Expansion Denial, Gas Royalties, and Leachate Costs
The bankruptcy followed a series of operational and regulatory issues described in court filings.
Blocked expansion, 2016–2018. An adjacent rock quarry operated by Vulcan Materials was scheduled for conversion to roughly 30 million tons of additional airspace, and in February 2016 the Virginia DEQ issued a permit authorizing the use. Chesterfield County challenged the permit and blocked the expansion, and in July 2018 the county Board of Supervisors denied the land-use application for the conversion. Subsequent litigation against the county was unsuccessful. The First Day Declaration Dkt. 12 states that the denial forced the company to write off about 17 million tons of planned capacity. A 2004 Virginia Supreme Court case caselaw.findlaw.com: 2004 Virginia Supreme Court case (outside source, not verified by ElevenFlo) documented earlier disputes between the operator and the county.
Closure and lost revenue, December 2022. With expansion blocked and capacity exhausted, the landfill ceased accepting waste on December 30, 2022 Dkt. 12, ending the debtors' primary revenue stream while environmental obligations continued. The debtors downsized staff and retained consultants for the closure process, which—managed by related entity Shoosmith Construction—includes placing intermediate and final cover, repairing erosion damage, cleaning sediment basins, replacing storm piping, and installing slope down drains. Property transfers in 2024 reduced the landfill footprint from 506 to 335 acres and cut permitted design capacity from 75.89 million to 42.1 million cubic yards.
The Swift Creek Renewables gas contract. In April 2020, Shoosmith Bros. contracted with Morrow Energy, through subsidiary Swift Creek Renewables, LLC ("SCR"), to capture, treat, and sell landfill methane through pipeline networks; the gas qualifies for special treatment under federal policy for its cellulosic renewable value, as described in the First Day Declaration. To enable SCR's operations, Shoosmith purchased gas rights from Ingenco Dkt. 12 (now owned by Archaea Energy, a BP company) for $6.75 million, structured as sixty-four monthly payments of $126,682.20, with the first gas transfer on September 13, 2023.
Royalties below projection. The SCR transaction entitled Shoosmith to a 25% royalty on gas production, with projections exceeding $1.0 million per month. A contractual provision halved royalties until SCR recovered "Reimbursable Costs" estimated not to exceed $8.0 million. Actual results differed sharply, according to the CRO's declaration Dkt. 12:
| Metric | Projected | Actual |
|---|
| SCR Construction Costs | about $40 million | Higher |
| Reimbursable Costs Cap | $8 million | $42+ million |
| Monthly Royalty |
Because reimbursable costs reached more than $42 million Dkt. 12 against the $8 million cap, royalties stayed reduced far longer than anticipated, holding post-closure revenue below $50,000 per month.
Environmental violations, June 2024. On June 20, 2024, Shoosmith received a letter from the Virginia DEQ Dkt. 12 asserting violations of Air Pollution Control Law, including high-temperature wells, destruction of the synthetic closing cap's integrity, and leachate generation exceeding engineering estimates. Shoosmith contends that SCR caused these conditions through the manner in which it drilled the landfill liner during methane capture, allegations that remain disputed.
Leachate contract termination, July 2024. Effluent leachate—the contaminated liquid generated when precipitation percolates through decomposing waste—requires continuous removal and treatment. Until July 3, 2024, Shoosmith held a contract with Chesterfield County Dkt. 12 to treat leachate at the county's Publicly Owned Treatment Works for $0.02 per gallon, keeping monthly treatment costs between $30,000 and $50,000. According to the First Day Declaration, a former employee allegedly falsified the quantity and chemical analysis of the leachate delivered to the county, triggering suspension and termination of the contract. Forced to use private providers, the debtors now pay $0.22 per gallon ($0.15 treatment plus $0.07 transportation), an "eleven-time cost increase" the debtors called unsustainable given that they "now have relatively no income." The landfill generates about 400,000 gallons of leachate weekly, or roughly 20.8 million gallons annually, pushing annual treatment costs above $597,000 against a 2017 estimate of about $18,950 that county documents note chesterfield.gov: 400,000 gallons of leachate weekly (outside source, not verified by ElevenFlo) the company has not updated.