Westfield asks Delaware court to defer Water Gremlin trust's $77 million coverage fight to Minnesota - ElevenFlo
Westfield asks Delaware court to defer Water Gremlin trust's $77 million coverage fight to Minnesota
ElevenFlo ·
On November 18, 2026, Westfield Insurance asked the court to abstain from or stay the liquidating trustee's objection to its Claim No. 61 because its own coverage action is pending, though stayed, in Minnesota. Failing that, it asked the court to allow the claim Dkt. 951. Westfield has also moved to dismiss, or have the court abstain from, the trustee's suit seeking at least $77 million Dkt. 936. A related sealing motion is set for the January 7, 2027 omnibus hearing .
Westfield Insurance wants a coverage action it filed in Minnesota in 2023 to decide whether its policies cover the TCE and lead claims. That action has been stayed since the bankruptcy. The liquidating trustee chose the bankruptcy court instead, filing a damages suit and an objection to Westfield's claim there on the same day.
On November 18, 2026, Westfield Insurance Company responded to the objection that Edward T. Gavin, trustee of the WG GUC Liquidating Trust, filed against its Claim No. 61. Westfield's first request is that the court abstain from or stay the objection. It argues that the coverage question is already pending in its prepetition Minnesota action. It also argues that its settlement agreement with Water Gremlin selects Minnesota law and an exclusive Minnesota federal forum. As a fallback, Westfield asks for a stay until the court decides its motion to dismiss the trustee's adversary proceeding. If the Minnesota action is allowed to proceed, it wants the stay to last until that action reaches final judgment. If the court reaches the merits, Westfield asks it to overrule the objection and allow the claim, payable once a no-coverage determination is final and non-appealable Dkt. 951.
On November 19, Westfield moved to seal settlement materials that support both its response and its motion to dismiss or abstain. Objections are due December 18, 2026 at 4:00 p.m. ET. The motion is set for the January 7, 2027 omnibus hearing at 11:00 a.m. ET Dkt. 958. The court had set the claim objection for a scheduling conference at its November 5, 2026 omnibus hearing Dkt. 942. With the court's permission, that hearing moved to January 7 Dkt. 950.
The Westfield dispute is the main contested matter left in a case whose sale and plan phases are complete. Water Gremlin Company, WG Sub, LLC and Water Gremlin Holdings, Inc. filed chapter 11 in Delaware on October 27, 2023 Dkt. 1. Tort claims over historical trichloroethylene emissions from the company's plant in White Bear Township, Minnesota, drove the filing, not lender pressure. The debtors sold the U.S. operations and the Italian subsidiary in the first four months of the case. They then negotiated a global settlement with their parent, Okabe Co., Ltd. The court confirmed the resulting joint plan of liquidation on August 1, 2025 Dkt. 814, and the plan took effect on October 28, 2025 Dkt. 859. A December 4, 2025 final decree closed the two affiliate cases Dkt. 883. Post-effective matters continue in the lead case, No. 23-11775.
Westfield says pollution exclusions defeat coverage in every policy year
Claim No. 61 seeks reimbursement of a settlement payment Westfield made on the Curry lead-exposure claim. Westfield calls the claim a general unsecured reimbursement obligation under its settlement agreement with Water Gremlin. Under its reading, the obligation depends on a final determination that the policies give no coverage. The response redacts the amount. Westfield says Water Gremlin agreed not to contest the amount and that Westfield paid it in full Dkt. 951.
On the merits, Westfield says the trustee's coverage theory rests on the lack of a separate lead exclusion in two policy years. Pollution exclusions, it says, appear in every relevant year. It argues that Minnesota law treats lead as a pollutant, so lead allegedly carried home from the plant falls within those exclusions. If the court reaches the merits, Westfield asks it to decide the pollution-exclusion question as a matter of law before discovery or an evidentiary hearing Dkt. 951. These are Westfield's positions in a response the court has not yet heard.
A declaration by Howard A. Cohen supports the response. It was filed in a redacted public version and a sealed version Dkt. 954Dkt. 953. The November 19 motion asks to seal the Westfield and Curry settlement agreements, including an addendum. It also asks to redact two exhibits and parts of the response and of the opening brief on the motion to dismiss or abstain. Westfield cites confidential settlement terms and personal identifying and health information. Access would be limited to the court, the U.S. Trustee, the liquidating trustee and its counsel, and others the court authorizes. Westfield says it is conferring with the trustee's counsel on the scope Dkt. 958.
The trustee seeks at least $77 million and full disallowance of Claim No. 61
Westfield's coverage fight with Water Gremlin predates the bankruptcy. Westfield filed a declaratory judgment action in the District of Minnesota in mid-2023. That action was stayed when Water Gremlin filed its suggestion of bankruptcy in October law360.com: Westfield Insurance Company v. Water Gremlin Company - Law360 (outside source). Westfield's response says it remains stayed Dkt. 951. The plan did not settle the dispute. Rights under the Westfield policies went to the liquidating trust, which was to prosecute the coverage actions and defend against Westfield's indemnification claims. Other insurance rights went to the settlement trust. Westfield's own claims were placed in Class 4d, with a projected recovery of 0% to 55% and treatment as Class 4a general unsecured claims if allowed Dkt. 763.
On August 31, 2026, the trustee sued Westfield in adversary proceeding 26-50649. The complaint alleges that Westfield breached its duty to defend Water Gremlin in the TCE lawsuits. It asks for a declaration that the Westfield policies cover those suits. It alleges at least $77 million of lost going-concern value, $54 million at Water Gremlin and $23 million at Holdings. It seeks no less than that amount, plus attorneys' fees and costs. It also alleges that the Westfield settlement agreement requires reimbursement of reasonable fees and costs if the policies are found to cover the Curry Claim Dkt. 936. These are the trustee's allegations.
The same day, the trustee objected to Claim No. 61, in which Westfield asserts a general unsecured claim of undetermined amount. The objection disputes Westfield's right to reimbursement for the Curry settlement. It alleges that the policies for the relevant period had no lead-liability exclusion, unlike the policies for the years immediately before and after. It asks the court to disallow the claim in full and bar Westfield from any distribution from the liquidating trust. It also asks the court to align the objection's deadlines, discovery and hearing with the adversary proceeding Dkt. 937. Westfield's request to send the coverage question to Minnesota would separate the two matters again.
Both creditor groups have a stake in the result. An allowed Westfield claim would share in the liquidating trust's pool for general unsecured creditors. No claim in that pool has yet been allowed or paid Dkt. 949. Westfield asks that any allowed amount be paid only after a no-coverage ruling is final and non-appealable Dkt. 951. Recoveries from Westfield may not stay with unsecured creditors. As first filed, the plan sent proceeds of TCE-related insurance claims under the Westfield assignment to the settlement trust Dkt. 683.
The settlement trust has paid $18.9 million; general unsecured claims remain unpaid
The WG TCE Tort Claims Settlement Trust filed its report for the quarter ended June 30, 2026 on October 29, 2026. It shows $3,076,344 disbursed in the quarter and $19,056,183 since the effective date. Of that, $18,913,886 has been paid on $27,250,000 of allowed claims. The trust expects to apply for a final decree by December 31, 2027 Dkt. 948. The allowed amount matches the $27.25 million settlement of the TCE lawsuits that TwinCities.com reported on February 13, 2026. The plaintiffs' lead attorney, Dean Salita, told the outlet that the settlement is funded partly by sale proceeds held in trust and partly by Okabe twincities.com: $27.25 million settlement reached in case involving defunct Water Gremlin (outside source).
The WG GUC Liquidating Trust reported no disbursements in the quarter ended September 30, 2026. It reported $1,998,778 in total transfers since the effective date. It has paid administrative, secured and priority claims in full. It lists $2.7 million of anticipated payments on general unsecured claims but has allowed or paid nothing in that category Dkt. 949. The prior quarter's report shows $179,802 disbursed in the three months to June 30, 2026 Dkt. 938.
Tort claimants have received most of the money paid since effectiveness; general unsecured creditors have received nothing yet. Cumulative payments since the October 28, 2025 effective date: settlement trust through June 30, 2026; liquidating trust through September 30, 2026.
Trust and claims
Paid since effectiveness
Reported against
Settlement trust: TCE tort claims
$18,913,886
$27,250,000 allowed
Liquidating trust: administrative claims
Claims work continues. On February 27, 2026, the trustee moved to extend the claim objection deadline through June 1, 2026, citing ongoing claim-resolution talks Dkt. 916. Argo Partners has filed transfer notices for two trade claims. The first, filed August 10, 2026, covers Loffler Companies' Claim No. 48 for $3,009.35 Dkt. 934. The second, filed September 29, 2026, covers East Penn Manufacturing's Claim No. 49 for $52,920 Dkt. 945.
The December 4, 2025 final decree closed the cases of WG Sub, LLC (No. 23-11774) and Water Gremlin Holdings, Inc. (No. 23-11776). It preserved the liquidating trust's right to dispute claims filed in those cases Dkt. 883. Final post-confirmation reports for both cases, covering the quarter ended December 31, 2025, show no transfers Dkt. 939Dkt. 940.
An Okabe-funded global settlement became a liquidating plan with two trusts
In the second year of the case, the focus shifted from asset sales to a global settlement among the debtors, the official committee of unsecured creditors and Okabe Dkt. 750. On November 27, 2024, Okabe announced an agreement in principle reached in mediation with the committee, Water Gremlin and Holdings. In exchange for releases from unsecured creditors, including the tort plaintiffs, Okabe would contribute $14.4 million, about 2.2 billion yen, to Water Gremlin's estate daiwair.co.jp: td_download.cgi (outside source). Nasdaq reported Okabe's announcement of the settlement agreement on December 3, 2024 nasdaq.com: Okabe Co., Ltd. Announces U.S. Lawsuit Settlement Agreement (outside source). Okabe recorded an extraordinary loss of approximately 5.5 billion yen for the settlement and the writedown of its investment in the U.S. subsidiaries daiwair.co.jp: 5.5 billion yen (outside source).
The debtors filed the combined plan and disclosure statement on April 1, 2025 Dkt. 683 and amended it on May 30, 2025. Two cash payments fund the settlement trust: $14.4 million from Okabe and a $13.5 million WG Holdings contribution from the estates. A further $2.5 million of GUC consideration goes to the liquidating trust. A $1 million holdback is kept for two years to support indemnification of released parties. Okabe kept the right to end its funding if the confirmation order was changed in a way it did not accept before the order became final Dkt. 750. Okabe waived its own claims in exchange for releases and a plan sale of specified assets, including certain causes of action and releases. TCE tort and lead claims are channeled to the settlement trust Dkt. 763. That trust pays claims under a point value system as a qualified settlement fund under section 468B of the tax code. Claimants must sign a release to receive a distribution .
Okabe cash and an estate contribution fund the tort settlement trust; unsecured creditors receive a separate $2.5 millionCash contributions under the solicitation version of the combined plan, filed June 6, 2025. Excludes insurance rights, preserved estate claims and the plan sale.
Settlement trust
Liquidating trust
Okabe contributionSettlement trust$14.4M
WG Holdings contributionSettlement trust$13.5M
GUC considerationLiquidating trust$2.5M
Show the numbers
The solicitation version, filed June 6, 2025, set July 9, 2025 as the voting and objection deadline and July 29, 2025 for the confirmation hearing Dkt. 763. On August 1, 2025, the court entered an order that approved the disclosure statement on a final basis and confirmed the plan Dkt. 814. The plan has ten classes of claims and interests. Classes 1 and 2 are unimpaired, and Classes 3 and 4a through 4d voted. The order found that each holder would receive at least as much as in a hypothetical chapter 7 liquidation.
Plan classes and projected recoveries in the solicitation version Dkt. 763
Class
Claims
Status
Projected recovery
1
Priority claims
The confirmation order authorized a liquidating trust and a separate settlement trust. It directed the debtors to transfer each trust's assets on the effective date. It approved Edward T. Gavin as liquidating trustee, with authority to investigate, prosecute and resolve preserved estate claims. The order approved debtor releases, TCE tort claimant releases, third-party releases by releasing parties, and exculpation. It noted that the solicitation package set out the release disclosures in bold, conspicuous form. It also approved the plan sale to Okabe as part of the global settlement, finding that no other bidders came forward for those assets and that the sale was fair and reasonable Dkt. 814. The debtors' October 29, 2025 notice reported that the plan took effect on October 28, 2025, once the conditions in Article XIII were satisfied or waived. The notice set December 12, 2025 as the deadline for final fee applications Dkt. 859.
TCE tort claims, not lender pressure, put the company in chapter 11
Water Gremlin was founded in 1949 in White Bear Township, Minnesota, and Okabe acquired it in 2005. The company grew from lead fishing sinkers into battery terminals for automotive, e-vehicle, industrial and military customers. It used roughly 160,000 square feet of Minnesota manufacturing and warehousing space. The first-day declaration says the debtors used trichloroethylene, or TCE, as a degreasing solvent through 2018. It also describes the company's later self-disclosure to the Minnesota Pollution Control Agency, a $4.5 million civil penalty and roughly $1.5 million of supplemental environmental projects Dkt. 11.
The only identified funded debt is an unsecured Mizuho line with about $21.6 million outstanding, guaranteed by Okabe
The first-day declaration says the debtors had no major prepetition secured creditors Dkt. 11 · p. 3. Their identified funded debt was an unsecured line of credit with Mizuho Bank, Ltd. for up to $25 million of aggregate principal. Approximately $21.6 million, plus interest and fees, was outstanding on the petition date Dkt. 11 · p. 4. The disclosure statement describes the line as essentially a letter of credit that worked like a series of weekly term loans. Each week's draw repaid the prior week's balance and covered operating needs. Okabe guaranteed Water Gremlin's obligations under the line Dkt. 763 · p. 31. The debtors could no longer draw on the line when they filed Dkt. 13 · p. 31. Identified funded debt is therefore at least approximately $21.6 million. The filings do not state a total for all funded debt.
Beyond Mizuho, the debtors owed trade liabilities and environmental remediation obligations and faced the contingent tort exposure. Holdings, an Illinois corporation wholly owned by Okabe, was the holding company for Water Gremlin and the Italian subsidiary Aquila Dkt. 683 · p. 30. Okabe is a publicly traded Japanese industrial group. Its October 2023 financial release attributed the chapter 11 filings to a sharp drop in profitability in the U.S. battery-terminal business assets.minkabu.jp: October 2023 financial release (outside source). On the petition date, the debtors employed about 178 full-time and 14 temporary workers in Minnesota Dkt. 11.
SG Credit's $10 million DIP tied the case to a 150-day sale timeline
To fund the case until a sale, the debtors sought a superpriority facility of up to $10 million from SG Credit Partners. The motion asked for $7 million at the outset and a $3 million incremental tranche subject to further conditions. A borrowing base tied to eligible accounts and inventory governed availability. Proceeds were budgeted for ordinary-course working capital and chapter 11 administrative costs Dkt. 13. The November 1, 2023 interim order allowed borrowing of up to $3 million, the debtors' cash needs for the interim period under the approved budget Dkt. 42 · p. 8. The November 18, 2023 final order authorized borrowing of up to $10 million Dkt. 111 · p. 7.
The lender received liens under sections 364(c)(2) and 364(c)(3) and a section 364(c)(1) superpriority administrative claim, subordinate only to the carve-out Dkt. 13. Under the final order, the liens reach avoidance actions and their proceeds. For claims against insiders or affiliates, however, the lender has a lien only on proceeds. It can collect those proceeds only after all other DIP collateral has been liquidated or disposed of. The order also waives section 506(c) surcharge and marshaling Dkt. 111. Maturity came at the earliest of three dates: a sale closing; a maturity date the lender could elect on or after the termination date; or 150 days after the petition date, extendable to 180 days with the lender's consent . Events of default included payment defaults, covenant breaches and material misstatements. They also included appointment of a trustee, conversion to chapter 7 and pursuit of a plan the lender had not approved. These terms tied the DIP to the sale schedule rather than a longer reorganization . On January 12, 2024, the court approved an amendment to the DIP loan documents. It removed certain conditions on further financing for continued operations and carried an amendment fee .
Accuma bought the Italian subsidiary and Otter Lake the U.S. business; the tort liabilities stayed in the estate
The debtors retained Intrepid Investment Bankers before filing. According to the first-day declaration, Intrepid contacted approximately 140 potential strategic and financial buyers and obtained five indicative valuation ranges Dkt. 11. The court approved bidding procedures on November 20, 2023 Dkt. 115. The first auction was for the Italian subsidiary, Water Gremlin Aquila Company S.p.A. In November 2023, the debtors designated Accuma Corporation as stalking horse bidder for Aquila. Its bid carried aggregate consideration of $18,929,014, supported by a 10% deposit of $1,892,901 Dkt. 152. Bid protections included a $567,870.43 breakup fee and up to $378,580.29 of documented expense reimbursement, together capped at 5% of the purchase price. The bid had no financing, internal-approval or diligence condition.
After the December 18, 2023 auction, the debtors named Accuma the successful bidder and filed the executed equity purchase agreement. It set a $9 million base equity price plus post-closing consideration equal to 95% of final inventory and receivables. The price was subject to adjustment for closing cash, indebtedness and retained liabilities. The transferred property included all issued and outstanding equity of WG Italy and certain related patent assignments Dkt. 191.
The U.S. operations were sold separately. On February 15, 2024, the court entered an order approving a February 9, 2024 purchase agreement for specified Water Gremlin assets in the United States Dkt. 283. The buyer, Otter Lake Technologies, is a Minnesota company. It said publicly that it planned to keep running the lead battery terminal and metal components business at the White Bear Township site presspubs.com: Local company acquires Water Gremlin assets - presspubs.com (outside source). Press coverage reported that the Otter Lake sale did not include the TCE tort liabilities, which stayed in the bankruptcy estate cbsnews.com. Law360 reported approximately $24.1 million in aggregate consideration across the court-approved U.S. and Italian sales . Intrepid later reported that the cross-border sale closed in early 2024 . The combined plan later listed three sale sources among the estate's assets: the Aquila equity sale ($23.2 million), equipment sales and the sale of the Minnesota facility .
Final fee awards total $8.68 million across seven firms
On January 21, 2026, the court entered an omnibus order approving final fee applications for seven professionals. The order authorized the liquidating trust to pay the approved amounts, net of prior payments and voluntary reductions Dkt. 913.
Final fee awards in the January 21, 2026 omnibus order
Professional
Fees
Expenses
Dorsey & Whitney LLP
$4,003,766.00
$99,802.62
Brown Rudnick LLP
$1,641,118.25
$32,437.64
Riveron RTS, LLC
$1,370,132.20
$14,538.80
Province, LLC
$1,177,389.50
$2,355.81
Cole Schotz P.C.
$300,872.00
$3,232.64
Nilan Johnson Lewis, P.A.
$18,715.50
$0.00
Stretto, Inc.
$17,069.40
$0.00
Summed, the seven awards come to $8.68 million in fees and expenses. The order also reflects voluntary and court-directed cuts: $150,000 for Dorsey & Whitney, $125,000 for Brown Rudnick, $65,000 for Province and $25,000 for Cole Schotz. Riveron took a $25,000 voluntary reduction and a separate $14,878.85 reduction at the court's request Dkt. 913.
Effectiveness came two years after the petition; the Westfield dispute runs into 2027
Key dates
Date
Event
October 27, 2023
Water Gremlin Company, WG Sub and Water Gremlin Holdings filed chapter 11 in Delaware.
November 1, 2023
Interim DIP order authorized up to $3 million.
November 18, 2023
Final DIP order authorized up to $10 million.
November 20, 2023
Bidding procedures order entered.
December 18, 2023
Aquila auction concluded; Accuma named successful bidder.
January 12, 2024
Court approved an amendment to the DIP loan documents.
February 15, 2024
Sale order entered for U.S. assets to Otter Lake Technologies.
November 27, 2024
Okabe announced an agreement in principle to contribute $14.4 million.
April 1, 2025
Combined plan and disclosure statement filed.
June 6, 2025
Solicitation version filed.
August 1, 2025
Court confirmed the joint chapter 11 plan of liquidation.
October 28, 2025
Plan effective date.
December 4, 2025
Final decree closed the WG Sub and Water Gremlin Holdings cases.
January 21, 2026
Omnibus final fee order entered.
February 13, 2026
$27.25 million TCE tort settlement reported.
August 31, 2026
Liquidating trustee sued Westfield and objected to Claim No. 61.
October 29 and 30, 2026
Both trusts filed post-confirmation reports; the November 5 omnibus hearing was moved.
November 18, 2026
Westfield responded to the claim objection, seeking abstention or a stay.
November 19, 2026
Westfield moved to seal settlement agreements and redact supporting filings.
December 18, 2026
Objection deadline on the sealing motion, 4:00 p.m. ET.
January 7, 2027
Rescheduled omnibus hearing, 11:00 a.m. ET, including the sealing motion.
Upfront fee of 3.0% of the initial amount plus 1.0% of the incremental amount; 2.0% incremental commitment fee; 2.0% exit fee
Milestones
Intrepid retention application within 5 days of the petition; bidding procedures order and final DIP order within 30 days; sale order within 120 days; sale closing and full repayment within 150 days, or 180 days with lender consent
Budget
13-week budget tested weekly; aggregate weekly disbursements may exceed the budget by no more than 15%
Carve-out
Weekly deposits for budgeted professional fees and U.S. Trustee fees; after default, a trigger notice limits the carve-out to amounts already deposited
: Water Gremlin sold to Otter Lake Technologies after filing ... (outside source)