Valves and Controls US's $17 million Weir settlement goes to December 7 evidentiary hearing over committee objection
ElevenFlo ·
Valves and Controls US withdrew its joint asbestos trust plan in July 2026 Dkt. 536 · p. 2 and now asks the court to approve a settlement in which Weir pays at least $17 million for releases of estate claims against Weir, First Reserve and the debtor's directors and officers Dkt. 558 · p. 5. The creditors' committee wants to prosecute the withdrawn plan itself or, failing that, have the case dismissed. It contests the deal at an evidentiary hearing set for December 7–10, 2026 Dkt. 810 · p. 2.
Jump to section
Judge Thomas M. Horan will decide whether the debtor may release the estate's claims against Weir and First Reserve for that payment, or whether the creditors' committee may instead pursue them through the asbestos trust plan the debtor withdrew in July.
The debtor, formerly Atwood & Morrill, is a Weir Group subsidiary with no employees or operations. It filed on July 25, 2025 facing about 2,632 unresolved asbestos claims. Its insurance was exhausted, and it held about $48 million in cash traceable to the $45 million allocated to it when Weir sold its valve business to First Reserve in 2019 Dkt. 2. Besides cash, the estate holds insurance rights and causes of action against Weir and First Reserve over the 2019 sale, and against the debtor's current and former directors and officers Dkt. 2Dkt. 49. The joint plan would have put the Weir and First Reserve claims in an asbestos trust unless they were settled Dkt. 393. The settlement would instead release all of those claims for at least $17 million in cash Dkt. 558 · p. 5.
A joint pretrial order entered November 13, 2026 sets testimony from December 7 to 10 on four contested matters heard together Dkt. 810 · pp. 1, 2. They are the settlement motion, the debtor's request to extend its exclusive right to propose a plan, the committee's August 20 motion to end that exclusivity or dismiss the case, and the committee's motion to stay the settlement proceedings Dkt. 807 · p. 1Dkt. 573 · p. 1. Approval would not end the case. The debtor would still need a new plan. It asks to keep the exclusive right to file one until 30 days after the court's order, with 60 more days to solicit votes Dkt. 562 · p. 1. If exclusivity ends instead, the committee says the withdrawn plan is substantially complete and needs only solicitation and confirmation Dkt. 573 · p. 9.
Weir would pay $17 million for releases covering Weir, First Reserve and the debtor's directors and officers
The debtor filed its Rule 9019 motion on August 1, 2026 Dkt. 558 · p. 1. Under the settlement, Weir would contribute at least $17 million in cash for the benefit of asbestos claimants, plus consideration meant to unlock an insurance settlement. In exchange, the estate would release its causes of action against Weir, First Reserve and their related parties, including the debtor's current and former directors and officers Dkt. 558 · p. 5. The cash rises to $17.5 million if the insurance settlement is not reached on account of Weir's limited indemnity to the insurer. That settlement concerns certain Atwood & Morrill asbestos policies issued by Travelers, the so-called Missing Policies. The debtor and Travelers are still negotiating over them Dkt. 558 · p. 16.
| Term | Weir offer, May 28, 2026 | Settlement Agreement |
|---|---|---|
| Cash from Weir | $12.5 million | $17 million, or $17.5 million if the insurance settlement is not reached on account of Weir's limited indemnity to the insurer |
| Weir's attorneys' fees | Estate pays Weir's fees above $750,000 | Estate pays none of Weir's fees |
| Insurance settlement | Not included | Weir gives a limited indemnity to facilitate a negotiated insurance settlement that would bring additional proceeds to the estate |
The debtor's special committee negotiated the deal. Its sole member is independent director Paul Aronzon, appointed April 15, 2024 Dkt. 558 · p. 2. The court appointed retired bankruptcy judge Shelley C. Chapman as mediator on February 24, 2026 Dkt. 302. Sessions among the debtor, the committee and Weir ran from March 11 to May 11 without a deal, and mediation terminated May 12 Dkt. 558 · p. 13Dkt. 440. According to the debtor, Weir reached out on May 19 proposing to settle the estate's claims. It offered $12.5 million on May 28, up from an earlier $7 million, and eight rounds of counterproposals followed. Principal terms were agreed July 16, and the special committee approved the agreement July 24 Dkt. 558 · pp. 15, 16. The debtor says the committee has never made an offer or counteroffer to settle the estate's claims Dkt. 558 · p. 13.
The debtor argues that the settlement delivers certainty of value and avoids litigation that would deplete the cash left for asbestos claimants. It also argues that the deal satisfies the Martin factors for approving settlements Dkt. 558 · pp. 5, 6. It says the special committee, not Weir, directed the decision to settle. It also says binding Third Circuit precedent in Whittaker and Emoral permits an estate to settle alter ego and successor liability claims Dkt. 788 · p. 11.
The committee wants the withdrawn trust plan, or dismissal, instead of the release
The committee says it opposes the settlement on behalf of nearly all unsecured creditors Dkt. 573 · p. 8. Its objection argues that the releases are non-consensual third-party releases of tort claims. It also argues that the proceeds would pay professional fees and produce no distribution to tort victims Dkt. 784 · p. 68. In its view, an insider settlement must meet the entire fairness standard Dkt. 784 · p. 69, and the debtor cannot carry its burden under Martin Dkt. 784 · p. 88. As an alternative, the committee asks the court to terminate exclusivity so it can prosecute, in substance, the plan the debtor withdrew. If the court declines, it asks for dismissal for cause under section 1112(b) Dkt. 573 · pp. 1, 9.
The debtor and the committee filed that plan jointly on March 6, 2026 and amended it on April 14. The court approved the disclosure statement on April 15 Dkt. 325Dkt. 392Dkt. 393Dkt. 536 · p. 1. It would have created a trust to assume liability for all asbestos claims. The trust would have been funded by insurance rights, insurance proceeds and trust causes of action, with a trust advisory committee selected by the committee. The plan also provided a separate fund for non-asbestos unsecured claims Dkt. 325. A settlement with Weir and First Reserve was optional. Without one, the estate's claims against them would vest in the trust Dkt. 393. The committee traces that structure to a January 14, 2026 letter agreement. In it, the debtor agreed not to release Weir without the committee's prior written consent. If negotiations failed, it agreed to proceed to confirmation with estate claims assigned to a trust run by an independent trustee Dkt. 573 · p. 6.
Confirmation was first set for June 16, then moved to July 9 and July 24 because the trust distribution procedures had not been filed. These procedures are the rules for valuing and paying asbestos claims Dkt. 457Dkt. 491Dkt. 558 · p. 14. The hearing was adjourned indefinitely on July 9, and the debtor withdrew the plan under its section 12.4 on July 18 Dkt. 536 · p. 2. The former co-proponents give different accounts. The debtor says they reached an impasse over the procedures. In its account, the committee's version used unsupported scheduled values, liberal medical and exposure criteria and an amendment provision that made any guardrails illusory Dkt. 558 · p. 14. It says the scheduled values were more than double the median values it had experienced in the tort system Dkt. 788 · p. 11. The debtor gave the committee notice of the impasse, and of its intent to seek approval of the Weir settlement, on July 17. That was the day after principal terms with Weir were agreed Dkt. 558 · pp. 15, 16. The committee says the procedures do not affect the debtor and the dispute was a pretext. It notes that the debtor declared the impasse the day after the court granted its third exclusivity extension. It also says the debtor had been negotiating privately with Weir since mid-May Dkt. 573 · p. 7.
The debtor, its special committee and Weir present first at the December 7–10 hearing
The settlement proponents are the debtor, its special committee and Weir. They present their full case first. After they rest on the issues on which they bear the burden, the committee and other objectors present their cases, followed by rebuttal Dkt. 807 · p. 2Dkt. 810 · p. 2. A party may call only witnesses made available for deposition by November 19. Opening statements are limited to 15 minutes per party Dkt. 810 · p. 2.
| Date | Step |
|---|---|
| November 19, 2026 | Depositions close Dkt. 810 · p. 1. The committee noticed Weir Group PLC's Rule 30(b)(6) deposition for 9:30 a.m. ET by Zoom Dkt. 812 · p. 1 |
| November 20 | Supplemental objections based on discovery taken since the original objection Dkt. 810 · p. 1 |
| November 30, 4:00 p.m. ET | Exchange of preliminary witness and exhibit lists and deposition designations Dkt. 810 · p. 1. Objection deadline on the removal deadline motion Dkt. 814 · p. 1 |
| December 2 | Movants' reply briefs. Witness and exhibit lists filed by 4:00 p.m. ET Dkt. 810 · p. 1 |
| December 4, 4:00 p.m. ET | Deposition counter-designations Dkt. 810 · p. 2 |
| December 7 to 10 | Evidentiary hearing at 1:00 p.m. ET on December 7 and 8 and 10:00 a.m. ET on December 9 and 10 Dkt. 810 · p. 2. The removal deadline motion is also set for December 7 at 1:00 p.m. Dkt. 814 · p. 1 |
Discovery disputes remained open as depositions closed. The notice for Weir's corporate deposition lists as its first topic the documents it calls the Letter Ruling Documents, including how they were prepared and used Dkt. 812 · p. 1. On November 18 the committee served second requests for admission and interrogatories on the debtor Dkt. 815 and filed two letters with the court. The first seeks an order compelling production of documents still withheld or redacted, in unredacted form. They include Weil's invoices for time before its engagement and a meeting attendee list. The parties had met and conferred without agreement Dkt. 818.
That letter relies on the deposition of S. Meck. Meck testified that he reviewed the documents with entities across the Weir enterprise in mind and wanted to understand how bankruptcy might benefit Weir as well as the debtor. He also discussed Weil's response that if A&M's estimated asbestos liability exceeded $65 million, claimants might seek an additional contribution from Weir. He recalled reviewing actuarial analyses but not their projected figures. He said he returned the signed Paul Hastings engagement letter in February 2024 Dkt. 818. Paul Hastings is the debtor's special counsel for evaluating claims against Weir and the debtor's current and former directors and officers Dkt. 49.
The second letter concerns Wes Wadle, who provides general counsel services to the debtor. The committee asks the court to require the debtor to make him available to testify at the hearing. Alternatively, it asks to examine him by video under a subpoena requiring his appearance near Dallas. Wadle submitted a declaration supporting the debtor's response to the committee's exclusivity and stay motions. The debtor's position is that he need not appear because it does not intend to call him and he lives and works near Dallas Dkt. 817. The committee's expert witness, Province, billed September work on claims estimation and forecasting and on preparing an expert report Dkt. 804.
Until the court rules on exclusivity, the debtor relies on Delaware Local Rule 9006-2. Its exclusive periods to file and solicit a plan were set to expire on August 6 and October 7, 2026. It says its August 6 request extends them automatically until the court considers it Dkt. 562 · p. 1. A separate November 17 motion asks to extend the deadline to remove pending civil actions from November 17, 2026 through February 15, 2027. The debtor says it is a party to more than 2,000 such actions Dkt. 814.
Estate cash has fallen to $33.7 million from about $48 million at filing
The estate has no operating revenue. The September 2026 monthly operating report shows ending cash of $33,713,039. Disbursements were $1,141,960 that month and $14,206,550 since the petition Dkt. 758 · p. 2. Approved fees and expenses for the debtor's own bankruptcy professionals reached $5,885,604, of which $5,658,531 had been paid Dkt. 758 · p. 3. The committee puts total professional fees and expenses at $13.62 million as of June 30, 2026. It says litigating the settlement will cost the estate millions more Dkt. 573 · p. 8.
- About $48M
- $46.7M
- $33.7M
Show the numbers
| Date | Cash |
|---|---|
| July 25, 2025 (petition date) | About $48M |
| Start of January 2026 | $46.7M |
| September 30, 2026 | $33.7M |
Source: first-day declaration Dkt. 2; January 2026 Dkt. 297 and September 2026 Dkt. 758 · p. 2 monthly operating reports
The latest monthly statements cover September 2026. Weil's statement requests $1,703,729 in fees for the month. Of that, $1,425,805.50 covers 965 hours on the Weir settlement matter Dkt. 802. On the committee's side, Caplin & Drysdale billed $362,225.50, mostly for litigation Dkt. 800. FTI Consulting requested $357,814 in fees Dkt. 813. Province requested $194,327 Dkt. 804. These amounts can still draw objections and have not been allowed.
Weir's 2019 sale left the debtor with the asbestos claims and $45 million
The debtor traces to Atwood & Morrill Co., founded in Salem, Massachusetts in 1900, which made valves for the power, oil and gas, and petrochemical industries. It stopped using asbestos-containing materials in 1985, and Weir acquired it in 1990. In 2019 Weir sold the debtor's operating assets to First Reserve as part of a $300 million sale. The debtor kept its asbestos liabilities and associated insurance, and $45 million of the proceeds was allocated to it to address legacy claims Dkt. 2. The sale closed July 1, 2019, and the operating business became Trillium Flow Technologies businesswire.com: closed on July 1, 2019 (outside source)trilliumflow.com: Trillium Flow Technologies (outside source). Weir's 2019 annual report disclosed that it gave First Reserve customary indemnification global.weir: 2019 annual report disclosed (outside source).
The debtor lent the $45 million to WHW Group, Inc., a Weir subsidiary, under a promissory note. WHW repaid the principal and interest on July 8, 2025, leaving about $48 million in the debtor's JPMorgan Chase account at filing. The debtor has no employees. A chief restructuring officer from AlixPartners and certain Weir officers manage it Dkt. 2.
Asbestos claims filed against the debtor rose from 373 in 2011 to 892 in 2024. Settlements and defense costs in 2024 totaled about $12.8 million. The debtor's Travelers coverage was exhausted as of May 1, 2025, while negotiations continued over a buyback of certain unlocated Missing Policies from 1968 to 1970. The debtor says an ad hoc asbestos claimants' committee formed in October 2024 represented about 65% of claimants. Its board added an independent director in April 2024 and formed a special committee with authority to evaluate strategic alternatives and investigate affiliate transactions Dkt. 2.
Sources
- Dkt. 2First Day Declaration of Scott M. TandbergFiled Jul 25, 2025Jul 25, 2025
- Dkt. 47Weil Counsel Retention ApplicationFiled Aug 7, 2025Aug 7, 2025
- Dkt. 48Retention of Cole Schotz as Delaware Co-CounselFiled Aug 7, 2025Aug 7, 2025
- Dkt. 49Retention of Paul Hastings as Special CounselFiled Aug 7, 2025Aug 7, 2025
- Dkt. 50CRO Retention ApplicationFiled Aug 7, 2025Aug 7, 2025
- Dkt. 51Retention of Kroll as Administrative AdvisorFiled Aug 7, 2025Aug 7, 2025
- Dkt. 56Notice of Appointment of Creditors' Committee Filed by U.S. Trustee.Filed Aug 14, 2025Aug 14, 2025
- Dkt. 151Order Authorizing UCC Financial Advisor RetentionFiled Oct 14, 2025Oct 14, 2025
- Dkt. 159Order Authorizing Brown Rudnick as UCC Co-CounselFiled Oct 15, 2025Oct 15, 2025
- Dkt. 160UCC Co-Counsel Employment OrderFiled Oct 15, 2025Oct 15, 2025
- Dkt. 180Order Retaining Committee Delaware CounselFiled Nov 4, 2025Nov 4, 2025
- Dkt. 297January 2026 Monthly Operating ReportFiled Feb 23, 2026Feb 23, 2026
- Dkt. 302Order Appointing MediatorFiled Feb 24, 2026Feb 24, 2026
- Dkt. 325Joint Chapter 11 Plan of LiquidationFiled Mar 6, 2026Mar 6, 2026
- Dkt. 364Bar Date OrderFiled Mar 26, 2026Mar 26, 2026
- Dkt. 392Amended Joint Plan of LiquidationFiled Apr 14, 2026Apr 14, 2026
- Dkt. 393Amended Disclosure Statement for Liquidation PlanFiled Apr 14, 2026Apr 14, 2026
- Dkt. 440Mediator's Certificate of CompletionFiled May 15, 2026May 15, 2026
- Dkt. 457Notice of Rescheduled Confirmation Hearing and DeadlinesFiled Jun 1, 2026Jun 1, 2026
- Dkt. 491Notice of Rescheduled Confirmation HearingFiled Jun 17, 2026Jun 17, 2026
- Dkt. 536Plan Withdrawal NoticeFiled Jul 18, 2026Jul 18, 2026
- Dkt. 558Settlement Approval MotionFiled Aug 1, 2026Aug 1, 2026
- Dkt. 562Exclusivity Extension MotionCited at p. 1 · Filed Aug 6, 2026Aug 6, 2026
- Dkt. 573Committee Seeks Exclusivity TerminationFiled Aug 20, 2026Aug 20, 2026
- Dkt. 758September 2026 Operating ReportFiled Oct 21, 2026Oct 21, 2026
- Dkt. 784Committee Settlement ObjectionFiled Oct 30, 2026Oct 30, 2026
- Dkt. 788Debtor’s Omnibus ObjectionCited at p. 11 · Filed Oct 30, 2026Oct 30, 2026
- Dkt. 800Fourteenth Monthly Fee ApplicationFiled Nov 4, 2026Nov 4, 2026
- Dkt. 802Weil Monthly Fee StatementFiled Nov 5, 2026Nov 5, 2026
- Dkt. 804Province Monthly Fee ApplicationFiled Nov 10, 2026Nov 10, 2026
- Dkt. 807Proposed Joint Pretrial OrderFiled Nov 11, 2026Nov 11, 2026
- Dkt. 810Pretrial Schedule and RulesFiled Nov 13, 2026Nov 13, 2026
- Dkt. 812Weir Deposition NoticeCited at p. 1 · Filed Nov 15, 2026Nov 15, 2026
- Dkt. 813FTI September Fee ApplicationFiled Nov 17, 2026Nov 17, 2026
- Dkt. 814Removal Deadline ExtensionCited at p. 1 · Filed Nov 17, 2026Nov 17, 2026
- Dkt. 815Second Discovery Service NoticeFiled Nov 18, 2026Nov 18, 2026
- Dkt. 817Committee Seeks Wadle TestimonyFiled Nov 18, 2026Nov 18, 2026
- Dkt. 818UCC Production RequestFiled Nov 18, 2026Nov 18, 2026
- Webclosed on July 1, 2019businesswire.com · Outside source
- WebTrillium Flow Technologiestrilliumflow.com · Outside source
- Web2019 annual report disclosedglobal.weir · Outside source