Court approves January mediation of Brayman Precast garage-collapse claims; plan solicitation hearing moves to Nov. 25
ElevenFlo ·
On November 13, 2026, the court approved a mediation protocol for claims arising from the Philadelphia parking-garage collapse, with mediation to begin by January 18, 2027 and end by January 22 Dkt. 332. Brayman’s motion to approve plan solicitation and confirmation procedures returns for a continued hearing on November 25, 2026, at 11:00 a.m., while the debtor negotiates an agreed order with objector High Concrete Group and Health Sciences Construction Group Dkt. 341.
Jump to section
The Subchapter V debtor makes precast concrete products in Saxonburg, Pennsylvania. It is operating on a $2.5 million debtor-in-possession loan from lenders that include its owner while it seeks approval to solicit votes on a plan.
On November 13, 2026, the court entered a revised order approving a mediation protocol for claims arising from the parking-garage collapse that led to the filing. The protocol provides for a global mediation of incident-related claims, defenses and rights, to begin no later than January 18, 2027 and conclude by January 22, 2027 Dkt. 332.
The court heard the debtor’s motion to approve plan solicitation and confirmation procedures on November 4, together with the mediation motion Dkt. 325. The solicitation hearing has since been continued by agreement to November 25, 2026, at 11:00 a.m. EST. In a November 18 status report, the debtor said it was still working with creditor High Concrete Group, LLC and Health Sciences Construction Group, Ltd. (HSC) on an agreed order that would resolve High Concrete’s objection and HSC’s response. If they settle, the debtor will submit the agreed order under a certification of counsel. If they do not, it will file a further status report before the hearing Dkt. 341.
The case is funded by a $2.5 million new-money term loan that the court approved on a final basis on August 27, 2026. The final order records $800,000 borrowed under the interim order and a further $1.7 million available once the final order was entered Dkt. 179 · p. 5. The order set two amended milestones: closing of an asset transfer by November 16, 2026 and, absent an asset transfer through a confirmed acceptable plan, confirmation of an acceptable plan by November 25, 2026 Dkt. 179. The continued solicitation hearing falls on the same day as that confirmation milestone.
Participating parties have paused incident litigation through January 22, 2027
The mediation order grants the debtor’s motion and requires participating parties to comply with the protocol. Participation is voluntary: a party may withdraw by written notice to the mediator and the other participants and by filing a notice with the court. Participants must attend with full settlement authority. Tort claimants may attend by telephone or video, but their counsel must attend in person. Confidential mediation memoranda are due to the mediator at least seven days before the mediation Dkt. 332.
The participating parties to the specified state-court action, bankruptcy claim-objection matters and adversary proceeding agreed not to advance or take formal action on those matters until they withdraw from mediation or until January 22, 2027, whichever comes first. Related deadlines and hearings are continued by stipulation and will be reset afterward by court order or agreement. Tort claimants may still take the steps needed to reissue their state-court writ of summons Dkt. 332.
The order limits what participation concedes. Taking part in mediation and the communications in it are not an admission, consent to bankruptcy-court jurisdiction over claims, or a waiver or release of claims, defenses, rights or insurance positions. Mediation does not stay or modify chapter 11 deadlines unless the court orders otherwise. Any settlement involving the debtor, its insurance rights or proceeds, coverage or estate property remains subject to applicable court approval Dkt. 332.
The debtor may pay its share of the mediator’s fees and expenses without a further order, but is not required to. Tort claimants bear their allocated share but need not pay before or as a condition of participating. Absent agreement, their share is due within 14 days after mediation concludes. Insurers have no cost-sharing obligation unless they separately agree to one Dkt. 332.
After the November 4 hearing, the debtor revised the proposed order and protocol to reflect changes discussed on the record. On November 6 it reported that it did not yet have sign-off from all parties Dkt. 316. Before the order was entered, High Concrete filed a reservation of rights. It supports mediation and intends to participate in good faith, but said it had neither reviewed nor approved the revised order and did not consent to it. It objected to two changes: removing global and individual settlement demands from mediation submissions, and permitting reissuance of the state-court writ. High Concrete said the order would place its estimation motion, claim objections and adversary proceeding in abeyance. It reserved its rights, including the right to seek relief from the abeyance period, but asked for no affirmative relief and did not seek to delay mediation Dkt. 329.
HSC wants plan solicitation to wait until mediation ends
The docket set October 22, 2026 as the deadline for the Subchapter V plan Dkt. 1. The debtor has since moved for approval of procedures to solicit votes on and confirm a plan, and the court heard that motion on November 4 Dkt. 325.
HSC asked the court to grant the solicitation-procedures motion with modifications. It supports mediation but argued that solicitation and confirmation litigation should not begin in earnest until mediation concludes, whether or not it produces a global settlement. HSC said its main concern is timing, not substance. Under the proposed procedures, solicitation packages and a confirmation notice could be due three business days after the procedures order is entered, which could put service within a week. Citing the number of parties and the complexity of the claims and counterclaims, HSC asked for longer mediation, solicitation and confirmation deadlines Dkt. 310.
High Concrete has also objected to the motion. The debtor’s negotiations aim to resolve both filings through a single agreed order before the November 25 hearing Dkt. 341.
HSC’s position affects the financing. The final financing order sets November 25, 2026 as the milestone for confirming an acceptable plan Dkt. 179. The mediation window, however, closes on January 22, 2027 Dkt. 332. If solicitation waits until mediation ends, confirmation would come after the milestone as written.
The $2.5 million facility is new money with no roll-up and a 12-month term
The final order authorizes borrowing and cash-collateral use to fund approved expenses. Loan proceeds may be used only as the loan documents permit and for budgeted expenses that cash collateral cannot cover, subject to permitted variances. The court found that Brayman lacked enough cash to fund its operations and could not obtain enough unsecured administrative credit Dkt. 179. The order describes the loans as new-money term loans of up to $2.5 million Dkt. 179 · p. 37. The debtor’s financing motion and the second Cohen declaration both state that the facility includes no roll-up Dkt. 16 Dkt. 168.
| Term | Final approved treatment |
|---|---|
| Maximum principal | $2.5 million |
| Borrowed under the interim order | $800,000 |
| Further availability on final approval | $1.7 million |
| Interest | U.S. prime rate plus 2% a year, payable in cash, in kind or a combination at the debtor’s option. The rate rises by 5 percentage points during a continuing event of default, after cure periods and written notice |
| Commitment fee | $25,000 (1% of commitments), earned on entry of the final order and payable under the approved budget |
| Exit fee | 2.5% of principal actually advanced and outstanding at payment in full, except repayment through an agent credit bid |
| Priority and collateral | Superpriority administrative claim and first-priority liens on DIP collateral, subject to the carve-out and permitted priority liens. Avoidance actions are excluded, but their proceeds are covered. Insurance proceeds are covered only for property loss or casualty to debtor assets |
| Carve-out after a trigger notice | Budgeted pre-notice professional fees, up to $250,000 of allowed post-notice professional fees (reduced by qualifying unused DIP proceeds), and specified statutory and clerk fees |
| Budget variance | 15% of cumulative operating disbursements, tested biweekly starting after the fourth week following closing |
| Remedies | After a default notice, the debtor, the Subchapter V trustee and the U.S. Trustee have 10 business days to seek court review. Suspending or terminating commitments requires at least 3 business days’ notice |
| Milestones | Closing of an asset transfer by November 16, 2026. Absent an asset transfer through a confirmed acceptable plan, confirmation of an acceptable plan by November 25, 2026 |
| Maturity | 12 months after the petition date, subject to written extension and earlier termination events |
Maturity is the earliest of three events: 12 months after the petition date (or a later date the debtor and required lenders agree in writing), dismissal or conversion to chapter 7, or the effective date of an acceptable plan. Acceleration and termination of commitments can also end the facility before that date Dkt. 179 · p. 75. Each borrowing is subject to conditions, including a borrowing notice, no default and materially accurate representations. Repaid loans cannot be reborrowed Dkt. 179.
The order waives surcharge of the collateral under section 506(c) unless the lenders agree in writing. It also waives marshaling, except as to avoidance proceeds, and applies section 552(b) waivers Dkt. 179. Cohen described the facility as funding efforts to preserve operations, maintain insurance, pursue insurance recoveries and seek agreement on a global restructuring Dkt. 168.
The debtor’s owner is a lender, and facility money cannot fund claims against the lenders
The final order names BPC-DIP Lending, LLC as agent. It lists BPC-DIP Lending, Brayman Construction Corporation, Brayman Holding Company, Inc. and Stephen M. Muck as lenders Dkt. 179. Cohen’s first-day declaration says Muck wholly owns the debtor. It also says Brayman approached three potential lenders and obtained no unsecured financing offer or better alternative Dkt. 19.
In his August 26 declaration, Cohen said that preparing the schedules identified payments to and from insiders during the year before bankruptcy. He reported that, after discussions with the debtor’s professionals, the lenders agreed to delete certain release provisions from the proposed final order Dkt. 168. As entered, the final order releases the agent and lenders from claims relating to the loan documents and the financing transactions, including specified lender-liability, equitable-subordination and challenge rights. Claims based on prepetition events are excluded from that release, except allegations concerning the DIP loan and its documents Dkt. 179.
The order bars using facility proceeds, the carve-out or the collateral to pursue claims against the lenders or their affiliates or to challenge the DIP obligations and liens. The one exception is seeking a determination that no event of default has occurred or is continuing. The lenders hold a lien on avoidance proceeds, and the order sets the order of recovery. They recover first from other DIP collateral, then from avoidance proceeds recovered from non-lender parties, and last from avoidance proceeds recovered from the lenders, the agent or their affiliates. The section 552(b) equities exception remains available for avoidance proceeds and for proceeds of claims against the lenders, their affiliates or the agent Dkt. 179.
The agent may credit bid the DIP obligations in a sale of collateral. That right is subject to section 363(k), the court’s power to limit or condition it for cause, and disclosure of affiliate or insider relationships Dkt. 179.
A fatal garage collapse cut into contract awards and cash
Brayman manufactures precast concrete products for transportation, marine, industrial, commercial and public-infrastructure projects. Its products include bridge deck panels, structural bridge components, stairs and box culverts. Cohen’s first-day declaration says the company leases its Saxonburg, Pennsylvania facility from a related entity, Victory Road, LLC. It puts historical gross revenue at approximately $12 million a year Dkt. 19.
According to Cohen, part of a parking garage under construction for the Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia collapsed on April 8, 2026, killing three construction workers. He described Brayman as one of several entities that provided services in connection with the incident. He said the incident was still under investigation when the declaration was filed Dkt. 19.
Cohen said Brayman then received correspondence threatening litigation, paid professionals to assist its internal investigation, and won fewer contracts amid media coverage. He said the resulting loss of liquidity and uncertainty over future business made an out-of-court solution unlikely Dkt. 19.
At filing, Cohen reported approximately $161,509 of cash. Against that, payroll for approximately 40 employees ran about $147,000 every two weeks, alongside vendor, subcontractor, insurance and other operating obligations. He reported approximately $373,124.74 in unsecured trade obligations as of the petition date Dkt. 19. The petition estimated both assets and liabilities at $1,000,001 to $10 million Dkt. 1.
Debtor counsel has requested $434,102.50 in fees through September
Raines Feldman Littrell LLP, the debtor’s counsel, filed its first interim fee application on November 13. It seeks $434,102.50 in fees and $1,806.28 in expenses for July 24 through September 30, 2026. After crediting $347,300.62 already received under the interim compensation procedures, it asks the debtor to pay $86,801.88. The application’s conclusion and proposed order state allowed compensation of $434,125.78, which differs from the $434,102.50 in its summary and schedules Dkt. 333.
For October, the firm’s monthly statement seeks $276,790.00 in fees, described as 80% of the month’s total, plus $4,548.88 in expenses Dkt. 327. The financing order caps allowed professional fees incurred after a carve-out trigger notice at $250,000 Dkt. 179.
On November 10, the debtor moved to modify the firm’s retention so it can engage subject-matter consultants. The debtor said such consultants may be needed to resolve incident-related claims and for plan purposes. The firm would seek reimbursement of their costs through its own expense applications. The debtor also asked to keep the consultants’ identities and engagement subject matter confidential until appropriate or until the court orders otherwise Dkt. 322.
Sources
- Dkt. 1Brayman Precast PetitionFiled Jul 24, 2026Jul 24, 2026
- Dkt. 16DIP Financing MotionFiled Jul 24, 2026Jul 24, 2026
- Dkt. 19Cohen First-Day DeclarationFiled Jul 24, 2026Jul 24, 2026
- Dkt. 168Cohen DIP Financing DeclarationFiled Aug 26, 2026Aug 26, 2026
- Dkt. 179Final DIP Financing OrderFiled Aug 27, 2026Aug 27, 2026
- Dkt. 310HSC Response on TimelinesFiled Nov 4, 2026Nov 4, 2026
- Dkt. 316Proposed Order StatusFiled Nov 6, 2026Nov 6, 2026
- Dkt. 322Consultant Retention ModificationFiled Nov 10, 2026Nov 10, 2026
- Dkt. 325Transcript Filing NoticeFiled Nov 10, 2026Nov 10, 2026
- Dkt. 327October Fee StatementFiled Nov 11, 2026Nov 11, 2026
- Dkt. 329High Concrete Reservation of RightsFiled Nov 11, 2026Nov 11, 2026
- Dkt. 332Mediation Protocol ApprovedFiled Nov 13, 2026Nov 13, 2026
- Dkt. 333Interim Fee ApplicationFiled Nov 13, 2026Nov 13, 2026
- Dkt. 341Plan Solicitation StatusFiled Nov 18, 2026Nov 18, 2026