast, N.Y., St. Martins Church Society Langford Erie County n/k/a Epiphany of Our Lord Roman Catholic Parish Community, Langford, N.Y., St. Mary Magdalene Roman Catholic Church Society, St. Mary of Immaculate Conception RCC Society, St. Mary of Lourdes Roman Catholic Church Society of Chautauqua, Bemus Point, St. Mary Redemptorist, Buffalo, St. Marys Catholic Church Society of East Eden n/k/a St. John Baptists Rom. Cath. Church Society of Boston, N.Y., St. Marys Catholic Church Society of Pavilion, N.Y. n/k/a Mary Immaculate Roman Catholic Parish of Pavilion, N.Y., St. Marys Church of the Redemptorists of Buffalo, NY, St. Marys of the Lake Roman Catholic Church Society of Mount Vernon, Hamburg, St. Marys Roman Church Society n/k/a The St. John the Baptist Roman Cath Congregation, St. Marys Roman Catholic Church Society of Batavia, N.Y. n/k/a Resurrection Roman Catholic Parish of Batavia, N.Y., St. Marys Roman Catholic Church Society of Belmont, N.Y. n/k/a Holy Family of Jesus, Mary, and Joseph Roman Catholic Church Society of Belmont, N.Y., St. Marys Roman Catholic Church Society of Bolivar, New York, St. Marys Roman Catholic Church Society of Canaseraga, New York, St. Marys Roman Catholic Church Society of Cattaraugus, N.Y., St. Marys Roman Catholic Church Society of Holley, St. Marys Roman Catholic Church Society of Little Valley, N.Y. n/k/a St. Marys Roman Catholic Church Society of Cattaraugus, N.Y., St. Marys Roman Catholic Church Society of Mayville, N.Y. n/k/a St. Mary of Lourdes Roman Catholic Church Society of Chautauqua, St. Marys Roman Catholic Church Society of Medina, N.Y. n/k/a Holy Trinity Roman Catholic Church of Medina, New York, St. Marys Roman Catholic Church Society of Niagara Falls, N.Y., St. Marys Roman Catholic Church Society of Strykersville n/k/a St. John Neumann Roman Catholic Church of Wyoming County, St. Marys Roman Catholic Church Society of Swormville, St. Marys Roman Catholic Church Society Silver Springs N.Y. n/k/a Saint Isidore Roman Catholic Parish of Perry, New York, St. Matthews Roman Catholic Church Society, St. Michael Archangel Roman Catholic Church Society of Lackawanna n/k/a Queen of Angels R.C. Church of Lackawanna, NY, St. Michaels Roman Catholic Church Society of Buffalo, NY, St. Michaels Roman Catholic Church Society of Warsaw, N.Y., St. Michaels Roman Catholic Church Society of South Byron n/k/a St. Brigids Roman Catholic Church Society of Bergen, N.Y., St. Monicas Roman Catholic Church Society, St. Nicholas Roman Catholic Congregation of North Java N.Y. n/k/a St. John Neumann Roman Catholic Church of Wyoming County, St. Pacificus Church & Cemetery Association of Humphrey n/k/a The Holy Name of Mary Roman Catholic Church Society of Ellicottville, N.Y., St. Patricks Roman Catholic Church of Belfast, N.Y., St. Patrick Roman Catholic Church Society of Hartland n/k/a Our Lady of the Lake Roman Catholic Parish of Barker and Lyndonville, N.Y., St. Patricks Roman Catholic Church Society of the City of Lockport, N.Y. n/k/a All Saints Roman Catholic Parish of Lockport, New York, St. Patricks Roman Catholic Church Society of Limestone, N.Y. n/k/a Our Lady of Peace Salamanca, St. Patricks Roman Catholic Church Society of Randolph, N. Y., St. Patricks Roman Catholic Church Society of Salamanca, N.Y. n/k/a Our Lady of Peace Roman Catholic Parish of Salamanca, N.Y., St. Pauls Roman Catholic Church Society of Dayton, N.Y., St. Pauls Roman Catholic Church Society of Kenmore, St. Peters Roman Catholic Church Society of Leroy n/k/a Our Lady of Mercy Roman Catholic Parish of LeRoy, New York, St. Philomenas Roman Catholic Church Society of Franklinville, N.Y., St. Pius X Roman Catholic Church Society of Town of Amherst, N.Y., SS. Rita and Patrick Roman Catholic Church Society of Buffalo, N.Y. n/k/a St. Clare Roman Catholic Church Society of Buffalo, N.Y., St. Rose of Lima Roman Catholic Church Society of Buffalo, St. Rose of Lima Roman Catholic Church of Forestville n/k/a Our Lady of Mount Carmel Roman Catholic Church Society of Silver Creek, N.Y., St. Stanislaus Church Society, St. Stanislaus Kostkas Roman Catholic Church Society of Niagara Falls, N.Y. n/k/a Divine Mercy Roman Catholic Parish of Niagara Falls, N.Y., St. Stanislaus Kostkas Roman Catholic Church Society of Perry, N.Y. n/k/a Saint Isidore Roman Catholic Parish of Perry, New York, St. Stephens Rom. Cath. Church Society of Buffalo n/k/a St. Clare Roman Catholic Church Society of Buffalo, N.Y., St. Stephens Roman Catholic Church of Grand Island, N.Y., St. Stephens Roman Catholic Church Society n/k/a Holy Trinity Roman Catholic Church of Medina, New York, St. Teresa of Avila Roman Catholic Church of Akron, NY, St. Teresa of the Infant Jesus Roman Catholic Church of Niagara Falls n/k/a St. Raphaels Roman Catholic Parish of Niagara Falls, N.Y., St. Teresas Roman Catholic Church Society, St. Thomas Aquinas Roman Catholic Church Society of Buffalo, St. Thomas More, Ripley, St. Timothys Roman Catholic Church Society of Tonawanda, N.Y., St. Valentines Roman Catholic Church Society of Buffalo n/k/a St. Clare Roman Catholic Church Society of Buffalo, N.Y., St. Vincent de Paul Roman Catholic Church Society of Buffalo, St. Vincents Roman Catholic Church Society of Attica, N.Y. n/k/a SS. Joachim & Anne Roman Catholic Church of Attica, New York, St. Vincents Roman Catholic Church Society of North Evans n/k/a Saint John Paul II Roman Catholic Parish Community, St. Vincents Roman Catholic Church of Springbrook, N.Y., Sts. Agatha and Ambrose Roman Catholic Parish of Buffalo, N.Y. n/k/a Our Lady of Charity Catholic Parish, Sts. Peter and Paul R. C. Church Society Arcade, New York n/k/a St. Mary Roman Catholic Church Society of Arcade, N.Y., The Annunciation Roman Catholic Church Society of Buffalo, N.Y. n/k/a Our Lady of Hope Roman Catholic Parish of Buffalo, New York, The Ascension Roman Catholic Church Society of North Tonawanda n/k/a Saint Jude the Apostle Roman Catholic Parish of North Tonawanda, New York, The Assumption Roman Catholic Church Society of Albion n/k/a Holy Family Roman Catholic Parish of Albion, N.Y., The Assumption Roman Catholic Church Society of Portageville, N.Y. n/k/a Saint Isidore Roman Catholic Parish of Perry, New York, The Church of St. Mary of Angels, Olean, The Church of St. Mary of Sorrows n/k/a Sts. Columba-Brigid Roman Catholic Church of Buffalo, N.Y., The Church of the Assumption of Lancaster N.Y., The Good Shepherd Roman Catholic Church Society of Pendleton, N.Y., The Holy Cross Roman Catholic Church Society of Salamanca, New York n/k/a St. Patricks Roman Catholic Church Society of Limestone, N.Y., The Holy Family Roman Catholic Church Society of the City of Buffalo n/k/a Our Lady of Charity Catholic Parish, The Holy Fourteen Helpers of the Town of West Seneca, Middle Ebenezer, The Holy Name of Mary Roman Catholic Church Society of East Pembroke, N.Y. n/k/a Saint Maximilian Kolbe Roman Catholic Parish of Corfu, N.Y., The Holy Name of Mary Roman Catholic Church Society of Ellicottville, The Immaculate Conception Roman Catholic Church Society of East Aurora, N.Y., The Immaculate Conception Roman Catholic Church Society of Wellsville, N.Y., The Most Holy Redeemer Roman Catholic Church Society of Cheektowaga, N.Y. n/k/a St. Lawrences Roman Catholic Church Society of Buffalo, The Nativity Roman Catholic Church Society of Orchard Park, New York, The Queen of Peace Roman Catholic Church Society of Buffalo n/k/a Saint John Gualbertus Roman Catholic Church Society of Cheektowaga, Erie Co., N.Y., The Roman Catholic Church of St. Franciscus Xavarius, Buffalo n/k/a Assumption Roman Catholic Church Society of Buffalo, N.Y., The Sacred Heart of Jesus Roman Catholic Church Society of Batavia, New York n/k/a Ascension Roman Catholic Parish of Batavia, N.Y., The Sacred Heart of Jesus Roman Catholic Church Society of Dunkirk New York, The St. John Baptists Society North Buffalo n/k/a Assumption Roman Catholic Church Society of Buffalo, N.Y., The Visitation Roman Catholic Church Society of Buffalo N.Y. n/k/a St. Katharine Drexel Roman Catholic Church Society of Buffalo, N.Y., Transfiguration, Buffalo, Transfiguration Roman Catholic Church Society n/k/a St. Johns Roman Catholic Church Society of Olean, N.Y., Trustees of St. Patrick Church, Town of Java n/k/a St. John Neumann Roman Catholic Church of Wyoming County, The Diocese of Buffalo, N.Y. vs 21st Century Premier Insurance Company (f/k/a National Ben Franklin Fire Insurance Co. of Pittsburgh, PA), Ace Property and Casualty Insurance (successor-in-interest to Aetna Insurance Company), Home Fire and Marine Insurance Company of California d/b/a Firemans Fund Corporation, American Alternative Insurance Corporation (successor-in-interest to American Union Insurance Company of New York), American Automobile Insurance Company, American Guarantee and Liability Insurance Company, American Insurance Company, Arrowood Indemnity Company (successor-in-interest to American and Foreign Insurance Company, Eagle Indemnity Company of New York, Globe Indemnity Company, Phoenix Assurance Company of New York, New Am, Bedivere Insurance Company (f/k/a Potomac Insurance Company and successor-in-interest to General Accident Insurance Company of America), Century Indemnity Company, Certain Underwriters at Lloyds, London and Certain London Market Companies, Columbia Casualty Company, Continental Casualty Company, Continental Insurance Company (successor-in-interest to Boston Old Colony Insurance Company, Commercial Insurance Company of Newark, New Jersey (f/k/a Commercial Casualty Insurance Company), Fidelity, Covenant Insurance Company (successor-in-interest of Covenant Mutual Insurance Company), Employers Fire Insurance Company; Employers Insurance Company of Wausau (f/k/a Employers Insurance of Wausau A Mutual Company f/k/a Employers Mutual Liability Insurance Company of Wisconsin), Excelsior Insurance Company, Fair American Insurance and Reinsurance Company (f/k/a Putnam Reinsurance Company), Federal Insurance Company, Firemans Fund Insurance Company, Great American Insurance Company (successor-in-interest to Agricultural Insurance Company), Great American Insurance Company of New York (successor-in-interest to American National Fire Insurance Company), Guarantee Mutual Assurance Co. of America; Hanover Insurance Company (successor-in-interest to Massachusetts Bonding and Insurance Company), Harford Mutual Insurance Company, Hartford Steam Boiler Inspection and Insurance Company, Indemnity Insurance Company of North America, Insurance Company of North America, Integon National Insurance Company (f/k/a Bankers and Shippers Insurance Company), Lamorak Insurance Company (f/k/a OneBeacon America Insurance Company f/k/a Commercial Union Insurance Company f/k/a Employers Commercial Union Insurance Company), Liberty Mutual Insurance Company, Merchants Mutual Insurance Company, Metropolitan Casualty Insurance Company, Michigan Millers Mutual Insurance Company, Middlesex Insurance Company (f/k/a Middlesex Mutual Insurance Company), National Surety Corporation, National Union Fire Insurance Company of Pittsburgh, PA, Nationwide Insurance Company of America, Nationwide Mutual Insurance Company (f/k/a Farm Bureau Mutual Automobile Insurance Company), New England Insurance Company (f/k/a New England Reinsurance Corporation), New Hampshire Insurance Company (f/k/a Mainland Insurance Company, successor-in-interest to New York Casualty Insurance Company), New Hampshire Insurance Company, New York Central Mutual Fire Insurance Company, NGM Insurance Company (successor-in-interest to National Grange Mutual Insurance Company), North River Insurance Company, Pawtucket Insurance Company, Peerless Insurance Company, Pennsylvania Lumbermens Mutual Insurance Company, Phoenix & London Assurance Limited, Phoenix Insurance Company, Providence Washington Insurance Company, Royal Globe Insurance Company, RSUI Indemnity Company (successor-in-interest to Buffalo Insurance Company), Selective Insurance Company of America (f/k/a Exchange Mutual Insurance Company f/k/a Exchange Mutual Indemnity Insurance Company), SPARTA Insurance Company (successor-in-interest to American Employers Insurance Company), St. Paul Fire and Marine Insurance Company, St. Paul Mercury Insurance Company, The Hartford Financial Services Group (successor-in-interest to Hartford Accident and Indemnity Company and Hartford Fire Insurance Company), TIG Insurance Company (successor-in-interest to American Surety Company of New York), Travelers Casualty and Surety Company (successor-in-interest to Aetna Casualty and Surety Company), Travelers Indemnity Company (successor-in-interest to Gulf Insurance Company), U.S. Fidelity and Guaranty Company, U.S. Fire Insurance Company, Unigard Insurance Company (successor-in-interest to Jamestown Mutual Insurance Company), Utica Mutual Insurance Company, Westport Insurance Corporation (successor-in-interest to the Manhattan Fire and Marine Insurance Company), Yorkshire Insurance Company of New York (f/k/a The Yorkshire Indemnity Company of New York), Zurich American Insurance Company. Statutory Fee Due: $350 - DEFERRED. (Attachments: # 1 Summons) (Flag set: AP, APpending, DEFER) (Lyster, Timothy) (Entered: 01/19/2021)Filed Jan 19, 2021Jan 19, 2021
- Dkt. 4844Main Street Sale ApprovedFiled May 29, 2026May 29, 2026
- Dkt. 4901Diocese Joint Reorganization PlanFiled Jun 17, 2026Jun 17, 2026
- Dkt. 5056Amended Reorganization PlanFiled Aug 21, 2026Aug 21, 2026
- Dkt. 5057Buffalo Diocese Plan ProposalFiled Aug 21, 2026Aug 21, 2026
- Dkt. 5076Buffalo Diocese Plan ProposalFiled Aug 27, 2026Aug 27, 2026
- Dkt. 5155Property Sale Bidding OrderFiled Oct 13, 2026Oct 13, 2026
- Dkt. 5212Insurance Settlement RulingFiled Nov 2, 2026Nov 2, 2026
- Dkt. 5233July Operating SchedulesFiled Nov 13, 2026Nov 13, 2026
- Dkt. 5238Broker Employment AuthorizedFiled Nov 16, 2026Nov 16, 2026
- Dkt. 5239Property Sale ProceduresFiled Nov 16, 2026Nov 16, 2026
- Dkt. 5239Diocese Property Sale NoticeFiled Nov 17, 2026Nov 17, 2026
- Dkt. 5246Plan Voting TabulationFiled Nov 16, 2026Nov 16, 2026
- Dkt. 5249Insurers’ Policy Carve-Out RiderFiled Nov 17, 2026Nov 17, 2026
- Dkt. 5255OLV Insurance ObjectionFiled Nov 17, 2026Nov 17, 2026
- WebAbuse survivors approve the Buffalo Diocese’s $327 million settlement plan, with court approval still to come | The Buffalo Chroniclebuffalochronicle.com · Outside source
- WebJudge approves broker for sale of former St. Mary’s Church in Cattaraugusbtpm.org · Outside source