The Roman Catholic Bishop of Oakland (RCBO) filed chapter 11 on May 8, 2023 to resolve clergy abuse claims. The official committee of unsecured creditors, which represents abuse claimants, has its own plan on file that would require $195.2 million from RCBO. That plan is also unconfirmed Dkt. 2833.
The court's 109-page memorandum decision was entered October 2 and amended October 15. Among other things, it holds that the plan fails section 1129(a)(7), the best-interests test. That test requires every impaired creditor that does not accept a plan to receive at least what it would get in a chapter 7 liquidation. The court found the plan did meet section 1129(a)(10), which requires at least one impaired class to accept govinfo.gov: The Roman Catholic Bishop of Oakland (outside source). The East Bay Times reported that 97% of abuse claimants voted against the plan eastbaytimes.com: Judge denies request by Oakland Catholic diocese to green-light contentious payout to abuse victims (outside source). Any revised diocese plan will need a liquidation comparison that answers the court's findings, set out below.
The diocese and the committee are now negotiating through court-appointed mediators. On November 16 the court added retired Judge Daniel Buckley as a mediator over the objection of four insurers Dkt. 3629. The insurers had argued that a two-party mediation track would shut them out of plan talks that affect their coverage Dkt. 3623.
The diocese has also passed the end of its financing term. The final DIP order set maturity at the earliest of August 1, 2026, plan effectiveness or acceleration Dkt. 3165. That date has passed with no plan confirmed, and the filings do not show whether the loan was extended or repaid. The lender is the Roman Catholic Cemeteries of the Diocese of Oakland (RCC), the diocese's own cemetery corporation. RCC was also to provide the rejected plan's $55 million exit loan Dkt. 2758.
The court found material errors in the diocese's liquidation analyses
The best-interests test compares what a claimant would receive under the plan with what it would receive in a chapter 7 liquidation. The court found structural problems in the diocese's liquidation analyses. It held that the supplemental analysis left out at least one material asset and overstated the debt a liquidation would have to pay. It found the analyses' assumptions arbitrary and overbroad, including an accelerated timeline for property sales and the projected litigation and liquidation costs. It also held that the analyses wrongly counted the full $30 million contribution from the Roman Catholic Welfare Corporation of Oakland (RCWC) as if all Class 4 abuse claimants could share it equally govinfo.gov: The Roman Catholic Bishop of Oakland (outside source). Under the plan, that money sat in an escrow that pays only survivors who sign a release of RCWC Dkt. 2654.
The court also rejected the diocese's religious-liberty arguments. It held that the Bankruptcy Code and case law give no basis to treat the diocese differently from any other debtor because it is a religious entity. It held that the diocese had not explained how the confirmation requirements would infringe religious freedom. It also held that the First Amendment and the Religious Freedom Restoration Act either do not apply to confirmation issues or make it impossible to assess their effect on them govinfo.gov: The Roman Catholic Bishop of Oakland (outside source). The diocese's earlier disclosure statements had argued that the First Amendment's ministerial exception protects church-operated property from forced sale in a chapter 7 liquidation Dkt. 1831. The East Bay Times quoted the court as saying that being a church “doesn't make it a religious entity worthy of special protections, it makes it a debtor.” The paper reported that the judge suggested the diocese return to negotiations, and that Bishop Michael Barber called the ruling a setback eastbaytimes.com: Judge denies request by Oakland Catholic diocese to green-light contentious payout to abuse victims (outside source).
The rejected plan would have paid $150 million from RCBO over 3.5 years: $40 million at effectiveness, $6 million at the first anniversary, $5.9 million at the second and $98.1 million by the 3.5-year mark. Liens on specified real property would have secured the installments. RCWC would have contributed $30 million through the escrow Dkt. 2758. Settling insurers Continental Casualty Company (CNA), Certain Underwriters at Lloyd's and London Market Companies (LMI) and Westport Insurance Corporation would have paid a combined $44.3 million at effectiveness. Rights under all other insurers' policies would have passed to the survivors' trust Dkt. 2654. The $55 million RCC exit loan would have refinanced $15 million of DIP obligations and funded the initial contribution Dkt. 2758. To fund the rest, the diocese would have sold up to 12 houses of worship and vacant parcels. The Livermore property, owned by affiliate Adventus, was to be a primary source .
The committee plan asks $195.2 million from RCBO without new loans and has not been confirmed
The committee filed its first competing plan on March 6, 2026 Dkt. 2705 and its First Amended Plan on April 15 Dkt. 2833. RCBO would pay $195.2 million: $33.1 million at effectiveness, then $6 million, $28.9 million, $46.3 million and $80.9 million at set intervals Dkt. 2753. The last payment falls in September 2029. Deeds of trust on real property worth at least 125% of the obligation would secure the later payments Dkt. 2833. RCWC could contribute $118.9 million in exchange for releases: $70 million at effectiveness and $48.9 million later Dkt. 2753. RCWC has rejected that contribution, and RCWC and RCC have said they will not fund the committee plan Dkt. 2812.
The committee says its plan is feasible without new-money loans. RCBO's payments would come from real property sales, the merger or closure of about 30 parishes and any assets freed by the restricted-asset litigation Dkt. 2812. The diocese called the plan “patently unconfirmable.” It said the plan depended on a “forced loan” from a third party, a return to the bond market and restricted cash of RCBO and RCWC, and so could not meet the feasibility test of section 1129(a)(11) Dkt. 2707.
Each allowed abuse claimant would receive a $5,000 initial distribution. A $50,000 immediate payment option remains. Survivors who litigate against non-settling insurers could earn claim enhancements of 10% to 100%. The plan reserves $7.7 million for unknown claims, funded over two years, and sets a 10-year term for the compliance monitor. The committee estimates an average recovery of $492,800 per survivor Dkt. 2833. It says its plan gives abuse claimants $44.2 million more than the diocese plan, and that the diocese's tentative insurer settlements undervalue the insurers' exposure Dkt. 2753. The Mercury News reported that the committee wants to negotiate its own insurer settlements. It also reported that the compliance monitor's term is a separate sticking point: the committee wants at least 10 years and the diocese generally five mercurynews.com: Oakland diocese, abuse victims far apart in settlement talks (outside source).
The committee plan asks more of both RCBO and RCWCTotal proposed contributions over about 3.5 years, as stated in the diocese's March 27, 2026 plan, since denied confirmation, and the committee's April 2026 disclosure statements. The committee plan's RCWC amount applies only if RCWC elects to contribute, and RCWC has rejected it. No insurer settlement amount is shown for the committee plan.
Diocese plan (March 27, 2026)
Committee plan (April 15, 2026)
RCBO (diocese plan)$150.0M
RCWC escrow (diocese plan)$30.0M
Settling insurers (diocese plan)$44.3M
RCBO (committee plan)
The committee's disclosure statement set a June 4, 2026 voting deadline and a confirmation hearing beginning June 15, 2026 Dkt. 2833. No order confirming the committee plan has been entered.
Mediation resumed with a fourth mediator over insurer objections
On November 6, 2026, the diocese applied to appoint Buckley as an additional mediator, effective October 12. It said earlier mediation had not produced a consensual plan. The committee supported the request, but the insurers had not agreed when it was filed. Buckley would charge $2,000 an hour with no retainer, payable solely by the estate and not shared with insurers Dkt. 3615.
Four insurers objected: Insurance Company of North America, Pacific Employers Insurance Company, Pacific Indemnity Company and Westchester Fire Insurance Company. They argued that the two-party “Committee Mediator” track would exclude them from talks on plan terms that affect coverage. They also argued that Buckley could appear partial. The committee had chosen him as abuse claims reviewer under a proposed plan. He is also a fiduciary of an Archdiocese of Los Angeles trust whose claimants, the insurers say, include people with claims against RCBO. The insurers noted that three mediators were already available: Sontchi, Newsome and Gallagher Dkt. 3623. Buckley's declaration says he never served or was paid as reviewer under that unconfirmed plan Dkt. 3616. LMI asked that insurers help choose mediators and be included in future sessions aimed at a global settlement Dkt. 3626.
The court had called a November 16 status conference on the mediation Dkt. 3625. The same day it entered the appointment order. The order approves Buckley's employment under section 327, effective October 12. It leaves his compensation for later review under sections 330 and 331 and declines to approve terms under section 328(a) Dkt. 3629. Buckley and retired Judge Sontchi held mediation sessions on November 18–19. The diocese and the committee said that mediation is continuing Dkt. 3635.
Bellwether juries have returned verdicts of $16 million and $14.3 million
The Mercury News reported that the bankruptcy court allowed six abuse suits to proceed to trial as test cases while settlement talks lagged mercurynews.com: Oakland diocese, abuse victims far apart in settlement talks (outside source). On April 22, 2026, an Alameda County jury returned a $16 million verdict against the diocese: $12 million in past and $4 million in future non-economic damages. The plaintiff was a former Union City altar boy who said former priest Stephen Kiesle abused him in 1975. Bishop Barber said awards of that size “underscore the necessity of the bankruptcy process and a confirmed plan that pays all survivors fairly and equitably, not just those fortunate enough to be first in line for a trial” mercurynews.com: Verdict reached in bellwether sex abuse lawsuit against Oakland Diocese (outside source).
RCC, the diocese's cemetery corporation, is its prepetition, DIP and proposed exit lender
On December 27, 2022, RCC and RCBO entered into a credit agreement for a secured loan of up to $26 million Dkt. 2885 · p. 12. At the petition date, RCBO owed $25,795,655 in principal and accrued interest under that loan. Deeds of trust on six properties secure it Dkt. 3165 · p. 5. The rejected plan would have reinstated the loan, leaving it unimpaired and waiving default interest. Principal that came due before effectiveness and remained unpaid would have been amortized over the loan's remaining term Dkt. 2758 · p. 36.
For three years the case ran without postpetition financing, on operating revenue and sales of residential property. In December 2025 the court approved the sale of 1834 San Antonio Avenue in Alameda for $1,860,000, with proceeds directed to professional fees Dkt. 2534. On February 6, 2026, it approved the free-and-clear sale of 1822 San Antonio Avenue for $1,170,000 Dkt. 2617. By July 2025 the diocese held $1.9 million in unrestricted cash against an estimated $8.7 million in outstanding professional fees chapter11cases.com: Oakland Diocese Seeks to Dismiss Own Bankruptcy After $29 Million in Losses, Failed Settlement Talks (outside source). In February 2026 the court denied its motion to defer professional fee payments Dkt. 2707.
On May 5, 2026, RCBO moved for DIP financing. It reported about $63,000 in available cash and about $3.66 million in professional fees due in May. It said it needed funding through effectiveness, then projected for July 31, 2026 Dkt. 2885. The court authorized $5.0 million on an interim basis on May 13 Dkt. 2936. After negotiations, the committee consented to the final order Dkt. 3036, which the court entered on June 9 Dkt. 3165. The facility does not roll up the prepetition RCC loan . DIP proceeds cannot be used to challenge RCC's liens or prepetition claims . In an October 30, 2026 fee application, the claims agent said the diocese was reviewing its cash position to decide whether and when it could pay the amounts requested .
The committee values RCBO's real estate at over $500 million; the diocese says much of its property is restricted
RCBO reported $76.1 million in total assets in its November 30, 2025 monthly operating report Dkt. 2530. The diocese treats much of its cash and real estate as restricted for charitable purposes under California law and excludes it from creditor recoveries Dkt. 1874. The committee says RCBO holds more than 250 properties Dkt. 2812 and values its real estate at over $500 million Dkt. 2833. The Catholic Cathedral Corporation of the East Bay owes RCBO a $41.8 million note. The plans would satisfy it by transferring the Cathedral Center to RCBO Dkt. 1831.
The committee earlier filed adversary proceedings seeking substantive consolidation of RCBO with its parishes and affiliates Dkt. 1595. In Adv. Pro. 24-04051 it seeks a ruling that $33.3 million of assets are unrestricted and available to creditors Dkt. 2833. An appeal to the district court, filed in August 2025, concerns a ruling on restricted-asset and governance rights Dkt. 2202. RCBO's schedules listed the Oakland Parochial Fund as holding a claim on a $35 million loan. RCBO's current chief financial officer later declared that the funds were RCBO's own, and the fund withdrew the claim by stipulation .
Survivors rejected the $143.5 million Third Amended Plan by 99% before the court conditionally dismissed the case
The diocese filed its original plan in November 2024 Dkt. 1445. The January 2025 amended plan offered at least $117.25 million in cash from RCBO and RCWC, plus the 122.5-acre Livermore property Dkt. 1595. The Third Amended Plan of March 2025 raised the cash to $143.5 million and removed the Livermore property from the trust's assets Dkt. 1831. The voting declaration filed June 6, 2025 showed a 99% rejection rate Dkt. 2040.
On September 9, 2025, the diocese moved to dismiss its own case. It cited professional fees above $3 million a month and the failure to reach a settlement Dkt. 2293. On November 25, 2025, the court granted dismissal without prejudice and found no evidence of bad faith. The dismissal was to take effect unless the diocese filed a signed settlement term sheet by November 26 Dkt. 2467. The case was not dismissed. A non-binding term sheet filed December 11, 2025 outlined a settlement of about $242 million among RCBO, RCWC and settling insurers Dkt. 2505. The parties were at an impasse on the funding timeline by February 17, 2026, and each side then filed its own plan .
The cash RCBO and RCWC would put into the survivors' trust rose from $117.25 million to $180 million across four diocese plansCombined cash contributions from RCBO and RCWC as stated for each plan; RCWC's share is conditioned on survivor releases in each version. The Modified Fourth Amended Plan of March 27, 2026 kept the $180 million. Excludes insurer settlements, the Livermore property and assigned insurance rights.
$117.25M
$117.25M
$143.5M
$180.0M
Amended Plan
Second Amended Plan
Third Amended Plan
Fourth Amended Plan
Show the numbers
Professional fees passed $44.6 million by November 2025
Cumulative professional fees exceeded $44.6 million through November 2025, with monthly fees regularly above $3 million Dkt. 2657.
Debtor counsel and committee counsel account for the largest cumulative feesCumulative fees through November 2025 for eight estate professionals, as reported with the eighth interim fee applications. Excludes later periods.
Debtor professionals
Committee professionals
Foley & Lardner LLPDebtor counsel$14,795,444
Lowenstein Sandler LLPCommittee lead counsel$11,024,329
The applications for May through August 2026 go to hearing on December 2 Dkt. 3608. Ordinary-course professionals are paid outside that process. The diocese reports paying Dr. Kemner $2,049,913.71 from the petition date through September 30, 2026 Dkt. 3612.
Interim fee requests for May through August 2026, set for hearing December 2, 2026
Professional
Requested
Lowenstein Sandler LLP
$6,866,956.00
Foley & Lardner LLP
$4,863,424.90
Berkeley Research Group
$737,033.65
AB 218 revived the abuse claims that drove the filing
RCBO is a California corporation sole established in 1962. It administers the civil affairs of the Catholic diocese covering Alameda and Contra Costa counties, with about 550,000 resident Catholics and 82 parishes and missions. It operates alongside separately incorporated non-debtor affiliates. RCWC oversees 32 elementary schools and two high schools, and RCC operates six cemeteries, five mortuaries and two mausoleums Dkt. 19.
After California's 2002 law temporarily reviving expired abuse claims, the diocese paid about $56 million to settle the claims of 52 plaintiffs. Assembly Bill 218, signed on October 13, 2019, opened a second window for previously time-barred childhood sexual abuse claims through December 31, 2022. By the petition date, about 332 lawsuits and mediation demands were pending against RCBO Dkt. 19. After the bar date, 386 unique, non-duplicative abuse claims were filed Dkt. 1874. RCBO believes about 345 of them may ultimately be entitled to distributions from the survivors' trust Dkt. 2654.
10% unfavorable variance allowance on operating disbursements, tested monthly; variance reports due by the 15th of each month
Carve-out
Court and U.S. Trustee fees, up to $25,000 for a chapter 7 trustee, budgeted allowed professional fees incurred before a termination declaration, and $50,000 after a trigger notice
Lender protections
Waivers of the section 506(c) surcharge, the section 552(b) equities exception and marshaling; right to credit bid the DIP obligations in a sale of DIP collateral Dkt. 3165
Dkt. 1846 · p. 7
Dkt. 2707
Plan
Filed
RCBO and RCWC cash
Amended Plan
January 2025
$117.25M
Second Amended Plan
February 2025
$117.25M
Third Amended Plan
March 2025
$143.5M
Fourth Amended Plan
February 2026
$180.0M
Sources: amended disclosure statement Dkt. 1595; second amended disclosure statement Dkt. 1763; third amended disclosure statement Dkt. 1874; committee disclosure statement comparison of the diocese plan Dkt. 2753
Committee lead counsel
$11,024,329
Alvarez & Marsal
Debtor restructuring advisor
$5,067,311
Berkeley Research Group
Committee financial advisor
$3,329,801
Burns Bair LLP
Committee special insurance counsel
$2,008,764
VeraCruz Advisory
Debtor consultant
$1,735,750
Dr. Matthew J. Kemner
Expert
$1,308,940
Kurtzman Carson Consultants
Claims agent
$1,236,309
Covington & Burling
$409,362.36
National Economic Research Associates
$343,286.70
Alvarez & Marsal
$261,163.69
Stout Risius Ross (valuation)
$173,214.40
Stout Risius Ross (real estate)
$102,617.33
Fee examiner David M. Klauder and Bielli & Klauder