PREPA bondholders and Oversight Board argue summary judgment Nov. 18 as $8.26 billion of revenue bonds remain unresolved
ElevenFlo ·
PREPA has no confirmed plan nine years into Title III; the Oversight Board's fifth amended plan would pay non-settling bondholders only the value of their collateral, after the First Circuit held the $8.26 billion of revenue bonds non-recourse Dkt. 5582. Next is the November 18, 2026 omnibus hearing, where the fuel line lenders intend to be heard on the Board's and bondholders' cross-motions for summary judgment Dkt. 6316.
Nine years after the July 2, 2017 petition, no plan has been confirmed. The Oversight Board's fifth amended plan would pay bondholders who do not settle only the value of their collateral.
The bondholder litigation is the next event in PREPA's Title III case. For the November 18, 2026 omnibus hearing, Assured Guaranty reserved the right to argue the PREPA bondholders' motion for summary judgment, the Oversight Board's motion for partial summary judgment concerning Counterclaim IV, and motions to exclude expert testimony from Julia Frayer, David Daly and David Plastino Dkt. 6317. The fuel line lenders intend to be heard on the Board's and bondholders' cross-motions for summary judgment concerning the accounting counterclaim, including issues raised in their earlier statements Dkt. 6316. U.S. Bank, as successor bond trustee, reserved the right to be heard on the bondholders' motion Dkt. 6321. National Public Finance Guarantee, GoldenTree Asset Management and Syncora Guarantee also filed notices reserving the right to be heard on matters affecting them Dkt. 6315Dkt. 6320.
The Board's plan proposal is the fifth amended plan, filed with its disclosure statement on March 28, 2025 Dkt. 5582. It would make distributions in cash and up to about $2.54 billion of new bonds, settle with the fuel line lenders at 84% of their allowed claims, and pay non-settling bondholders their pro rata share of the bond collateral value in cash after a valuation process. The disclosure statement left the voting deadline and the confirmation hearing date blank.
Two other deadlines are close. The court's November 9, 2026 show-cause order directed movants seeking relief from the automatic stay to explain by November 23 why their renewed motion should not be denied for lack of jurisdiction while their appeal of the earlier denial is pending; responses are due November 30 Dkt. 6303. Separately, the mediation team paused its financial advisor's services effective August 16, 2026, according to the advisor's November fee application Dkt. 6304.
PREPA entered Title III with about $9 billion of debt and years of operating deficits
PREPA is a government-owned public corporation of the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico, established in 1941 and the island's only electric utility. It serves about 1.5 million customer accounts with roughly 6,000 MW of generating capacity fueled mainly by oil, natural gas and coal. LUMA Energy operates the transmission and distribution system, and Genera PR operates the legacy generation plants.
A November 2023 supplemental disclosure statement attributes the debt to operating shortcomings and an inability to put through modest rate increases, which produced persistent deficits, legacy debt and pension obligations. By May 2017, it says, PREPA held about $9 billion in financial debt obligations, or $6,000 per customer Dkt. 4167 · p. 315. When the Board's members were appointed on August 31, 2016, PREPA had an estimated $11.4 billion of liabilities, including over $9 billion of funded debt Dkt. 3297 · p. 23.
On July 2, 2017, the Board issued a restructuring certification and filed PREPA's Title III petition Dkt. 3245 · p. 36. On October 6, 2017, the court directed joint administration of PREPA's case with the initial Title III cases . Bond insurers Assured Guaranty, National and Syncora and the Ad Hoc Group of PREPA Bondholders had already sued PREPA, the Board and the Puerto Rico Fiscal Agency and Financial Advisory Authority (AAFAF) on August 7, 2017 .
Revenue bonds are most of the debt, and the First Circuit held they are non-recourse
PREPA issued power revenue bonds between 1974 and 2016 under a January 1, 1974 trust agreement, with effective interest rates between 3.9% and 10% and maturities from 2017 to 2043 Dkt. 5582 · p. 78. U.S. Bank National Association is the successor trustee. The trustee's master proof of claim asserts $8,258,614,148 of principal and $217,903,197.39 of prepetition interest, or $8,476,517,345.39 in total, as of the petition date Dkt. 4171 · p. 165. The 2018 financing motion described the bonds as about $8.3 billion Dkt. 549.
The fuel line loans are the other identified funded debt. Under a May 4, 2012 credit agreement, Scotiabank and other lenders agreed to advance up to $500 million, later increased to $550 million; $549,950,000 was outstanding at the petition date, and Cortland Capital Market Services replaced Scotiabank as administrative agent effective May 17, 2019. Under a July 20, 2012 trade finance facility, Citibank agreed to advance up to $250 million, of which about $146,042,000 was outstanding Dkt. 3245 · p. 81. With interest accrued through July 2, 2017, the fuel line loans total $700,877,093.58 Dkt. 5582 · p. 949. In June 2020, the ad hoc group of fuel line lenders held about $537.5 million of advances under the fuel line credit agreement, 97.72% of those outstanding .
Identified debt across these three instruments is about $8.95 billion of petition-date principal. The disclosure statements put PREPA's debt at about $9 billion.
Revenue bonds account for $8.26 billion of the $8.95 billion in identified PREPA debtPrincipal outstanding at the July 2, 2017 petition date for the three instruments with stated balances; excludes accrued interest. The Citibank balance is approximate. Not a complete debt inventory.
Owed by PREPA
Power revenue bondsU.S. Bank (trustee)$8,258.61M
Scotiabank fuel line loanCortland (agent)$549.95M
Citibank fuel line loanCitibank (lender)$146.04M
Show the numbers
The Board and the bondholders disputed the reach of the bondholders' lien. On June 12, 2024, the First Circuit ruled that the bondholders' security interest under the trust agreement extends to PREPA's "Net Revenues" and was perfected by a financing statement, but that the bonds are non-recourse: they can be paid only from the collateral, and the bondholders have no unsecured claim against PREPA Dkt. 5582 · p. 78.
The fuel line lenders have pressed their own priority claim. Cortland, SOLA, Solus Opportunities Fund 5 and Ultra NB filed a declaratory judgment complaint against the Board, AAFAF, PREPA and U.S. Bank on July 9, 2019 Dkt. 1. The fifth amended plan's disclosure statement describes the fuel line lenders' litigation as asserting that their loans are "Current Expenses" payable ahead of the bonds .
The fifth amended plan would pay non-settling bondholders only their collateral value
The Board filed PREPA's first plan and disclosure statement on December 16, 2022 Dkt. 3111 and amended both several times in early 2023. On March 31, 2023, the court terminated pending motions tied to the termination of the PREPA restructuring support agreement and to a motion to dismiss PREPA's Title III case Dkt. 3364. A September 11, 2023 order on the third amended plan set a disclosure statement hearing for November 14–15, 2023, a pretrial conference for February 27, 2024 and a confirmation hearing beginning March 4, 2024 Dkt. 3950. The Board filed further modified versions, including a corrected fifth modified third amended plan on November 16, 2023 Dkt. 4171, and on February 29, 2024, AAFAF responded to the objecting bondholders' supplemental objection to confirmation Dkt. 4943.
After the First Circuit's ruling, the Board filed the fifth amended plan and its disclosure statement on March 28, 2025 Dkt. 5582. The plan's debt capacity is based on the 2025 PREPA fiscal plan, using a fixed amortization schedule that does not depend on electric load and about $2.6 billion of cash from non-PREPA sources to support a Rate Reduction Fund for restructured debt and pension obligations. Creditors would receive cash, funded by bond sales, and up to $2,536,362,339 of new bonds. Purchasers led by BlackRock committed under a forward delivery bond purchase agreement to buy $1,886,292,470 of Series B bonds to provide cash for distributions. The new bonds would be secured by PREPA's revenues, subject to PREPA's right to use revenues for operating expenses, and a missed payment would not be an event of default if Reorganized PREPA borrows from the Rate Reduction Fund.
The fifth amended plan would issue up to $2.54 billion of new PREPA bonds in three seriesProposed principal per the March 28, 2025 disclosure statement; the Series A amount is approximate. The bonds have not been issued.
Series A (fuel line lenders)8 years · 6.00%$650.07M
Series B-1 (tax-exempt)11 years · 6.00%$323.00M
Series B-2 (tax-exempt)35 years · 7.125%$1,563.29M
Total$2,536.36M
Show the numbers
The plan settles with the fuel line lenders and leaves non-settling bondholders to a valuation. The fuel line lenders would receive 84% of their allowed claims in cash and Series A bonds in exchange for supporting the plan and dismissing their Current Expense litigation. Bondholders who do not settle would receive their pro rata share of the bond collateral value in cash after a valuation process, so their projected recovery ranges from 0% to 100%. A general unsecured claims trust would receive $335 million in cash plus avoidance action proceeds; the disclosure statement estimates the unsecured pool at $800 million, down from $4.9 billion asserted, after about $2.4 billion of lost-profits claims by counterparties to power purchase and operating agreements was disallowed. Pension accrual would freeze at effectiveness and cost-of-living adjustments would end; frozen benefits would be paid on a pay-as-you-go basis funded by rates and the Rate Reduction Fund.
Fifth amended plan: proposed treatment by class, per the March 28, 2025 disclosure statement
Class
Claims
Estimated amount
Projected recovery
1
First settlement bondholders
$74,972,431
50.00%, in cash and Series B-1 bonds
2A, 2B
Classes 1 through 6 and 9 are impaired and entitled to vote. These are proposed terms; the disclosure statement did not fix a voting deadline or a confirmation hearing date.
PREPA's postpetition financing came as a $300 million unsecured Commonwealth loan
On January 27, 2018, the Board and AAFAF asked the court for interim and final orders authorizing secured postpetition financing for PREPA with priming liens and superpriority claims Dkt. 549. The court referred the motion to a magistrate judge for discovery Dkt. 705 and set a final hearing for February 15, 2018 Dkt. 658. On February 16, 2018, PREPA filed notice of a revised $300 million loan from the Commonwealth Dkt. 722. On February 19, 2018, the court authorized PREPA to borrow up to $300 million and gave the lender a superpriority administrative expense claim; the order grants no liens Dkt. 744 · p. 4.
Liquidity remained tight in 2025. The fifth amended plan's disclosure statement says that as of January 2025, PREPA needed an additional $381 million to meet transmission and distribution service account requirements and $343 million for generation service accounts Dkt. 5582.
LUMA sued in 2025 over how disputes under its grid operating contract are classified
LUMA Energy, LLC and LUMA Energy Servco, LLC sued PREPA and the Puerto Rico Public-Private Partnerships Authority (P3A) on August 25, 2025 Dkt. 1. The suit concerns six issues P3A raised in a July 22, 2025 notice of dispute under the June 22, 2020 transmission and distribution operation and maintenance agreement. They include federal funding reimbursements, with more than $550 million in potential reimbursements at issue, pole attachment fee collections, vegetation management after the April 16, 2025 island-wide blackout, and audit reporting. LUMA asks the court to compel mediation over whether the issues are "technical disputes," to bar the defendants from invoking the agreement's technical dispute process until that question is resolved, and to declare how the issues are classified. It alleges that the defendants are misclassifying the issues to avoid public and judicial scrutiny and to build a pretext for terminating the agreement.
Puerto Rico's Act 1-2025 also changed PREPA's operating constraints. It delayed the ban on coal-fired generation to December 31, 2032 and dropped the 40% renewable energy target for 2025 and the 60% target for 2040, while keeping the 100% target for 2050 Dkt. 5582.
Source: modified disclosure statement for the first amended plan Dkt. 3245 · p. 81
Dkt. 5582
Series
Term
Rate
Principal
Series A (fuel line lenders)
8 years
6.00%
$650.07M
Series B-1 (tax-exempt)
11 years
6.00%
$323.00M
Series B-2 (tax-exempt)
35 years
7.125%
$1,563.29M
Total
$2,536.36M
Source: fifth amended plan disclosure statement Dkt. 5582
PREPA revenue bonds (non-settling)
Not estimated
0.00% to 100.00%, depending on bond collateral value
3
Pension claims
$3.286 billion (present value)
90.00%, pay-as-you-go; benefits frozen
4
Fuel line loan claims
$700.9 million
84.00% to 88.31%, in cash and Series A bonds
5
General unsecured claims
$800 million
7.24% to 70.33%, from trust assets
6
Vitol settlement claim
$41,457,383
50% of the Class 5 recovery
7, 8, 10
Customer, eminent domain and convenience claims
Various
100.00%
Dkt. 722
Priority and security
Superpriority administrative expense claim; unsecured, with no collateral liens
Budget
13-week budgets approved by the lender and the Oversight Board; expenses obligated by FEMA are outside the variance test
Carve-out
Allowed unpaid fees and expenses of professionals for PREPA, the Board and the creditors' committee, and state matching requirements for federal grants and loans
Maturity
Earliest of repayment in full with termination of commitments, the effective date of a confirmed plan unless other treatment is agreed, or termination after an event of default