Albany diocese takes chapter 11 plan to December 17 disclosure hearing as creditors’ committee seeks delay for discovery
ElevenFlo ·
The diocese’s disclosure-statement motion, which also seeks solicitation, balloting and confirmation-hearing procedures for its plan, is set for hearing December 17, 2026. On November 16 the official committee of unsecured creditors asked the court to adjourn that hearing without a date until it receives discovery responses due in early December and deposes a diocese representative, or else to hold a prompt section 105 conference Dkt. 2925.
Jump to section
The Roman Catholic Diocese of Albany filed for chapter 11 on March 15, 2023, after 440 suits under New York’s Child Victims Act. The official committee of unsecured creditors wants discovery from the diocese, its parishes and its insurers before the court takes up the disclosure statement.
The Diocese of Albany has filed a chapter 11 plan and a motion to approve its disclosure statement. The court has set December 17, 2026 to hear that motion, along with the proposed solicitation, balloting and confirmation-hearing procedures. The official committee of unsecured creditors, which is separate from the official committee of tort claimants, wants the hearing taken off the calendar. In a November 16 letter it asked for an adjournment without a date, with the hearing re-noticed after it receives and evaluates discovery and deposes the diocese’s representative. As an alternative, it asked for a section 105 conference at the court’s earliest convenience, citing the coming holiday and its December 10 response deadline Dkt. 2925. The request is pending.
The October bill from the diocese’s counsel shows the plan process and mediation running side by side. Whiteman Osterman & Hanna billed 78.0 hours in October, mainly on the plan and disclosure statement, plan-funding analysis, mediation, a dispute over an additional mediator, Rule 2004 discovery and retention matters Dkt. 2927. On November 13 the court allowed interim compensation on seven professional fee applications and directed the diocese to pay the awards. Most of the money went to advisers to the tort claimants’ committee.
The creditors’ committee says it needs discovery before it can respond to the disclosure statement
The committee’s letter says its push for discovery began with a Rule 2004 motion filed August 18, 2026. After the plan was filed, other parties argued that discovery should proceed under Rule 9014 and Part VII of the bankruptcy rules. The committee says it told the court at the October 15 hearing that it needed substantial discovery before objections and a hearing, and it calls the current timing unfair Dkt. 2925.
On November 5 the committee served Part VII discovery demands on the diocese, the tort claimants’ committee, the parishes, Interstate and the National Catholic Risk Retention Group. Responses are due in early December. The committee is also working with counsel for LMI to identify the proper parties and to learn whether counsel can accept service of subpoenas. It expects requests for more time and objections that may require meet-and-confers or motions to compel. It also says it cannot depose the diocese’s representative until the diocese meets its other disclosure obligations Dkt. 2925.
Child Victims Act suits precipitated the filing
The diocese filed its voluntary petition on March 15, 2023 Dkt. 1. New York’s Child Victims Act, enacted in 2019, reopened the limitations period for sexual abuse claims. Between August 14, 2019 and the petition date, 440 actions were filed against the diocese under the act. The first-day declaration reported that more than 50 of them had been resolved and settled. The Adult Survivors Act, signed in May 2022, opened another one-year window for claims Dkt. 6.
The declaration identified two other disputes. One is the St. Clare’s Action, which involves the St. Clare’s Hospital Retirement Income Plan. The other is an action by New York Attorney General Letitia James that alleges breaches of fiduciary duty and violations of state law in the management of that pension fund. The diocese said it filed to maximize assets for abuse survivors, administer all claims fairly through an equitable assessment process, give certainty on unresolved claims and continue its essential services Dkt. 6.
The diocese was founded in 1847 and incorporated under New York law in 1941. It serves about 306,500 Catholics in 14 upstate counties through 126 parishes and 4 apostolates Dkt. 6. Each parish is a separate not-for-profit corporation under New York’s Religious Corporations Law, with the bishop as president and the pastor as secretary and treasurer. The diocese had about 75 employees at filing Dkt. 7.
Most of the diocese’s $27.4 million in net assets was designated or donor-restricted
The chief financial officer’s first-day declaration reported total assets of $37,736,642 and total liabilities of $10,298,453 at December 31, 2022. That left net assets of about $27.4 million, of which only $1,806,663 was undesignated Dkt. 7.
- Designated funds$16,260,835
- Donor-restricted funds$9,370,690
- Undesignated funds$1,806,663
Show the numbers
| Net asset category | Amount |
|---|---|
| Designated funds | $16,260,835 |
| Donor-restricted funds | $9,370,690 |
| Undesignated funds | $1,806,663 |
| Net assets | $27,438,188 |
Source: chief financial officer’s first-day declaration Dkt. 7
Diocese funds are also held in two investment vehicles. The Foundation of the Roman Catholic Diocese of Albany held about $8,141,862 of diocese funds. The Diocesan Investment and Loan Trust held about $8,700,000, including the diocese’s self-insured retention. The trust pays participants a 2% annual return and charges the diocese a $65,000 annual administrative fee Dkt. 6.
The diocese’s insurance program is administered by Catholic Mutual Group. Its self-insured retentions are $250,000 for general and automobile liability, $500,000 for workers’ compensation and $1,000,000 for real property claims. A $4,316,716 letter of credit from Trustco Bank secures the workers’ compensation coverage. At filing, the diocese asked to keep its existing cash management system, which had 17 accounts at Berkshire Bank, Citizens Bank and KeyBank Dkt. 7. In March 2024 the court authorized a sale of property free and clear of liens under section 363(f) Dkt. 833.
The diocese and its parishes sued their insurers in October 2023
On October 31, 2023 the diocese filed an adversary complaint seeking a declaratory judgment, joined by parishes, churches and apostolates across the diocese. The defendants are Certain Underwriters at Lloyd’s, London, on policies issued to the diocese for September 1, 1978 to September 1, 1991; Catalina Worthing Insurance; Hartford Accident & Indemnity Company; Hartford Fire Insurance Co.; Interstate Fire & Casualty Company; The Catholic Mutual Relief Society of America; and The National Catholic Risk Retention Group Dkt. 1. Interstate, the National Catholic Risk Retention Group and LMI are among the parties the creditors’ committee is now seeking discovery from Dkt. 2925. Blank Rome LLP is the diocese’s special insurance counsel Dkt. 2915.
An earlier adversary proceeding, filed June 1, 2023, sought injunctive and declaratory relief against a group of individual defendants Dkt. 1. The diocese filed a notice of voluntary dismissal of that proceeding on July 7, 2023 Dkt. 35.
The diocese pays its own professionals and the tort committee’s
On November 13, 2026 the court entered seven interim fee orders, and each one directs the diocese to pay the amounts allowed. The largest awards were $673,146.00 in fees to Stinson LLP, counsel to the official committee of tort claimants Dkt. 2918, and $342,906.00 to Stout Risius Ross, the committee’s real estate valuation expert, on its first interim application Dkt. 2919. The orders for Keegan Linscott, Blank Rome and Berkeley Research Group cover January 1 through July 31, 2026.
- Stinson LLP (ninth interim)Counsel to tort claimants’ committee$673,146.00
- Stout Risius Ross (first interim)Real estate valuation expert to tort claimants’ committee$342,906.00
- Burns Bair LLP (eighth interim)Special counsel$73,226.00
- Blank Rome LLP (ninth interim)Diocese’s special insurance counsel$65,708.44
- Keegan Linscott & Associates (ninth interim)Diocese’s financial advisor$31,206.25
- Berkeley Research Group (ninth interim)Financial advisor to tort claimants’ committee$27,605.38
- Stout Risius Ross (seventh interim)Expert consultants to tort claimants’ committee$14,471.00
Show the numbers
| Professional | Role | Fees allowed | Expenses allowed |
|---|---|---|---|
| Stinson LLP (ninth interim) | Counsel to tort claimants’ committee | $673,146.00 | $914.78 |
| Stout Risius Ross (first interim) | Real estate valuation expert to tort claimants’ committee | $342,906.00 | $0.00 |
| Burns Bair LLP (eighth interim) | Special counsel | $73,226.00 | $5,186.62 |
| Blank Rome LLP (ninth interim) | Diocese’s special insurance counsel | $65,708.44 | $5,908.25 |
| Keegan Linscott & Associates (ninth interim) | Diocese’s financial advisor | $31,206.25 | $1,490.84 |
| Berkeley Research Group (ninth interim) | Financial advisor to tort claimants’ committee | $27,605.38 | $0.00 |
| Stout Risius Ross (seventh interim) | Expert consultants to tort claimants’ committee | $14,471.00 | $0.00 |
Under the interim compensation procedures, professionals file monthly statements seeking 80% of their fees. Whiteman Osterman & Hanna’s October statement sought $29,576.40 in fees and $281.27 in costs. Its invoice lists two payments by the diocese applied on October 19, 2026, of $46,311.60 and $78,577.20, and a total balance due of $145,102.17 Dkt. 2927. Keegan Linscott’s October statement is its forty-fourth. It describes reviewing and reconciling the diocese’s August and September monthly operating reports, including discrepancies in reported liabilities and accounts payable, and communications about corrections Dkt. 2929.
Sources
- Dkt. 1Chapter 11 Voluntary Petition for Non-Individuals. Fee Amount $1738 Filed by The Roman Catholic Diocese of Albany, New York. Chapter 11 Plan due by 07/13/2023. Disclosure Statement due by 07/13/2023. (Brennan, Francis) (Entered: 03/15/2023)Filed Mar 15, 2023Mar 15, 2023
- Dkt. 1Adversary case 23-90012-1. (91 (Declaratory judgment)) Complaint by The Roman Catholic Diocese of Albany, New York, All Saints Catholic Church, All Saints on the Hudson Parish (Mechanicville), All Saints on the Hudson Parish (Stillwater), Annunciation Church, Black Catholic Apostolate, Blessed Sacrament Church, (Albany), Blessed Sacrament Church (Mohawk), Blessed Sacrament Church (Bolton Landing), Cathedral of the Immaculate Conception, Christ Our Light Roman Catholic Church, Christ Sun of Justice Parish, Christ the King Church, Church of Saint Joseph (Stottville), Church of Saint Joseph (Stuyvesant), Church of Saint Mary at Clinton Heights, Church of Saint Peter, Church of St. Adalbert, Church of St. Marys/St. Pauls, Church of St. Stanislaus, Church of the Holy Family, Church of the Holy Spirit, Church of the Holy Trinity, Corpus Christi Church, Holy Cross Church (Morris), Holy Cross Church (Salem), Holy Family Parish, Holy Mother and Child Parish (Corinth), Holy Spirit Church, Holy Trinity Catholic Church, Immaculate Conception Church (New Lebanon), Immaculate Conception Church (Hoosick Falls), Immaculate Conception Church (Glenville), Immaculate Heart of Mary Parish (Watervliet/Green Island), Korean Apostolate, Mission Our Lady of the Snow, Notre Dame-Visitation Church, Our Lady of Fatima Church, Our Lady of Grace Church, Our Lady of Hope Church (Whitehall), Our Lady of Knock Shrine, Our Lady of Mount Carmel Church, Our Lady of the Annunciation Church, Our Lady of the Assumption Church, Our Lady of the Snow, Our Lady Queen of Apostles Church, Our Lady Queen of Peace Parish, Parish of Mater Christi, Parish of Our Lady of Hope (Copake Falls), Parish of Our Lady of Hope (Fort Plain), Parish of Our Lady of the Valley, Parish of St. Isaac Jogues (Chestertown), Parish of St. Isaac Jogues (Hague), Parish of the Holy Trinity & Our Lady of Victory Adoration Chapel, Sacred Heart Church (Margaretville), Sacred Heart Church (Sidney), Sacred Heart Church (Stamford), Sacred Heart Church (Cairo), Sacred Heart Church (Tribes Hill), Sacred Heart Church (Castleton-on-Hudson), Sacred Heart Church (Troy), Sacred Heart of Jesus Church, Sacred Heart Church (Lake George), Sacred Heart-Immaculate Conception Church, Shrine Church of Our Lady of the Americas, Spanish Apostolate, St. Ambrose Church, St. Anns (Andes), St. Anns Church, St. Anthony of Padua, St. Anthonys Church, St. Augustines Church, St. Cecilias Church, St. Clares Church, St. Clements Church, St. Edward the Confessor Church, St. Francis de Sales (Elka Park), St. Francis de Sales Church (Herkimer), St. Francis of Assisi Church (Northville), St. Francis of Assisi Parish, Delaware Ave. Site (Albany), St. Francis of Assisi Parish, South End Site (Albany), St. Gabriel the Archangel Church, St. Henrys Church, St. James Church (Chatham), St. James Church (North Creek), St. Joan of Arc Church, St. John the Baptist Church (Valatie), St. John the Baptist Church (Walton), St. John the Baptist Church (Greenville), St. John the Baptist Church (Newport), St. John the Evangelist Church, St. Joseph Church, St. Joseph the Worker Parish (Richfield Springs), St. Joseph the Worker Parish (West Winfield), St. Josephs (Stephentown), St. Josephs Chapel (Ashland), St. Josephs Church (Broadalbin), St. Josephs Church (Dolgeville), St. Josephs Church (Worcester), St. Josephs Church (Greenfield Center), St. Josephs Church (Schenectady), St. Josephs Church (Scotia), St. Josephs Church (Fort Edward), St. Josephs Church (Greenwich), St. Jude the Apostle Church, St. Kateri Tekakwitha Parish, Union Street Site (Schenectady), St. Kateri Tekakwitha, Rosa Road Site (Schenectady), St. Lucy/St. Bernadette Church, St. Lukes Church, St. Madeleine Sophie Church, St. Margaret of Cortona, St. Mary of the Assumption, St. Marys Church (Coxsackie), St. Marys Church (Amsterdam), St. Marys Church (Cooperstown), St. Marys Church (Oneonta), St. Marys Church (Nassau), St. Marys Church (Ballston Spa), St. Marys Church (Waterford), St. Marys Church (Granville), St. Marys Church (Glens Falls), St. Marys Church (Galway), St. Marys Church on Capitol Hill (Albany), St. Marys Church, Crescent (Waterford), St. Matthews Church, St. Michael the Archangel Church (Troy), St. Michael the Archangel Church (South Glens Falls), St. Michaels Church, St. Patricks Church (Ravena), St. Patricks Church (Athens), St. Patricks Church (Catskill), St. Patricks Church (Cambridge), St. Paul the Apostle Church (Hancock), St. Paul the Apostle Church (Schenectady), St. Pauls Church (Rock City Falls), St. Peter the Apostle Church (Stillwater), St. Peters Church, St. Philip Neri Church, St. Pius X Church, St. Stephens Church, St. Theresa of the Child Jesus Church, St. Therese Chapel, St. Thomas the Apostle Church (Cherry Valley), St. Thomas the Apostle Church (Delmar), St. Vincent de Pauls Church (Albany), St. Vincent de Pauls Church (Cobleskill), Sts. Anthony & Joseph Church, The Catholic Community of Our Lady of Victory, The Catholic Community of Saint Cecilia, The Parish of Saint Joseph/Saint Michael/Our Lady of Mount Carmel, The Parish of St. John the Evangelist and St. Joseph, Transfiguration Parish, Vietnamese Apostolate, St. Teresa of Avila Church, St. Adalbert Church, Church of the Annunciation, St. Margaret Mary Church, Our Lady of Mercy Church, St. John the Baptist (Chestertown), Our Lady of Victory, St. Francis de Sales (Albany), St. Catherine of Siena Church, Church of St. Helen, Church of the Annunciation, St. Alphonsus Church, St. Agnes Church, St. Margaret Mary Church, Church of the Annunciation, Church of Our Lady of Angels, Church of St. Margaret Mary, St. Brigids Roman Catholic Church, St. Josephs Church (Rensselaer), St. Stanislaus Church against Certain Underwriters at Lloyds, London subscribing to policies issued to the Diocese of Albany, New York for periods effective from September 1, 1978 to September 1, 1991, Catalina Worthing Insurance, Hartford Accident & Indemnity Company, Hartford Fire Insurance Co., Interstate Fire & Casualty Company, The Catholic Mutual Relief Society of America, The National Catholic Risk Retention Group, Inc.. Fee Amount $ 350.. (Brennan, Francis) (Entered: 10/31/2023)Filed Oct 31, 2023Oct 31, 2023
- Dkt. 1Adversary case 23-90005-1. (72 (Injunctive relief - other)),(91 (Declaratory judgment)) Complaint by The Roman Catholic Diocese of Albany, New York against Sharon Winner, Shannon Webb, Jasmatie Tennassee, Dylan Custer, Deana Wasson, Barbara Dalmata, Raymond Dalmata, John Doe 1, John Doe 2, LG 68 Doe. Fee Amount of $350 is DEFERRED.. (Brennan, Francis) (Entered: 06/01/2023)Filed Jun 1, 2023Jun 1, 2023
- Dkt. 6First Day DeclarationFiled Mar 15, 2023Mar 15, 2023
- Dkt. 7First Day DeclarationFiled Mar 15, 2023Mar 15, 2023
- Dkt. 35Notice of Voluntary Dismissal Filed by The Roman Catholic Diocese of Albany, New York. (Brennan, Francis) (Entered: 07/07/2023)Filed Jul 7, 2023Jul 7, 2023
- Dkt. 833Order Granting Motion To Sell Property Free and Clear of Liens under Section 363(f) (Related Doc # 689) (Bazan, Judy) (Entered: 03/07/2024)Filed Mar 7, 2024Mar 7, 2024
- Dkt. 2914Ninth Interim Fee OrderFiled Nov 13, 2026Nov 13, 2026
- Dkt. 2915Blank Rome Interim AwardFiled Nov 13, 2026Nov 13, 2026
- Dkt. 2916BRG Ninth Interim CompensationFiled Nov 13, 2026Nov 13, 2026
- Dkt. 2917Burns Bair Fee OrderFiled Nov 13, 2026Nov 13, 2026
- Dkt. 2918Stinson Ninth Interim FeesFiled Nov 13, 2026Nov 13, 2026
- Dkt. 2919Interim Fee Application OrderFiled Nov 13, 2026Nov 13, 2026
- Dkt. 2923Seventh Interim Fee OrderFiled Nov 13, 2026Nov 13, 2026
- Dkt. 2925Committee Seeks Hearing DelayFiled Nov 16, 2026Nov 16, 2026
- Dkt. 2927October Fee StatementFiled Nov 16, 2026Nov 16, 2026
- Dkt. 2929October Fee StatementFiled Nov 16, 2026Nov 16, 2026